Home › Developmental Biology › Ageing in Animals: Why Animals Grow Old and Die

Ageing in Animals: Why Animals Grow Old and Die

ZWZoologistsWorld · Reviewed for scientific accuracy


Ageing
is the slow, uneven decline that visits almost every animal: the body that was once quick and strong becomes slower, weaker and more likely to fail, and the risk of dying rises with every year that passes. A young mouse runs, breeds and heals fast, and an old mouse moves stiffly, breeds poorly and heals slowly, and the difference is not one thing going wrong but many things going wrong together, the muscles, the immune system, the senses and the repair systems all fading at once. The same pattern, with different timing, is found in a dog, a horse, a bird and a human, and the timing is the puzzle: a mayfly lives for a single day, a fruit fly for about seven weeks, a mouse for about three years, a dog for about thirteen, and a tortoise for more than a century, and all of them are built from the same kinds of cells, the same DNA and the same chemistry. Ageing is not an accident, and it is not a disease, and it is not a single process: it is the outcome of damage that accumulates faster than the body can repair it, and of an evolutionary bargain in which the body invests in breeding now and pays for it later, and it is the subject of this article.

The first thing to understand is that ageing is not the same as dying, and it is not the same as lifespan. Lifespan is how long an animal lives, and it is set mostly by the world outside: by predators, by disease, by accidents and by food, and most animals in the wild die long before ageing has a chance to show. Senescence is what happens inside the body as it grows old: the gradual loss of function, the rising risk of death and the falling fertility, and it is the part of ageing that biology can study, because it is a property of the body itself, not of the world around it. A mouse in a laboratory, protected from predators and disease, still ages and dies in about three years, and a tortoise in a zoo, fed and sheltered, still ages, only far more slowly, and the difference between the two, three years against more than a hundred, is the difference in how fast senescence runs in each of them. The question of why it runs fast in one and slow in another is the central question of the whole subject, and the answer touches every part of zoology, from the molecules in a cell to the ecology of a species.

This article covers the whole subject at full depth: what senescence is and how it differs from lifespan, the three survivorship curves that describe how animals die, the enormous range of lifespans across the animal kingdom, from a day to more than five hundred years, and why the range is so wide, the cellular causes of ageing, the DNA damage, the shortening telomeres, the oxidative damage and the stem cells that run down, the three great evolutionary theories that explain why natural selection allows ageing at all, the animals that barely age, the tortoises, the lobsters and the jellyfish that can reverse its own life cycle, the longest lives ever recorded, the calorie restriction experiments and what the model organisms, the worm, the fly and the mouse, have taught us, and the difference between ageing in the wild and ageing in captivity. The science is explained in plain language, and the numbers are given where they matter, because this is a subject where the numbers, how many years, how many divisions, and how many mutations, are the point.

Ageing at a Glance

The simplest way to hold the subject is a single sentence: ageing, or senescence, is the progressive loss of function with time, measured by a rising risk of death and a falling ability to reproduce, and it happens because damage accumulates in the body's cells faster than the body's repair systems can fix it. The damage is of many kinds, and it comes from inside and outside at once: the DNA is nicked and broken by radiation and by the cell's own chemistry, the ends of the chromosomes shorten every time a cell divides, the proteins are damaged by the oxygen the cell burns for energy, and the stem cells that replace worn-out tissue gradually run out. The repair systems are good, and they fix most of the damage, but they are not perfect, and the damage that escapes repair is permanent, and it adds up, year after year, until the tissues work less well, the organs fail more often, and the animal dies of something that a young animal would have survived. Ageing is the bill for living, and every animal pays it, only at different rates.

The second thing to understand is that ageing is a trade, and the trade is written into the animal's genes. A body has a limited amount of energy, and it must divide that energy between keeping itself alive and making the next generation, and the division is a bargain that natural selection has struck differently in different species. An animal that breeds early and often, like a mouse, puts its energy into reproduction, and it spends little on repair, and it ages fast and dies young, and its genes are passed on before the damage matters. An animal that breeds late and slowly, like a tortoise or a whale, puts its energy into repair, and it spends much on keeping its body in good order, and it ages slowly and lives long, and its genes are passed on over decades. The bargain is the reason a mouse and a tortoise, built from the same chemistry, live such different lives: they are not two different kinds of machine, they are the same machine run on different budgets, and the budget is set by the world they live in, by how dangerous it is and by how long an animal can expect to survive in it.

The third thing to understand is that ageing is not inevitable in the way it first appears, because a few animals barely age at all, and one can even reverse its own ageing, and their existence proves that the machinery of ageing can be slowed, stopped or run backwards. A tortoise can live for more than a century with almost no measurable decline, a lobster keeps growing and stays fertile throughout its life, a freshwater hydra shows no increase in mortality with age at all, and the immortal jellyfish can turn itself from an adult back into a juvenile polyp and start again. These exceptions are not miracles: they are animals in which the repair systems keep pace with the damage, or in which the body can rebuild itself from scratch, and they are the reason biologists study ageing with such hope, because if a jellyfish can reset its own clock, the clock itself is not a law of nature, it is a setting, and settings can, in principle, be changed. The rest of this article explains how the clock works, why it runs at different speeds, and what the exceptions teach us about it.

What Senescence Actually Is

Senescence is the word biologists use for ageing, and it is worth defining carefully, because the word carries more meaning than the everyday word ageing does. Ageing, in everyday speech, means getting older, and it includes the harmless changes of age, the grey hair, the slower gait and the longer sleep, and it is a neutral description of time passing. Senescence means something narrower and more specific: the progressive deterioration of function that comes with age, the decline in the body's ability to survive and to reproduce, and it is measured, not by looking at an animal, but by counting, by the rising probability of death at each age and by the falling number of offspring produced at each age. A young animal has a low risk of dying and a high fertility, and an old animal has a high risk of dying and a low fertility, and the change between the two is senescence, and it is the change, not the age itself, that the science of ageing studies.

The distinction matters because not every change with age is senescence, and not every animal that lives long shows it. A tortoise grows larger with age, and a lobster grows larger with age, and the growth is a change, but it is not a deterioration, and the tortoise that is larger is also, in some ways, stronger, because it is harder for a predator to kill. A deer grows larger antlers with age, and a male elephant grows larger and more dominant, and the change is an improvement, not a decline. Senescence is only the part of ageing that makes the animal worse at surviving and reproducing: the weakening muscles, the clouding eyes, the failing kidneys, the immune system that stops recognising invaders, and the fertility that falls. An animal can grow old without senescing, in the strict sense, if its risk of dying does not rise with age, and the few animals that manage it, the hydra, some tortoises and some rockfish, are called negligibly senescent, and they are the exceptions that prove the rule, because every other animal, from the fruit fly to the human, shows the rise.

Senescence is also not a disease, and the difference is worth making, because it changes how the subject is studied. A disease has a cause, a single virus, a single bacterium, a single broken gene, and it can be cured by removing the cause, and it strikes some animals and not others. Senescence has no single cause, and it strikes every animal of a species, and it cannot be cured by removing one thing, because it is the sum of many things going wrong at once, the DNA damage, the shortened telomeres, the damaged proteins and the exhausted stem cells, and the sum is what makes it hard to treat. A disease is an event, and senescence is a process, and the process is the background against which diseases happen: an old animal is more likely to get cancer, more likely to get an infection, and more likely to die of a broken bone, not because ageing is a disease, but because ageing has weakened the systems that would have fought the disease off. The distinction is the reason the science of ageing is the science of many small failures, not of one big one.

Survivorship Curves: Three Ways to Die

The pattern of death in a population can be drawn as a curve, and the curve shows how many individuals of a group born at the same time are still alive at each age, and the shape of the curve is one of the most informative pictures in ecology, because it shows at a glance whether a species dies young or dies old. The curve is called a survivorship curve, and there are three classic shapes, named Type I, Type II and Type III, and almost every animal fits one of them, roughly, and the fit tells the story of its life. A Type I curve is flat for most of life and then drops steeply at the end: most individuals survive to old age, and then most of them die in a short period, and it is the curve of humans and of large mammals, of elephants, whales and horses, and of animals that are well protected as young and that die, when they do, of old age. A Type II curve is a straight diagonal line: the risk of dying is the same at every age, so the same fraction of the survivors dies each year, young and old alike, and it is the curve of many birds, of some reptiles and of animals that live with a steady risk of predation throughout life. A Type III curve drops steeply at the start and then flattens: most individuals die very young, and the few that survive live a long time, and it is the curve of most fish, of frogs, of oysters and of almost every marine invertebrate, and of animals that make thousands of offspring and protect almost none of them.

The three curves are the outcome of three different strategies, and the strategies are the same ones that divide the animal kingdom into the few-offspring and the many-offspring camps. A Type I animal invests heavily in a few young: it makes one or two at a time, it feeds them, protects them and teaches them, and most of them survive, because the parent has paid for their safety, and the parent's investment is the reason the curve stays flat. A Type III animal invests almost nothing in each young: it makes thousands or millions of eggs, and it leaves them to the sea or to the pond, and most of them are eaten within days, and the few that survive are the lucky ones, and the curve falls steeply because the young are unprotected. A Type II animal is in the middle: it makes a moderate number of young, it protects them for a while, and then they face a steady risk, and the curve is a straight line because the risk never changes much. The curves are not just descriptions: they are the reason the lifespans differ, because a Type I animal lives in a world where it can expect to survive to old age, and so it pays to invest in repair, while a Type III animal lives in a world where it will probably die young, and so it pays to invest in reproduction, and to spend little on a body that is unlikely to last.

