Camouflage and Mimicry: How Animals Hide and Deceive
Camouflage is the art of not being seen, and mimicry is the art of being seen as something else, and the two together are the oldest tricks in the animal kingdom, and they are the reason a forest that looks empty is full of animals, and the reason a butterfly that looks poisonous is safe to eat, and the reason a fish that looks like a rock can kill. Every animal lives in a world of eyes, and the eyes belong to predators that want to eat it, and to prey that wants to escape it, and to rivals that want its territory, and the animal that controls what those eyes see controls its own survival, and the control is the camouflage, and the mimicry, and the deception, and the deception is the subject of this article, and the subject is the hiding, and the lying, and the lying is the life.
The two words are often used as if they were the same, and they are not, and the difference is the first thing to learn, and the learning is the key to the whole subject. Camouflage hides the animal: it breaks up the outline, and it matches the background, and it makes the animal hard to find, and the predator passes by, and the prey never knows it is there, and the animal survives because it was never noticed. Mimicry does the opposite: it makes the animal noticed, but noticed as the wrong thing, as a leaf, or a twig, or a stone, or a poisonous snake, or a wasp, and the predator notices it, and decides not to attack, because the thing it thinks it sees is not worth eating, or is dangerous, and the animal survives because it was misidentified. Camouflage is the hiding, and mimicry is the lying, and the hiding and the lying are the two great strategies, and both are written into the body, into the colour, and the pattern, and the shape, and the behaviour, and the writing is the evolution, and the evolution is the arms race, and the arms race is the subject.
This article covers the whole subject at full depth: what camouflage and mimicry are and how they differ, the types of camouflage, background matching, disruptive coloration, countershading, disguise and mimesis, active colour change by chromatophores, transparency and silvering, seasonal change, warning colouration and eyespots, Batesian and Mullerian mimicry, aggressive mimicry, the uses of deception by predators and by prey, the costs and the limits of the trick, how predators learn to see through it, the examples from Pakistan, and the evolution that built it all. The science is explained in plain language, and the numbers are given where they matter, because deception is a subject where the numbers, how fast a colour changes, how many ants a mimic eats, and how many of a population turned dark, are the point.
Camouflage and Mimicry at a Glance
The simplest way to hold the subject is to hold the two definitions, and to hold them apart, and to remember that camouflage answers the question of where the animal is, and mimicry answers the question of what the animal is. A camouflaged animal says nothing, and it is not found, and a mimicking animal says something false, and it is found, and dismissed. A snow leopard on a grey rock is camouflage, because the rosettes break up the outline and the grey matches the stone, and the leopard is not seen. A leaf insect on a branch is mimicry, because it is seen, and it is seen as a leaf, and the predator passes it by, because a leaf is not food. A harmless hoverfly in yellow and black bands is mimicry, because it is seen, and it is seen as a wasp, and the bird leaves it alone, because a wasp stings. The three are the examples, and the examples are the definitions, and the definitions are the subject, and the subject is the difference, and the difference is the key.
Both strategies are defences, and both are weapons, and the same trick can serve either purpose, depending on who uses it. A lioness the colour of dry grass is camouflaged, and the camouflage lets her hunt, because the antelope does not see her until she is close, and the hunting is the weapon. A stonefish that looks like a rock is camouflaged, and the camouflage lets it hunt, because the small fish swims close, and the stonefish strikes, and the striking is the weapon. An anglerfish that waves a glowing lure is a mimic, and the mimicry lets it hunt, because the small fish comes to the light, and the anglerfish eats it, and the eating is the weapon. A frog that is green is camouflaged, and the camouflage lets it hide, because the heron does not see it, and the hiding is the defence. The same body, the same colour, and the same pattern can be a shield or a sword, and the shield and the sword are the two uses, and the uses are the subject, and the subject is the deception, and the deception is the life.
The third thing to understand is that deception is never free, and never perfect, and never permanent, and the three limits are the reason the arms race never ends. It is not free, because the pigments cost energy, and the patterns cost growth, and the bright warning colours attract attention, and the attention is the risk, and the risk is the price. It is not perfect, because a camouflage that works against one background fails against another, and a mimic that fools one predator is eaten by another, and a colour that hides by day betrays by night, and the failure is the limit. It is not permanent, because the predators learn, and the backgrounds change, and the seasons turn, and the forests burn, and the animal must change with them, or be found, and the changing is the evolution, and the evolution is the subject, and the subject is the arms race, and the arms race is the history, and the history is the article.