The curves are also not fixed, and they change with the world the animal lives in, which is why the same species can show a different curve in the wild and in captivity. A mouse in the wild has a curve closer to Type II or even Type III: it is eaten by owls and foxes, it catches diseases, and few mice live to be a year old, and the ones that do are the lucky ones. A mouse in a laboratory, protected from predators and disease, has a curve closer to Type I: most of them survive to two years, and then they die of old age, in a steep drop, and the change shows that the mouse's body is capable of living to old age, and that it is the world, not the body, that kills it young in the wild. A human in a rich country has a Type I curve so flat that almost everyone survives to seventy, and a human in a poor country a century ago had a curve closer to Type II, with deaths spread across life, and the difference is medicine, food and safety, not biology. The survivorship curve is therefore a picture of the world as much as of the animal, and it is the first thing a biologist draws when asking how a species ages, because it shows where the deaths fall, and where they fall decides what natural selection can do about them.


Survivorship typeShape of the curveWhen most deaths happenTypical animals
Type IFlat, then a steep drop late in lifeOld ageHumans, elephants, whales, horses, large primates
Type IIA steady diagonal declineSpread evenly across all agesMany birds, some reptiles, small mammals in the wild
Type IIIA steep drop early, then flatVery young, as eggs or larvaeMost fish, frogs, oysters, corals, marine invertebrates

The Lifespan Spectrum: A Day to Five Centuries

The range of animal lifespans is one of the widest ranges in all of biology, and it is worth laying out in full, because the numbers themselves are the argument. At the short end is the mayfly, whose adult lives for about a day, and in some species for only a few hours, and the adult does not even feed: it emerges, mates, lays its eggs and dies, and its whole adult life is a single day of reproduction, because the larva has done all the growing and all the feeding, in the water, for months or years before it. Next is the worker honeybee, which lives for about six weeks in summer, flying out to forage every day until its wings wear out, and the drone, the male, lives for a few weeks and dies after mating. The fruit fly lives for about forty to fifty days, the house mouse for about two to three years, the dog for about ten to thirteen, the horse for about twenty-five to thirty, and the human for about seventy to eighty, and each step up the ladder is a body that has invested more in repair and less in early reproduction, and each step is a different answer to the same question of how long a body is worth keeping.

At the long end the numbers become startling, and they are worth giving precisely, because they are the proof that ageing can run very slowly indeed. The African elephant lives for about sixty to seventy years, the Galápagos tortoise for a hundred to a hundred and fifty, and the oldest known living land animal, a Seychelles giant tortoise named Jonathan, was born in about 1832 and was still alive in 2026, at about a hundred and ninety-four years old, and he has outlived the steamship, the telephone and the aeroplane. The bowhead whale, a great Arctic whale, lives for more than two hundred years, and the oldest ever aged, from the chemical changes in its eye and from the harpoon fragments found in its blubber, was about two hundred and eleven years old, which means it was born before the American Civil War and was still swimming when the first smartphones were made. The Greenland shark, a slow, cold-water shark of the North Atlantic, is the longest-lived vertebrate ever measured, at an estimated three hundred and ninety-two years, give or take a hundred and twenty, dated from the radiocarbon in its eye lens, which means it was born in about 1620, before the English Civil War, and it grows so slowly, about a centimetre a year, that it does not breed until it is about a hundred and fifty years old. And the longest-lived animal of all is not a vertebrate at all, but a clam, the ocean quahog, and one individual, nicknamed Ming, was aged at five hundred and seven years from the rings in its shell, which means it was born in 1499, in the lifetime of Leonardo da Vinci, and it was still alive when it was dredged up off Iceland in 2006.

The spectrum is not random, and it is not a simple ladder from small to large, although size is part of it, because the pattern has clear rules, and the rules are the subject of the next section. The first rule is that size helps: a large animal is harder for a predator to kill, and it can afford to invest in repair, and so large animals, on average, live longer than small ones, and the elephant outlives the mouse, and the whale outlives the dog. The second rule is that the pattern has striking exceptions, and the exceptions are the most informative part: a bat, which is the size of a mouse, can live for thirty years or more, ten times as long as a mouse, because it can fly away from predators, and a bird, which is the size of a mouse, can live for twenty years, because it can fly too. The third rule is that the cold helps: the Greenland shark and the ocean quahog live in cold water, and cold slows chemistry, and the slow chemistry means slow damage, and slow damage means a long life. The spectrum is a map, and the map shows that lifespan is not a property of the body alone, but of the body in its world, and the world, the predators, the temperature and the food, sets the pace of the clock.


AnimalTypical maximum lifespanWhat sets the pace
Mayfly (adult)About 1 dayAdult does not feed; all growth done as a larva
Worker honeybeeAbout 6 weeks in summerWings wear out; high activity, no repair investment
Fruit flyAbout 40–50 daysShort-lived model organism; rapid reproduction
House mouseAbout 2–3 yearsHigh predation; breeds early, repairs little
DogAbout 10–13 yearsMedium size; larger breeds live shorter than small ones
HumanAbout 70–80 yearsLarge brain, long childhood, heavy repair investment
African elephantAbout 60–70 yearsVery large; few predators as an adult
Galápagos tortoiseAbout 100–150 yearsSlow metabolism, hard shell, negligible senescence
Bowhead whaleMore than 200 yearsVery large, cold water, slow growth, strong DNA repair
Greenland sharkAbout 392 years (estimate)Cold Arctic water; grows about 1 cm a year
Ocean quahog clamAbout 507 yearsCold deep water; very slow metabolism, long dormancy

Why Lifespans Differ So Widely

The first reason lifespans differ is predation, and it is the most powerful reason of all, because an animal that is likely to be eaten tomorrow has no reason to invest in a body that would last for decades. A mouse lives in a world of owls, foxes and cats, and most mice are eaten within their first year, and a mouse that spent its energy on repairing its body for a long life would be wasting it, because it would be eaten before the repair paid off, and natural selection has therefore made the mouse a sprinter: it breeds at six weeks old, it has many litters, and it ages fast, because its genes are passed on before the predators get it. A tortoise lives in a world where almost nothing can eat an adult, because its shell is too hard, and it can expect to live for decades, and a tortoise that spent its energy on breeding and none on repair would be wasting its chance, because it has decades of breeding ahead of it, and natural selection has therefore made the tortoise a marathon runner: it breeds slowly, it grows slowly, and it repairs its body well, because the repair pays off over a century. The rule is simple and it explains most of the spectrum: the safer the animal, the longer it lives, because safety makes repair worth paying for, and danger makes it a waste.

The second reason is flight, and it is the clearest proof that safety, not size, is what matters. A bat is the size of a mouse, and it eats the same food, and it has the same warm-blooded metabolism, and yet a bat can live for thirty years or more, ten times as long as a mouse, and the reason is that a bat can fly, and a mouse cannot, and flying lets the bat escape the predators that kill the mouse, and the escape makes a long life possible, and the bat has evolved the repair systems to match. A bird is the same story: a bird the size of a mouse can live for twenty years, because it can fly away from danger, and a bird that cannot fly, like an ostrich, is large and long-lived for the same reason a tortoise is, because it is too big to be eaten easily. The island rule is the same logic in reverse: animals that evolve on islands without predators, like the tortoises of the Galápagos, live long, because the danger is gone, and animals that evolve under heavy predation live short, because the danger is constant, and the lifespan of a species is, in large part, a measure of how dangerous its world is.

The third reason is temperature and metabolism, and it is the reason the cold-water animals live so long. Chemistry runs slower when it is cold, and the damage that causes ageing, the breaking of DNA, the wearing of proteins and the burning of fuel, all run slower too, and an animal in cold water accumulates damage more slowly than an animal in warm water, and it ages more slowly. The Greenland shark lives in water that is close to freezing, and its metabolism is so slow that it grows about a centimetre a year, and the ocean quahog lives buried in cold mud, and it spends much of its life dormant, barely moving, barely feeding, and barely ageing, and the cold is the reason both of them hold the records. Warm-blooded animals pay a different price: a bird or a mammal burns fuel constantly to keep its body warm, and the burning produces the damage that ages it, and the price of warmth is a faster clock, and it is the reason a warm-blooded animal of a given size lives a shorter life than a cold-blooded animal of the same size, and the reason the longest-lived animals of all are the cold ones, the shark, the clam and the tortoise, basking in the sun but cold-blooded underneath.

The Cellular Causes: Damage Accumulates

At the level of the cell, ageing is the accumulation of damage, and the damage is of four great kinds, and each of them is worth knowing, because each of them is a target of the body's repair systems, and each of them, when the repair fails, is a cause of the decline. The first is damage to the DNA, the instruction book of the cell: the DNA is broken and misspelled thousands of times a day in every cell, by radiation from the sun and the rocks, by the chemicals in food and smoke, and by the cell's own chemistry, and the cell has repair crews that fix most of the breaks, but not all of them, and the breaks that are not fixed become mutations, and the mutations accumulate, and a cell that has accumulated enough of them stops working properly, or becomes cancerous, or dies. The second is damage to the proteins, the machines of the cell: proteins are folded into precise shapes, and the shapes are damaged by heat, by oxidation and by time, and the damaged proteins clump together, and the clumps clog the cell, and the clogging is the reason old cells are full of the brown pigment lipofuscin, the wear-and-tear pigment, and of the tangles and plaques that mark the brains of old animals.

The third kind of damage is to the ends of the chromosomes, the telomeres, and it is covered in its own section below, because it is the most famous of the cellular causes. The fourth is the decline of the stem cells, the cells that replace the worn-out tissue, and it is also covered below, because it is the reason the body stops healing. The four kinds of damage are linked, and they feed each other: the DNA damage makes the cell produce faulty proteins, and the faulty proteins damage the mitochondria, and the damaged mitochondria produce more of the reactive oxygen that damages the DNA, and the cycle accelerates, and the acceleration is the reason ageing speeds up with age, and the reason an old animal declines faster than a young one. The body fights the cycle with its repair systems, and the repair systems are good, but they are not perfect, and the imperfection is the point: a perfect repair system would make the animal immortal, and no animal has one, because perfect repair costs too much energy, and the energy is needed for breeding, and the bargain is the subject of the theories below.

The damage is also not the same in every tissue, and the difference matters, because it is the reason some organs age faster than others. The brain ages badly, because its neurons are never replaced, and a neuron that is damaged stays damaged, and the damage accumulates over a lifetime, and it is the reason memory fades and reactions slow. The skin ages visibly, because it is exposed to the sun, and the sun's ultraviolet light breaks the DNA and the collagen, and the skin wrinkles and thins. The muscles age because their stem cells, the satellite cells, run down, and the muscle cannot repair itself after exercise, and it shrinks. The immune system ages because its stem cells run down too, and it stops recognising invaders, and it starts attacking the body's own tissues, and the infections that a young animal would shrug off become dangerous. The heart ages because its muscle cells are rarely replaced, and the gut ages slowly, because its lining is replaced every few days, and the difference between the tissues is the difference in how fast their stem cells work, and the stem cells are the key to the whole subject.

Telomeres and the Hayflick Limit

Every chromosome ends in a cap called a telomere, a stretch of repeated DNA that protects the end of the chromosome the way the plastic tip protects the end of a shoelace, and the telomere is the most famous of the cellular causes of ageing, because it is a clock that counts the divisions of a cell. The clock works because of a simple mechanical problem: when a cell copies its DNA to divide, the copying machine cannot copy the very end of the strand, and a small piece is lost at every division, about fifty to two hundred base pairs, and the telomere, which is made of thousands of repeated base pairs, absorbs the loss, and it gets shorter with every division, and when it gets too short, the cell stops dividing, and it enters a state called senescence, in which it stays alive but never divides again, and it releases chemicals that inflame the tissue around it. The limit was discovered by Leonard Hayflick in 1961, when he found that human fibroblasts grown in a dish would divide about fifty times and then stop, and the limit is called the Hayflick limit, and it is the number of divisions a normal body cell is allowed before its telomeres run out.

The telomere clock is not the whole story of ageing, and it is important to say so, because the popular idea that telomeres are the cause of ageing is too simple. The clock matters most in the tissues that divide often, the skin, the gut and the blood, where the cells must keep dividing to replace the worn-out ones, and in those tissues the shortening telomeres are a real limit, and the stem cells that keep them going are the ones that matter. It matters less in the tissues that rarely divide, the brain and the heart, where the cells are made once and last a lifetime, and the ageing there is caused by other damage, not by telomere shortening. And the clock can be reset: the germ cells, the sperm and the eggs, make an enzyme called telomerase, which rebuilds the telomeres, and the telomeres of a newborn are long, because the germ cells rebuilt them, and the stem cells of the body make telomerase too, in small amounts, and the cancer cells make it in large amounts, which is one reason a cancer cell can divide forever, and why telomerase is both a repair system and a danger. The telomere is a clock, but it is a clock that can be wound, and the winding is part of the bargain between repair and reproduction.

The evidence that telomeres matter comes from animals that break the clock, and the evidence is worth giving, because it is honest about what telomeres do and do not do. Mice that are bred without telomerase age faster, and their wounds heal more slowly, and their immune systems fail earlier, and they die younger, which shows that telomeres matter. But mice that are bred with longer telomeres do not live much longer, and the long-lived animals, the tortoise and the whale, do not have obviously longer telomeres than the short-lived ones, which shows that telomeres are not the whole story, and that the clock is one of several, and the others matter too. The human disease dyskeratosis congenita, in which telomerase is broken, causes premature ageing, with failing bone marrow, lung disease and early death, and it is the clearest proof in humans that the telomere clock is real. And the disease progeria, in which children age rapidly and die in their teens, is caused not by telomeres but by a broken protein in the nucleus, lamin A, which damages the DNA, and it is the proof that ageing can be driven by other damage too. The telomere is one cause among many, and the many causes are the reason ageing is hard to stop.


Oxidative Damage and the Free Radical Theory

The cell burns fuel to make energy, and the burning is done in the mitochondria, the small power stations of the cell, and the burning is not clean: it throws off sparks, in the form of reactive oxygen species, the free radicals, and the sparks damage whatever they touch, the DNA, the proteins and the fats of the cell's membranes, and the damage is the basis of the free radical theory of ageing, proposed by Denham Harman in 1956. The theory says that ageing is, in large part, the accumulation of the damage done by the cell's own energy production, and that the faster a cell burns fuel, the faster it ages, and the theory was, for decades, the most popular explanation of ageing, because it was simple, because it explained why a fast metabolism seemed to mean a short life, and because it suggested a simple cure, that antioxidants, the vitamins and the chemicals that mop up the free radicals, should slow ageing down. The cure did not work: the large trials of antioxidant vitamins in humans showed no benefit, and in some cases they showed harm, and the mice that were given extra antioxidant enzymes did not live longer, and the theory, in its simple form, is now known to be wrong, or at least incomplete.

The reason the simple theory fails is that the free radicals are not only damage: they are also signals, and the cell uses them to talk to itself. A small burst of free radicals tells the cell to make more of its own defences, and the defences, the enzymes that neutralise the radicals, are made in response to the radicals themselves, and an animal that is exposed to a little more oxidative stress can become more resistant to it, a phenomenon called hormesis, and it is the reason exercise, which produces free radicals, makes the body stronger rather than weaker, and the reason a little stress can be good for a cell. The mitochondria themselves are also part of the story: the DNA of the mitochondria is small and exposed, with no protective histones and poor repair, and it accumulates mutations with age, and the mutated mitochondria produce less energy and more free radicals, and the cycle accelerates, and the acceleration is the reason the energy of an old animal falls, and the reason its muscles weaken. The free radicals are therefore both a cause of ageing and a signal that the cell uses to defend itself, and the balance between the two is the reason the simple cure, swallowing antioxidants, does not work, because it mops up the signal as well as the damage.

The evidence for the oxidative theory is mixed, and the honest account of it is worth giving, because it shows how the science actually works. The animals that live longest do tend to produce fewer free radicals, and their mitochondria leak less, and the naked mole rat, which lives for thirty years, produces as many free radicals as a mouse, but its proteins are more resistant to them, and its repair systems are better, which shows that it is not the number of sparks that matters but the resistance to them. The fruit flies that are bred to make extra antioxidant enzymes do not live longer, and the worms that are bred to make fewer free radicals do not live longer either, and the mice that are given a drug that mimics the antioxidant enzymes do not live longer, and the failures are the reason the theory has been revised. The revised theory says that oxidative damage is one of several causes of ageing, and that it matters most in the mitochondria, and that the damage to the mitochondrial DNA is the part that counts, because the mitochondria are the cell's power, and when the power fails, the cell fails. The free radical is still a villain, but it is one villain among many, and the others, the DNA damage, the telomeres and the stem cells, are equally important.

Stem Cells Run Down

The body is constantly wearing out, and it is constantly being repaired, and the repair is done by stem cells, the cells that can divide to make more of themselves and to make the specialised cells of a tissue, and the stem cells are the reason a cut heals, the reason the gut lining is replaced every few days, and the reason the blood is remade every few months. The stem cells live in niches, small pockets in the tissue where they are sheltered and fed, and they divide slowly, and each division makes one stem cell, to keep the stock, and one specialised cell, to do the work, and the system works well when the animal is young, and it works less well when the animal is old, because the stem cells themselves age, and their niches deteriorate, and the repair slows down. The decline is called stem-cell exhaustion, and it is one of the hallmarks of ageing, and it is the reason an old animal heals slowly, and the reason its blood is made more slowly, and the reason its muscles shrink.

The decline happens for several reasons, and each of them is worth knowing, because each of them is a target for the research that tries to slow ageing. The stem cells accumulate the same damage as every other cell, the DNA breaks, the shortened telomeres and the oxidative damage, and the damaged stem cells divide less well, or they die, or they turn into the wrong kind of cell. The niche around them deteriorates too: the blood vessels that feed them thin out, the signals that tell them when to divide weaken, and the inflammation that comes with age, the chronic low-grade inflammation that biologists call inflammaging, poisons the niche and stops the stem cells from working. And the stem cells themselves change their behaviour: the blood stem cells of an old mouse make more of the myeloid cells, the cells of the innate immune system, and fewer of the lymphoid cells, the cells of the adaptive immune system, and the shift is the reason the old immune system is weaker and more prone to attacking the body's own tissues. The stem cell is not just a repairman: it is a cell that ages, and its ageing is the ageing of the tissue it serves.

The evidence that stem-cell decline matters comes from the experiments that reverse it, and the experiments are among the most striking in the whole science of ageing. When the blood stem cells of a young mouse are transplanted into an old mouse, the old mouse's blood is rejuvenated, and its immune system works better, and when the muscle stem cells of a young mouse are put into an old mouse, the old muscle heals faster, and the muscle grows stronger. When the blood of a young mouse is joined to the blood of an old mouse, in an experiment called parabiosis, the old mouse's brain, liver and muscle all improve, and its stem cells work better, and the young blood carries factors that wake the old stem cells up, and the old blood carries factors that put the young stem cells to sleep, and the experiment shows that the stem cells are not worn out, they are asleep, and they can be woken. The waking is not a cure, and it is not a treatment, and the factors in the blood are still being identified, but the experiment is the proof that stem-cell decline is not a fixed fate, and that the repair system can be revived, and the revival is one of the most active areas of ageing research.

Why Evolution Allows Ageing: Mutation Accumulation

The cellular causes explain how ageing happens, but they do not explain why natural selection allows it, and the why is a separate question, and it is the question that the evolutionary theories of ageing answer. The first of the three great theories is mutation accumulation, proposed by Peter Medawar in 1952, and it starts from a simple observation: natural selection is strong when an animal is young and weak when it is old, because most animals in the wild die young, from predators and disease, and few of them live to be old, and so a gene that harms an animal late in life is barely seen by natural selection, because most animals that carry it are already dead before it acts. A mutation that causes a disease at the age of five will be weeded out, because the animals that carry it die before they breed, and their genes are lost. A mutation that causes a disease at the age of fifty will not be weeded out, because the animals that carry it have already bred and passed it on, and their genes survive, and the mutation accumulates in the population, generation after generation, because there is no force to remove it. The result is that every species carries a load of late-acting harmful mutations, and the mutations are the reason ageing happens: they are the genetic burden that only shows itself late in life, when selection can no longer see it.

The theory is elegant, and it makes a prediction that has been tested, and the prediction is worth giving, because it is the kind of test that makes a theory convincing. The prediction is that if a population is kept in a safe environment, where the animals live long enough for the late-acting mutations to show themselves, the mutations will be exposed to selection, and the population will evolve to live longer, because the animals that carry the harmful mutations will now die before they breed, and their genes will be lost. The test was done in fruit flies, in the laboratory of Michael Rose, in the 1980s: the flies were bred so that only the oldest flies were allowed to breed, and the flies that lived longest left the most descendants, and over many generations the flies evolved to live much longer, doubling their lifespan, and the experiment showed that the genetic variation for a longer life was already there, in the population, hidden, because selection had never acted on it, and that the late-acting mutations were the reason the flies aged as fast as they did. The experiment is the strongest proof of the mutation accumulation theory, and it is the reason the theory is still taught, seventy years after Medawar proposed it.

The theory also explains why ageing is different in different species, and the explanation is the same logic applied to different worlds. A mouse lives in a dangerous world, and most mice die young, and selection is weak after the first year, and the late-acting mutations accumulate, and the mouse ages fast, because there is no force to stop it. A tortoise lives in a safe world, and most tortoises live to be old, and selection stays strong for decades, and the late-acting mutations are weeded out, and the tortoise ages slowly, because the force that removes the mutations is still working. The theory is therefore not just a theory of why ageing happens: it is a theory of why it happens at different speeds, and the speed is set by the danger of the world, and the danger is set by the predators, the disease and the food, and the whole subject comes back, again, to the world the animal lives in. The mutation accumulation theory is the foundation, and the other two theories are built on it.

Antagonistic Pleiotropy: Good Early, Bad Late

The second great theory is antagonistic pleiotropy, proposed by George Williams in 1957, and it is subtler than the first, because it says that some of the genes that cause ageing are not accidents that selection failed to remove, but genes that selection actively favoured, because they help the animal when it is young, even though they harm it when it is old. A gene is pleiotropic if it has more than one effect, and it is antagonistic if the effects pull in opposite directions, one good and one bad, and the theory says that a gene that gives an animal more offspring when it is young will be favoured by selection, even if the same gene kills the animal when it is old, because the young benefit is seen by selection and the old harm is not, because most animals die before the harm shows itself. The gene is a bargain, and the bargain is struck in favour of the young, because the young are the ones that breed, and the old are the ones that do not.

The examples are the proof, and they are worth giving, because they show the bargain working in real animals. The gene p53 is a tumour suppressor: it stops cells with damaged DNA from dividing, and it prevents cancer, and it is one of the most important genes in the body, and it is favoured by selection because it keeps young animals alive. But the same gene, by stopping cells from dividing, also stops the stem cells from replacing worn-out tissue, and it accelerates the decline of the tissues, and a mouse that is bred with extra copies of p53 gets less cancer but ages faster, and a mouse that is bred with less p53 gets more cancer but ages more slowly, and the trade is the proof of the theory: the gene that protects the young harms the old, and selection has chosen the protection, because the young matter more. Testosterone is another example: it makes a male strong, competitive and fertile when he is young, and it is favoured for that reason, but it also suppresses the immune system and damages the heart, and it shortens the life of the male, and the males of most species live shorter lives than the females, in part because of it. The calcium that makes bones strong when an animal is young is deposited in the arteries when it is old, and the arteries harden, and the same mineral that built the skeleton breaks the circulation, and the bargain is the same.

The theory also explains a pattern that the first theory cannot, which is why ageing is so consistent across a species, and why it looks like a programme rather than an accident. If ageing were only the accumulation of random mutations, it would be different in every individual, and it would be ragged and unpredictable, and in fact it is fairly regular, and the same organs fail in the same order, and the same diseases appear at the same ages, and the regularity suggests that some of the genes that cause ageing are the same in every individual, because they were favoured, not because they were missed. The antagonistic genes are the same in every member of the species, because selection put them there, and they act in the same way in every individual, and the regularity of ageing is the regularity of the bargain. The theory is therefore the complement of the first: the first says that selection is too weak to remove the bad genes, and the second says that selection is strong enough to favour them, because they help the young, and together the two theories explain why ageing is both universal and regular, and why it is so hard to stop, because the genes that cause it are the genes that made the animal successful in the first place.

The Disposable Soma: Energy Is Limited

The third great theory is the disposable soma theory, proposed by Thomas Kirkwood in 1977, and it is the most practical of the three, because it is about energy, and energy is the currency that every animal spends. The theory divides the body into two parts, the germline and the soma, and the germline is the line of cells that makes the sperm and the eggs, and the soma is everything else, the body itself, the muscles, the bones, the brain and the gut, and the theory says that the germline is maintained with great care, because it must last forever, passed from one generation to the next, and the soma is maintained only as well as it needs to be, because it is disposable, and it only needs to last long enough for the animal to breed, and after that it can be allowed to fall apart. The body is therefore a vehicle for the germline, and the vehicle is built to last only as long as the journey takes, and the journey is the time it takes to breed, and the vehicle is not built to last longer, because building it to last longer would cost energy that could have been spent on making more offspring.

The evidence for the theory is in the difference between the germline and the soma, and the difference is stark, and it is worth giving in detail, because it is the clearest proof of the bargain. The germ cells make telomerase, and they rebuild their telomeres, and their DNA is repaired with great care, and the mutations in the germline are rare, because the germline must be passed on clean. The body cells make little telomerase, and their telomeres shorten, and their DNA is repaired less carefully, and the mutations accumulate, because the body does not need to be clean, it only needs to last until breeding is done. The difference is the reason a child is born young, with long telomeres and clean DNA, even though its parents are old, because the germline was maintained while the soma aged, and the child starts again, with a fresh body, and the soma of the parent is discarded, and the germline goes on. The theory is the reason the body ages and the lineage does not, and the reason a species can live forever while every individual in it dies.

The theory also makes a prediction about reproduction and lifespan, and the prediction has been tested in many animals, and it is the most practical of all the predictions in the science of ageing. The prediction is that an animal that spends more energy on breeding will spend less on repair, and it will age faster, and an animal that spends less on breeding will spend more on repair, and it will age more slowly, and the trade is visible in the experiments. The fruit flies that are bred to breed late live longer, because they spend less on early reproduction and more on repair, and the worms that are sterilised live longer, because the energy that would have gone into making eggs goes into maintaining the body, and the male sheep that are castrated live longer than the intact males, because the testosterone that drives breeding also drives the damage. The most striking example is the honeybee: the queen and the worker have the same genes, but the queen lives for two to five years and the worker for about six weeks, and the difference is the food, because the queen is fed royal jelly and the worker is not, and the royal jelly switches on the genes for repair and switches off the genes for early reproduction, and the same genome, on a different diet, lives fifty times as long. The disposable soma is the reason, and the honeybee is the proof.


The Rate-of-Living Idea and Why It Fails

There is an older idea about ageing that is worth a section of its own, not because it is right, but because it is instructive, and because it is still widely believed, and the idea is the rate-of-living theory, proposed by Raymond Pearl in 1928. The theory says that every animal is given a fixed amount of living, a fixed number of heartbeats or a fixed amount of energy to spend, and that it spends the allowance faster if it lives faster, and that a fast metabolism therefore means a short life, and a slow metabolism means a long life, and the theory seemed to fit, because a mouse, which has a fast heartbeat and a fast metabolism, lives for three years, and an elephant, which has a slow heartbeat and a slow metabolism, lives for seventy, and a tortoise, which is slower still, lives for a century. The theory was simple, and it was elegant, and it suggested that the way to live long was to live slowly, to eat little, to move little and to keep the heart slow, and it was believed for decades, and it is still repeated in popular books about ageing.

The theory fails, and the failures are worth giving, because they show what a good theory must survive. The first failure is the bat: a bat has a heart that beats hundreds of times a minute when it flies, and a metabolism as fast as a mouse's, and yet it lives for thirty years, ten times as long as a mouse, and the bat breaks the rule, because it is small and fast and long-lived at once. The second failure is the bird: a bird has a body temperature higher than a mammal's, and a metabolism faster than a mammal's, and it lives longer than a mammal of the same size, and the bird breaks the rule in the other direction, because it is hot and fast and long-lived. The third failure is the experiment: the mice that are made to exercise, which raises their metabolism and their heartbeat, do not live shorter lives, and the mice that are kept cold, which slows their metabolism, do not live much longer, and the fruit flies that are kept in the cold, which slows their metabolism dramatically, do live longer, but they also move less and eat less, and the cold changes many things at once, and the experiment does not prove the theory. The rate of living is a correlation, not a cause, and the cause is the danger of the world, not the speed of the metabolism, and the bat and the bird are the proof, because they are fast and safe, and they live long.

The theory is not wholly wrong, and the part of it that survives is worth keeping, because it points to the real connection between metabolism and ageing. The connection is not the rate at which the fuel is burned, but the amount of damage the burning does, and the amount of repair the body does in response, and the animals that live long are not the ones that burn slowly, but the ones whose mitochondria leak less, whose proteins resist damage better, and whose repair systems are stronger. The naked mole rat burns fuel as fast as a mouse, but it lives for thirty years, because its proteins are more resistant to oxidative damage, and its DNA repair is better, and its cells are less likely to become cancerous, and the mole rat is the proof that the damage matters more than the rate. The rate-of-living theory is therefore a first approximation, and the better theory is the disposable soma, which says that the body spends its energy where it pays, and the spending, not the speed, is what sets the lifespan.

TheoryProposed byCore ideaKey evidence
Mutation accumulationPeter Medawar, 1952Selection weakens with age, so late-acting harmful mutations are never removedFlies bred to breed late evolve longer lives; the genetic variation was already there
Antagonistic pleiotropyGeorge Williams, 1957Genes that help early in life are favoured even if they harm late in lifeExtra p53 cuts cancer but speeds ageing; testosterone boosts fertility but shortens life
Disposable somaThomas Kirkwood, 1977Energy is limited; the germline is maintained, the body is allowed to fall apartQueen bees live 50 times longer than workers on the same genes; sterilised worms live longer
Rate of livingRaymond Pearl, 1928A fixed lifetime energy budget; faster living means a shorter lifeFails on bats and birds, which are fast and long-lived; a correlation, not a cause

Negligible Senescence: Animals That Barely Age

A few animals show almost no increase in mortality with age, and almost no decline in fertility, and they are called negligibly senescent, and they are the most important animals in the science of ageing, because they prove that senescence is not a law of nature. The freshwater hydra is the clearest case: it is a tiny freshwater polyp, a relative of the jellyfish, and it reproduces by budding, and a study that followed thousands of hydras for years found no increase in their risk of dying with age, and no decline in their fertility, and the hydra, in the laboratory, does not seem to age at all. The reason is that the hydra's body is constantly renewed: its stem cells divide continuously, and the old cells are pushed out and replaced, and the whole body is rebuilt every few weeks, and the damage never accumulates, because the damaged cells are discarded and new ones take their place. The hydra is a body that is always young, because it is always being rebuilt, and it is the proof that a body that can rebuild itself does not need to age.

The tortoise is a slower, larger version of the same story, and it is worth giving in detail, because the tortoise is the animal that most people think of when they think of a long life. A Galápagos tortoise grows throughout its life, and it stays fertile throughout its life, and a study of tortoises in zoos found that their risk of dying barely rises with age, and their fertility barely falls, and the tortoise, like the hydra, is close to negligibly senescent, and the reason is the same, in a slower form: the tortoise repairs its DNA well, it makes telomerase in its tissues, it has strong defences against cancer, and it lives in a shell that keeps it safe, and the safety means that selection has kept working on it for a century, weeding out the late-acting mutations that would have made it age. The tortoise is not immortal, and it does die, of disease and of accidents, and its organs do decline, slowly, but the decline is so slow that it is hard to measure, and the tortoise is the closest a large animal comes to not ageing at all.

The lobster is the most famous of the negligibly senescent animals, and it is also the most misunderstood, and the misunderstanding is worth correcting, because it is repeated in almost every popular article about ageing. The lobster does keep growing throughout its life, and it does stay fertile throughout its life, and a large female lobster carries more eggs than a small one, so the oldest lobsters are also the most fertile, which is the opposite of senescence, and the lobster's telomerase stays active in its tissues, and its telomeres do not shorten with age. But the lobster is not immortal, and it does age, in a real sense: it must moult to grow, and the moulting becomes harder and more dangerous as it gets larger, and the energy it costs grows, and a large lobster can die in its moult, trapped in its old shell, and the risk of dying in a moult rises with size, and the lobsters that die are the largest and the oldest. The lobster is therefore not an animal that does not age: it is an animal that ages differently, by growing instead of declining, and the growth itself becomes the limit, and the limit is the moult, and the moult is the price of the lobster's way of life. The honest account is that the lobster shows negligible senescence in its fertility and its telomeres, and real senescence in its moulting, and the two together are the reason it can live for fifty to a hundred years, and no longer.

The Immortal Jellyfish: Ageing in Reverse

The most extraordinary animal in the science of ageing is a jellyfish smaller than a fingernail, Turritopsis dohrnii, the immortal jellyfish, and it is extraordinary because it can do what no other animal can: it can reverse its own life cycle, turning itself from an adult back into a juvenile, and starting again. The jellyfish has the usual two-stage life: a polyp, which is a small stalk attached to the sea floor, and a medusa, which is the free-swimming jellyfish, and the polyp buds off medusae, and the medusae breed, and the medusae die, and the cycle goes on. But when a Turritopsis medusa is stressed, by starvation, by injury, by a change in temperature or by old age, it does something no other jellyfish does: it settles on the sea floor, and its bell collapses, and its tentacles are absorbed, and its cells change their type, in a process called transdifferentiation, and it becomes a polyp again, and the polyp buds off new medusae, and the cycle starts again, and the jellyfish has, in effect, gone back in time. The process has been observed in the laboratory many times, and a single individual has been made to reverse itself again and again, and the jellyfish is, in the laboratory, potentially immortal, because it can reset its clock whenever it needs to.

The reversal is not magic, and it is worth explaining, because the explanation shows what ageing is at the cellular level. The medusa's cells are specialised: the muscle cells contract, the nerve cells signal, the stinging cells sting, and each cell has a job, and the job is fixed by the genes that are switched on in it. When the medusa reverses, the cells switch their genes off and on again, and a muscle cell becomes a different kind of cell, and the whole body is reorganised, and the reorganisation is the same process that a stem cell uses to become a specialised cell, run in reverse, and the jellyfish is able to run it in reverse because its cells have kept the ability to change, an ability that most animals lose as they develop. The reversal is not a repair: it is a rebuild, and the rebuild discards the damaged cells and makes new ones, and the damage that had accumulated in the medusa is gone, because the cells that carried it are gone, and the new polyp is young. The jellyfish is the proof that the clock can be reset, and that the reset is a matter of the cells remembering how to change, and the remembering is the reason the jellyfish is studied so intensely, because if a jellyfish can do it, the machinery for doing it exists in nature, and the machinery is the target of the research.

The jellyfish is not truly immortal, and the qualification matters, because the word immortal is misleading, and it is the reason the animal is so often misunderstood. In the sea, a Turritopsis medusa is eaten by fish, and it is killed by disease, and it is washed up on beaches, and it dies, like every other jellyfish, and its ability to reverse itself does not save it from a predator, and it does not save it from a storm, and the reversal is a defence against stress and old age, not against being eaten. The jellyfish is immortal only in the sense that it does not have to die of old age, and that it can, in principle, keep reversing itself forever, in a laboratory, where nothing eats it, and the immortality is a laboratory immortality, not a wild one. The distinction is the same as the distinction between lifespan and senescence: the jellyfish has beaten senescence, but it has not beaten death, and no animal has, because death in the wild is mostly caused by the world outside, not by the clock inside, and the clock is only one of the ways to die.


The Longest Lives in the Animal Kingdom

The record holders deserve a section of their own, because each of them holds its record for a different reason, and the reasons together are a summary of the whole subject. The Greenland shark holds the record for the longest-lived vertebrate, at an estimated three hundred and ninety-two years, and it holds it because it lives in water close to freezing, and its metabolism is extremely slow, and it grows about a centimetre a year, and it does not breed until it is about a hundred and fifty years old, and the slow life is the reason the damage accumulates slowly, and the shark is the proof that cold and slowness are the simplest way to live long. The bowhead whale holds the record for the longest-lived mammal, at more than two hundred years, and it holds it because it is very large, and it lives in cold Arctic water, and it has exceptionally good DNA repair, and a study of its genome found that it carries extra copies of the genes that repair DNA and that control cell division, and the whale is the proof that repair, not just slowness, can make a long life. The ocean quahog holds the record for the longest-lived animal of all, at five hundred and seven years, and it holds it because it lives buried in cold mud, and it spends much of its life dormant, barely feeding and barely moving, and its metabolism is so slow that it is almost stopped, and the clam is the proof that doing almost nothing, for a very long time, is the surest way to live long.

The tortoise holds the record for the longest-lived land animal, at about a hundred and ninety-four years for Jonathan, the Seychelles giant tortoise, and it holds it because it is armoured, and it is slow, and it has strong DNA repair and strong defences against cancer, and a study of the giant tortoise genome found extra copies of the genes that suppress tumours and repair DNA, and the tortoise is the proof that a large body, which should mean more cells and more chances for cancer, can be protected by better repair. The naked mole rat holds a different kind of record: it is the size of a mouse, and it lives for about thirty years, ten times as long as a mouse, and it holds its record because it is resistant to cancer, because its cells stop dividing when they are crowded, because its proteins resist oxidative damage, and because it lives underground, in a burrow, where it is safe from predators, and the mole rat is the proof that a small animal can live long if it is safe and well repaired. The bowhead, the tortoise and the mole rat all point to the same conclusion: the long-lived animals are the ones that repair their DNA well, and that resist cancer, and that live in safe places, and the repair is the common thread.

The records also have a limit, and the limit is worth stating, because it is the reason the longest life is about five hundred years and not five thousand. The limit is set by the damage that cannot be repaired, and by the energy that repair costs, and by the fact that every repair system is itself made of proteins and DNA that can be damaged, and the repair of the repair systems is itself a cost, and the costs add up. A clam can live for five hundred years because it does almost nothing, and a shark can live for four hundred because it lives in the cold, and a whale can live for two hundred because it is large and well repaired, but none of them can live forever, because the damage, however slow, still accumulates, and the repair, however good, still fails, and the failure is the reason the records stop where they do. The longest life is not a fixed number, and a new record may be found, in a deeper ocean or a colder sea, but the limit is real, and it is set by the chemistry of damage and repair, and the chemistry is the same in every animal.

Calorie Restriction and the Model Organisms

The most reliable way ever found to extend lifespan in the laboratory is also the simplest: feed the animal less, and it lives longer, and the effect is called calorie restriction, and it has been shown in yeast, in worms, in flies, in fish and in mice, and it is the most reproduced result in the whole science of ageing. The first demonstration was in rats, in 1935, when Clive McCay found that rats fed about two-thirds of the normal amount of food lived about fifty percent longer, and grew more slowly, and stayed healthier for longer, and the result has been repeated in dozens of laboratories since, and the extension is large: the worms live twice as long, the flies live about a third longer, and the mice live about a third longer, and the animals are not just longer-lived, they are healthier, with less cancer, less diabetes and stronger immune systems, and the calorie restriction is the closest thing the science has to a proven way to slow ageing.

The model organisms are the reason the effect is understood as well as it is, and each of them has taught a different lesson. The worm, Caenorhabditis elegans, is a tiny nematode that lives for about two to three weeks, and it is the simplest of the models, with only about a thousand cells, and a gene in it called daf-2, which controls the insulin signalling pathway, was found by Cynthia Kenyon in 1993 to double the worm's lifespan when it was mutated, and the doubling was the first proof that a single gene could control how long an animal lives, and the pathway, insulin and insulin-like growth factor signalling, is the same pathway in humans, and the discovery is the reason the worm is the most studied animal in ageing research. The fruit fly lives for about forty to fifty days, and it has taught that the effect of calorie restriction depends on the protein in the diet, not only on the calories, and that the flies that eat less protein live longer, and the mouse lives for about two to three years, and it has taught that the effect works in a mammal, and that it works even when it is started late in life, and the shortest-lived vertebrate model, the turquoise killifish, lives for only four to six months, and it is the newest of the models, and it is the one that lets researchers test a treatment in a vertebrate in less than a year.

The mechanism of calorie restriction is now partly understood, and the understanding is worth giving, because it shows how the body's sensing of food controls its repair. When food is scarce, the body senses the shortage through the insulin pathway and through a protein called mTOR, which is the master switch for growth, and the switch is turned down, and the body stops growing and starts repairing, and it makes more of the enzymes that clean up damaged proteins, and it recycles its own worn-out parts, in a process called autophagy, and the recycling is the reason the restricted animal stays healthy: it is cleaning house, and the cleaning is what the well-fed animal does not do, because it is too busy growing. The drug rapamycin, which turns down mTOR directly, extends the lifespan of mice even when it is started late in life, in old mice, and the extension is about ten percent, and it is the proof that the pathway is the mechanism, and that a drug can do what the diet does, at least in part. The sirtuins, a family of proteins that are switched on by calorie restriction, were once thought to be the key, and the story of resveratrol, the chemical in red wine that was claimed to activate them, was oversold, and the resveratrol did not extend the lifespan of normal mice, and the overselling is a caution, and the honest account is that the mechanism is real, and it is the insulin and mTOR pathways, and the sirtuins are a part of it, but not the whole of it.

What the Model Organisms Taught Us

The model organisms have taught three great lessons, and the lessons are the foundation of the modern science of ageing. The first lesson is that lifespan is not fixed, and it can be changed, by a single gene, by a diet, or by a drug, and the change can be large: the worm that lives twice as long, the fly that lives a third longer, and the mouse that lives a third longer are the proof, and the proof is the reason the science is optimistic, because if lifespan can be doubled in a worm, it can, in principle, be changed in other animals too. The second lesson is that the pathways that control lifespan are the same in the worm, the fly, the mouse and the human, and the insulin pathway, the mTOR pathway and the pathways that sense nutrients are conserved across a billion years of evolution, and the conservation is the reason a discovery in a worm matters for a human, and the reason the worm is not a curiosity but a model. The third lesson is that the extension of lifespan is usually an extension of health, and the long-lived animals are not just older, they are healthier for longer, with less cancer and less frailty, and the health is the point, because a longer life that is spent sick is not a prize, and the science aims at healthspan, the years of healthy life, not only at lifespan.

The lessons come with honest limits, and the limits are worth stating, because the science is often oversold. The first limit is that the effects are smaller in the animals that already live long, and the calorie restriction that doubles the life of a worm extends the life of a mouse by a third, and it may extend the life of a primate by much less, and the two great studies of calorie restriction in rhesus monkeys disagreed: the Wisconsin study found that the restricted monkeys lived longer, and the National Institute on Aging study found that they were healthier but did not live longer, and the difference was in the diets, because the Wisconsin monkeys ate more, and were fatter, and the restriction helped them more, and the lesson is that the effect depends on what the animal was eating before, and that a well-fed animal gains more than an already lean one. The second limit is that the drugs that work in mice have not been shown to work in humans, and rapamycin extends the life of a mouse but it also suppresses the immune system, and it is not a treatment for ageing in people, and the metformin, the diabetes drug that is being tested for ageing, has not been shown to extend human lifespan, and the testing is still going on. The third limit is that the model organisms are short-lived, and the short life is what makes them useful, because an experiment takes weeks instead of decades, but it is also what makes them different, because a worm that lives for three weeks is not a small human, and the pathways are the same, but the details are not, and the translation from worm to human is the hardest part of the science.

The model organisms have also taught a quieter lesson, which is that ageing is not a single process, and that there is no single switch to turn it off. The worm that lives twice as long does so because one pathway is changed, and the fly that lives longer does so because another is changed, and the mouse that lives longer does so because a third is changed, and the changes add up, but they do not add up to immortality, and the longest-lived worm is still a worm that dies in weeks, and the longest-lived mouse is still a mouse that dies in years, and the limits are set by the body, not by the pathway. The science is therefore a science of slowing, not of stopping, and the slowing is real, and it is large, and it is the best news in the field, but it is not a cure, and anyone who promises a cure is selling something, and the honest account is that the model organisms have shown that ageing can be slowed, and that health can be extended, and that the slowing is the goal, and the goal is worth pursuing, because a slower clock is a longer healthy life.

Ageing in the Wild Versus in Captivity

Most animals in the wild never show senescence, and the reason is simple: they die first, of something else, and the something else is usually a predator, a disease, a famine or an accident, and the death comes before the clock has had time to run down. A wild mouse is eaten by an owl within its first year, and a wild rabbit is taken by a fox, and a wild fish is eaten by a larger fish, and the ones that survive are the lucky ones, and they are few, and the population is mostly young, and the old are rare, because the world kills them before ageing can. The biologists who study wild animals have therefore had to look hard to find senescence in the wild, and for a long time they thought it did not happen there, and that ageing was an artefact of the laboratory, a thing that only showed itself when an animal was protected from the world, and the thought was wrong, but it was understandable, because the wild hides its old animals, by killing them.

The wild does show senescence, when it is looked for carefully, and the evidence is worth giving, because it is the proof that ageing is real in nature, not only in a cage. The Soay sheep of St Kilda, a wild population that has been studied for decades, show a clear rise in mortality with age, and a clear fall in fertility, and the old ewes die in the winters, when the food is scarce, because their teeth are worn and they cannot eat enough, and the wear of the teeth is senescence, and it kills them. The red deer of the Isle of Rum show the same pattern, and the old stags lose their antlers and their strength, and they are driven off by younger stags, and they die, and the old hinds breed less often, and their calves are smaller, and the decline is senescence. The great tits of Wytham Wood show a rise in mortality with age, and a fall in the number of chicks raised, and the old birds are less able to find food in winter, and they die, and the pattern is the same. The wild animals do age, and the ageing shows itself in the hard seasons, when the food is scarce and the weather is bad, and the old animals, who could survive in a good season, cannot survive in a bad one, and the bad season is the test that reveals the decline.

Captivity changes the picture, and the change is dramatic, and it is the reason the zoo is the place where ageing is most visible. A captive animal is fed, sheltered and protected from predators, and it lives far longer than its wild counterpart, and it shows the senescence that the wild would have hidden, and the captive elephant lives to seventy, and the captive lion to twenty, and the captive parrot to eighty, and the old animals develop the diseases of old age, the arthritis, the cataracts, the kidney failure and the cancer, and the diseases are the same as the diseases of old humans, and the zoo is a window into what ageing does when the world stops killing the animal first. The difference between the wild and the captive is therefore not a difference in the body, but a difference in the world, and the body ages at the same rate in both, and the world decides whether the ageing is seen, and the seeing is the reason the science of ageing was built in the laboratory, where the animals are protected, and where the clock can be watched running down.

Can Ageing Be Slowed?

The question that every reader asks is whether ageing can be slowed, and the honest answer is that it can, in the laboratory, and it cannot yet, in a proven way, in a human, and the two halves of the answer are both true, and both need to be said. In the laboratory, ageing can be slowed by calorie restriction, by mutations in the insulin pathway, by drugs that turn down mTOR, and by the transplant of young stem cells, and the slowing is real, and it is large, and it is reproduced in many laboratories, and it is the reason the science is hopeful. In a human, none of these has been proven to extend life, and the calorie restriction that works in a mouse has not been shown to work in a person, and the drugs that work in a mouse have side effects that make them unsuitable as treatments, and the stem cells that rejuvenate a mouse have not been shown to rejuvenate a person, and the gap between the mouse and the human is the hardest gap in the science, because a mouse lives for three years and a human for eighty, and an experiment that takes a lifetime in a human takes a few months in a mouse.

What is known to help, in humans, is not a drug and not a diet, but the ordinary things that keep the body in good order, and the list is short and unglamorous, and it is worth giving, because it is the only advice that the science can honestly support. Exercise helps, because it makes the muscles stronger, and the heart stronger, and the bones denser, and it wakes the stem cells up, and the animals that exercise live longer and healthier lives, and the humans that exercise do too. Not smoking helps, because the smoke damages the DNA and the lungs, and the damage is the same damage that ages the body, and the smoker ages faster, in the skin, the lungs and the arteries, and the non-smoker ages more slowly. Eating well helps, not because any single food is a cure, but because a diet that is not excessive, and that is rich in the foods that do not damage the body, keeps the weight down and the blood sugar steady, and the steady blood sugar is the reason the insulin pathway, the same pathway that controls lifespan in the worm, stays quiet. And the social life helps, because the animals that are isolated age faster, and the humans that are lonely die earlier, and the reason is not fully understood, but the stress of isolation raises the inflammation that ages the body, and the company lowers it.

The future of the science is in the repair systems, and the most promising work is the work that wakes the stem cells up, and that clears the senescent cells, the cells that have stopped dividing and that poison the tissue around them. The senescent cells are a target because they are the cells that have reached the Hayflick limit, and they stay alive, and they release chemicals that inflame the tissue, and the inflammation ages the tissue, and the drugs that kill them, called senolytics, have been shown to improve the health of old mice, and to extend their lifespan by a little, and the trials in humans are beginning, and the results are not yet known. The reprogramming of cells, the turning of an old cell back into a stem cell, has been shown to rejuvenate the tissues of old mice, and the partial reprogramming, which turns the clock back a little without turning the cell into a stem cell, has restored the sight of old mice, and the work is the most exciting in the field, and it is also the most dangerous, because a cell that is reprogrammed too far can become cancerous, and the safety is not yet proven. The science is therefore at a hopeful and a cautious place, and the hope is real, and the caution is real too, and the honest answer to the question is that ageing can be slowed, in animals, and that the slowing in humans is the work of the next decades.

Key Takeaways

  • Senescence is the progressive loss of function with age, measured by rising mortality and falling fertility, and it is different from lifespan, which is set mostly by the world outside.
  • Survivorship curves come in three shapes: Type I, where most survive to old age; Type II, where the risk is the same at every age; and Type III, where most die very young.
  • Lifespans range from about a day in the mayfly to about 507 years in the ocean quahog clam, and the range is set by safety, size, temperature and repair.
  • The safer an animal is from predators, the longer it lives, because safety makes investment in repair worth paying for, and flight is the reason bats and birds outlive mice of the same size.
  • At the cellular level, ageing is damage that accumulates faster than repair: DNA damage, shortened telomeres, oxidative damage and stem cells that run down.
  • Telomeres shorten by about 50 to 200 base pairs at every cell division, and when they run out the cell stops dividing, at the Hayflick limit of about fifty divisions.
  • Free radicals damage the cell, but they are also signals, and the simple idea that swallowing antioxidants slows ageing has not worked in trials.
  • Stem cells decline with age, and their niches deteriorate, and the decline is the reason old animals heal slowly, but young blood and young stem cells can wake old stem cells up again.
  • Mutation accumulation says selection weakens with age, so late-acting harmful mutations are never removed, and flies bred to breed late evolve longer lives.
  • Antagonistic pleiotropy says genes that help early in life are favoured even if they harm late in life, and p53 and testosterone are the classic examples.
  • The disposable soma theory says energy is limited, the germline is maintained and the body is allowed to fall apart, and the queen bee, living fifty times longer than the worker on the same genes, is the proof.
  • The rate-of-living theory fails on bats and birds, which are fast and long-lived, and the damage matters more than the speed of living.
  • Some animals barely age: the hydra shows no rise in mortality, the tortoise barely declines, and the lobster keeps growing and stays fertile, though moulting becomes its limit.
  • The immortal jellyfish, Turritopsis dohrnii, can reverse its life cycle from adult medusa back to polyp, and reset its own clock, but it still dies from predators and disease.
  • The longest-lived vertebrate is the Greenland shark, at about 392 years, and the longest-lived animal is the ocean quahog clam, at about 507 years.
  • Calorie restriction extends lifespan in yeast, worms, flies and mice, and the insulin and mTOR pathways are the mechanism, and the drug rapamycin extends the life of old mice.
  • The worm C. elegans taught us that a single gene, daf-2, can double lifespan, and the pathways it controls are the same in humans.
  • Wild animals do age, and the ageing shows in hard seasons, but most wild animals die from predators and disease before senescence is visible, while captive animals live long enough to show it.
  • Ageing can be slowed in the laboratory, but no drug or diet has yet been proven to extend human lifespan, and exercise, not smoking and a good diet are the only advice the science can honestly support.

Short Questions

1. What is the difference between lifespan and senescence?

See answer

Lifespan is how long an animal actually lives, and it is set mostly by the world outside, by predators, disease, accidents and food, and most animals in the wild die long before ageing has a chance to show. Senescence is what happens inside the body as it grows old, the gradual loss of function, the rising risk of death and the falling fertility, and it is a property of the body itself, not of the world around it. A mouse in a laboratory, protected from predators and disease, still ages and dies in about three years, and a tortoise in a zoo still ages, only far more slowly, and the difference between the two is the difference in how fast senescence runs in each of them. The lifespan is the outcome, and senescence is the process, and the process is what the science of ageing studies, because it is the part that the body controls, and the part that can, in principle, be slowed.

2. Why do big animals usually live longer than small ones?

See answer

Big animals usually live longer than small ones because a large animal is harder for a predator to kill, and it can afford to invest in repair, and the repair pays off over a long life, while a small animal is easy prey, and it is likely to be eaten young, and it pays to invest in breeding early and often instead. An elephant lives for sixty to seventy years because almost nothing can kill an adult elephant, and a mouse lives for three years because almost everything can kill a mouse, and the difference is the danger of the world, not the size itself. The rule has striking exceptions that prove it: a bat is the size of a mouse but lives for thirty years, because it can fly away from predators, and a bird the size of a mouse lives for twenty years for the same reason, and the exceptions show that it is safety, not size, that sets the lifespan, and size matters because it usually brings safety.

3. What are telomeres and why do they matter?

See answer

Telomeres are caps on the ends of chromosomes, stretches of repeated DNA that protect the ends the way the plastic tip protects the end of a shoelace, and they matter because they shorten every time a cell divides, by about fifty to two hundred base pairs, because the copying machine cannot copy the very end of the strand. When a telomere gets too short, the cell stops dividing and enters senescence, and it stays alive but never divides again, and it releases chemicals that inflame the tissue around it. The limit is called the Hayflick limit, about fifty divisions for a human cell, and it is the reason the tissues that divide often, the skin, the gut and the blood, are limited by telomeres, while the brain and the heart, whose cells rarely divide, age for other reasons. The germ cells make telomerase, an enzyme that rebuilds telomeres, which is why a child is born with long telomeres even though its parents are old.

4. What is the disposable soma theory?

See answer

The disposable soma theory, proposed by Thomas Kirkwood in 1977, says that the body has a limited amount of energy, and it must divide that energy between keeping itself alive and making the next generation, and it divides it in favour of the germline, the cells that make sperm and eggs, which are maintained with great care because they must last forever, while the soma, the body itself, is maintained only as well as it needs to be, because it only has to last long enough for the animal to breed, and after that it can be allowed to fall apart. The body is a vehicle for the germline, built to last only as long as the journey takes, and the proof is the honeybee: the queen and the worker have the same genes, but the queen lives for two to five years and the worker for about six weeks, because the queen is fed royal jelly, which switches on repair, and the worker is not, and the same genome, on a different diet, lives fifty times as long.

5. Why do animals in zoos often live longer than in the wild?

See answer

Animals in zoos live longer than in the wild because the zoo removes the things that kill wild animals young, the predators, the disease, the famine and the accidents, and it feeds the animal, shelters it and treats it when it is sick, and the animal lives long enough for its body to age, and the ageing that the wild would have hidden becomes visible. A captive elephant lives to seventy, a captive lion to twenty, and a captive parrot to eighty, and the old animals develop the diseases of old age, the arthritis, the cataracts and the kidney failure, and the diseases are the same as the diseases of old humans. The body ages at the same rate in the wild and in captivity, and the difference is the world: the wild kills the animal before the clock runs down, and the zoo lets the clock run, and the zoo is therefore the place where ageing is most visible, and where the science of ageing was largely built.

6. Is there any animal that does not age at all?

See answer

No animal is truly free of ageing, but a few come close, and the closest is the freshwater hydra, a tiny polyp that shows no increase in its risk of dying with age and no decline in its fertility, because its body is constantly rebuilt by stem cells, and the damaged cells are discarded and replaced, and the damage never accumulates. The immortal jellyfish, Turritopsis dohrnii, can reverse its life cycle from adult medusa back to polyp and start again, and in the laboratory it can do this repeatedly, and it is potentially immortal in the sense that it does not have to die of old age. But both animals still die in the wild, of predators, disease and accidents, and the lobster, which keeps growing and stays fertile throughout its life, still dies when moulting becomes too hard, and the honest answer is that no animal has beaten death, and the few that have beaten senescence have beaten only the clock inside, not the world outside.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is senescence in animals?

Senescence is the progressive deterioration of function that comes with age, measured by a rising risk of death and a falling ability to reproduce. It is different from lifespan, which is how long an animal actually lives and is set mostly by predators, disease and accidents. Senescence is caused by damage that accumulates in the body's cells faster than the repair systems can fix it, including DNA damage, shortened telomeres, oxidative damage and stem cells that run down, and it happens in almost every animal, from the fruit fly to the human, though a few animals, like the hydra and some tortoises, show almost none of it.

Why do some animals live much longer than others?

Some animals live much longer than others mostly because they are safer from predators, and safety makes investment in repair worth paying for. A tortoise lives for more than a century because its shell keeps it safe, a bat lives for thirty years because it can fly away from danger, and a mouse lives for three years because it is eaten young, so it invests in breeding early instead of repair. Size helps, because large animals are harder to kill, and cold helps, because cold slows the chemistry of damage, which is why the Greenland shark and the ocean quahog clam, both cold-water animals, hold the records for the longest lives.

What is the immortal jellyfish?

The immortal jellyfish is Turritopsis dohrnii, a tiny jellyfish that can reverse its own life cycle, turning itself from an adult medusa back into a juvenile polyp and starting again. When it is stressed by starvation, injury or old age, its cells change type in a process called transdifferentiation, and the medusa collapses into a polyp, which then buds off new medusae. In the laboratory it can do this repeatedly, so it does not have to die of old age, but in the sea it is still eaten by fish and killed by disease, so it is immortal only in the sense that it has beaten senescence, not death.

Do lobsters really live forever?

No, lobsters do not live forever, although the claim is widely repeated. A lobster does keep growing throughout its life, and it stays fertile throughout its life, and its telomeres do not shorten with age, because its tissues keep making telomerase, and the oldest lobsters are the most fertile. But the lobster must moult to grow, and moulting becomes harder and more dangerous as it gets larger, and a large lobster can die trapped in its old shell, and the risk of dying in a moult rises with size. Lobsters can live for fifty to a hundred years, which is a long life, but they do age, and the moult is their limit.

What causes ageing at the cellular level?

At the cellular level, ageing is caused by four kinds of damage that accumulate faster than the body's repair systems can fix them. The DNA is broken and misspelled thousands of times a day, and the breaks that are not repaired become mutations. The telomeres, the caps on the ends of chromosomes, shorten by about 50 to 200 base pairs at every cell division, until the cell stops dividing. The mitochondria produce free radicals as they burn fuel, and the radicals damage DNA, proteins and fats. And the stem cells that replace worn-out tissue gradually run down, so the body heals more slowly. The four kinds of damage feed each other, and the cycle accelerates with age.

Can calorie restriction make animals live longer?

Yes, calorie restriction, feeding an animal about two-thirds of the normal amount of food, extends lifespan in yeast, worms, fruit flies and mice, and it is the most reproduced result in the science of ageing. The worms live about twice as long, and the mice about a third longer, and the animals are also healthier, with less cancer and stronger immune systems. The mechanism is the body's sensing of food through the insulin and mTOR pathways, which turn down growth and turn up repair, including the recycling of damaged parts. The effect is smaller in animals that already live long, and it has not been proven to extend human lifespan, and the two monkey studies disagreed, so it is a proven result in the laboratory, not yet a proven treatment in people.

MCQs

1. What is senescence in animals?

  • A. The gradual deterioration of function with age, with rising mortality and falling fertility
  • B. A disease caused by a single gene
  • C. The process of growing larger with age
  • D. The loss of the ability to reproduce only

Answer: A

Explanation: Senescence is the progressive deterioration of function that comes with age, measured by a rising probability of death and a falling number of offspring, and it is caused by damage accumulating faster than repair. It is not a single-gene disease, and it is not the same as growing larger, which in a tortoise or a lobster is an improvement, not a decline.

2. A survivorship curve in which most individuals survive to old age and then die quickly describes which type?

  • A. Type III
  • B. Type I
  • C. Type II
  • D. No known curve

Answer: B

Explanation: A Type I curve is flat for most of life and then drops steeply at the end, because most individuals survive to old age and then die of old age together, and it is the curve of humans, elephants and whales. Type III drops steeply at the start, because most die very young, and Type II is a steady diagonal, with the same risk of dying at every age.

3. What happens to telomeres each time a normal body cell divides?

  • A. They lengthen
  • B. They stay exactly the same
  • C. They shorten, by about 50 to 200 base pairs
  • D. They are copied exactly, with nothing lost

Answer: C

Explanation: The copying machine cannot copy the very end of the DNA strand, so a small piece is lost at every division, about fifty to two hundred base pairs, and the telomere absorbs the loss and gets shorter, and when it gets too short the cell stops dividing, at the Hayflick limit of about fifty divisions. The germ cells rebuild telomeres with telomerase, which is why a child is born with long telomeres.

4. The mutation accumulation theory of ageing was proposed by whom?

  • A. Peter Medawar
  • B. Charles Darwin
  • C. Gregor Mendel
  • D. Thomas Kirkwood

Answer: A

Explanation: Peter Medawar proposed the mutation accumulation theory in 1952, arguing that natural selection weakens with age, so late-acting harmful mutations are never removed and they accumulate in the population. Thomas Kirkwood proposed the disposable soma theory, and George Williams proposed antagonistic pleiotropy, and Darwin and Mendel worked before the theory of ageing existed.

5. What does antagonistic pleiotropy mean?

  • A. A gene that is harmful at every age
  • B. A gene that is beneficial early in life and harmful later in life
  • C. A gene that only acts after death
  • D. A gene that repairs damaged DNA

Answer: B

Explanation: Antagonistic pleiotropy means a gene with more than one effect, where the effects pull in opposite directions, one good and one bad, and the gene is favoured by selection because it helps the animal when it is young, even though it harms it when it is old. The classic example is p53, which prevents cancer in the young but stops stem cells from dividing and so speeds ageing in the old.

6. Which animal can reverse its life cycle, returning from an adult medusa to a polyp?

  • A. The moon jellyfish
  • B. The immortal jellyfish, Turritopsis dohrnii
  • C. The box jellyfish
  • D. The Portuguese man o' war

Answer: B

Explanation: Turritopsis dohrnii, the immortal jellyfish, can turn itself from an adult medusa back into a juvenile polyp when it is stressed, by transdifferentiation, in which its cells change type and the body is rebuilt, and it can do this repeatedly in the laboratory. The moon jellyfish, the box jellyfish and the Portuguese man o' war cannot reverse their life cycles.

7. Which is the longest-lived vertebrate known?

  • A. The bowhead whale
  • B. The Galápagos tortoise
  • C. The Greenland shark
  • D. The African elephant

Answer: C

Explanation: The Greenland shark is the longest-lived vertebrate ever measured, at an estimated three hundred and ninety-two years, dated from the radiocarbon in its eye lens. The bowhead whale lives for more than two hundred years, the Galápagos tortoise for a hundred to a hundred and fifty, and the African elephant for sixty to seventy, and the longest-lived animal of all is the ocean quahog clam, at about five hundred and seven years.

8. In laboratory animals, what does calorie restriction do?

  • A. It shortens lifespan
  • B. It has no effect on lifespan
  • C. It extends lifespan in yeast, worms, flies and mice
  • D. It works only in humans

Answer: C

Explanation: Calorie restriction, feeding about two-thirds of the normal amount of food, extends lifespan in yeast, worms, fruit flies and mice, and the worms live about twice as long and the mice about a third longer, and the animals are healthier too. The mechanism is the insulin and mTOR pathways, which turn down growth and turn up repair, and the effect has not been proven to extend human lifespan.

9. Why do lobsters keep growing throughout their lives?

  • A. They never moult
  • B. They moult and grow throughout life, and stay fertile
  • C. They regenerate their shells every day
  • D. They do not age at all

Answer: B

Explanation: Lobsters keep growing because they moult throughout life, shedding their old shell and growing a larger one, and they stay fertile throughout life, and their telomeres do not shorten, because their tissues keep making telomerase. But they are not immortal, and they do age: moulting becomes harder and more dangerous as they get larger, and a large lobster can die trapped in its old shell, and the moult is their limit.

10. Which statement about ageing is FALSE?

  • A. Telomeres shorten with each cell division
  • B. All animals age at the same rate
  • C. A tortoise can live for more than a century
  • D. Most wild animals die before senescence shows

Answer: B

Explanation: Statement B is false, and it is the central point of this article: animals age at wildly different rates, from a mayfly that lives a day to a Greenland shark that lives about four hundred years, and the rate is set by safety, size, temperature and repair. Statements A, C and D are all true: telomeres shorten at each division, a Galápagos tortoise can live for a hundred to a hundred and fifty years, and most wild animals are killed by predators and disease before senescence is visible.

Related articles

Comments

Leave a comment