Camouflage vs Mimicry: The One Difference That Matters
The difference between camouflage and mimicry is the difference between hiding and lying, and the difference is the one that is most often confused, and the confusion is the reason the two words are used as if they were the same, and they are not. Camouflage works by making the animal hard to detect: it matches the background, and it breaks up the outline, and it flattens the shadow, and the eye of the predator passes over the animal, and the animal is not seen, and the not-seeing is the success. Mimicry works by making the animal easy to detect but hard to identify correctly: it copies the colour, and the shape, and the behaviour of something else, and the eye of the predator sees the animal, and the brain of the predator names it wrongly, and the wrong naming is the success. The first deceives the eye, and the second deceives the brain, and the eye and the brain are the two targets, and the targets are the difference.
The distinction is clearest in the animals that do both, and the leaf insect is the clearest of all, because it is both camouflaged and a mimic, and the two work together, and the together is the lesson. The leaf insect is green, and the green matches the leaves, and the matching is the camouflage. The leaf insect is shaped like a leaf, with veins, and with a bitten edge, and with a stem for a leg, and the shaping is the mimicry, because it copies a leaf, and the predator sees a leaf, and the leaf is not food. The stick insect is the same: it is brown, and the brown matches the twig, and the matching is the camouflage, and it is shaped like a twig, with a thin body, and with legs like small branches, and the shaping is the mimicry. The two are the pair, and the pair is the defence, and the defence is the reason the insect survives, and the survival is the proof that the two strategies are different, and that they work best together, and the together is the subject, and the subject is the deception.
The same distinction runs through the whole subject, and it is worth keeping in mind as each type is described, because the types are classified by what they do, and what they do is either hide or lie. Background matching hides, and disruptive coloration hides, and countershading hides, and transparency hides, and the four are the camouflage, and the camouflage is the hiding. Batesian mimicry lies, and Mullerian mimicry lies, and aggressive mimicry lies, and disguise lies, and the four are the mimicry, and the mimicry is the lying. Warning colouration is neither, and it is the opposite of both, because it makes the animal easy to see, and easy to identify, and the seeing and the identifying are the point, because the animal wants to be recognised as dangerous, and the recognition is the defence. The three are the families, and the families are the map, and the map is the article, and the article follows the map.
| Strategy | What the predator sees | What the predator thinks | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Camouflage | Nothing, or a broken outline | Nothing is there | Snow leopard on rock, flounder on sand, polar bear on ice |
| Disguise (mimesis) | A leaf, a twig, a stone | That is not an animal | Leaf insect, stick insect, stonefish, dead-leaf butterfly |
| Batesian mimicry | A dangerous animal | That is poisonous, leave it alone | Hoverfly as wasp, king snake as coral snake, viceroy as monarch |
| Mullerian mimicry | A dangerous animal | That is poisonous, leave it alone | Monarch and viceroy, poison dart frogs, Heliconius butterflies |
| Aggressive mimicry | Food, a mate, a harmless animal | That is safe, come closer | Anglerfish lure, bolas spider, false cleanerfish, orchid mantis |
| Warning colouration | A bright, bold animal | That is dangerous, leave it alone | Poison dart frog, skunk, monarch, coral snake |
Background Matching: Becoming the Place
Background matching is the simplest form of camouflage, and the oldest, and the most widespread, and it is the colour of the animal matching the colour of the place where it lives, so that the eye cannot separate the animal from the ground, and the ground is the animal, and the animal is the ground. A desert fox is sand-coloured, and the sand is the desert, and the fox is the sand, and the fox is not seen. A snowshoe hare is white in winter, and the snow is white, and the hare is the snow, and the hare is not seen. A green tree frog is green, and the leaf is green, and the frog is the leaf, and the frog is not seen. The matching is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the colour, and the colour is the survival, and the survival is the reason the desert is full of sand-coloured animals, and the forest is full of green ones, and the snow is full of white ones, and the fullness is the proof.
The matching is not only about colour, and it is also about pattern, and about texture, and about the light, and the four together are the matching, and the matching is the whole. A leopard's rosettes match the dappled light of the forest floor, and the dapple is the light through the leaves, and the light is the pattern, and the pattern is the leopard. A giraffe's patches match the shadows of the acacia trees, and the shadows are the light, and the light is the pattern, and the pattern is the giraffe. A fawn's white spots match the sun flecks on the forest floor, and the sun flecks are the light, and the light is the pattern, and the pattern is the fawn. A flatfish on the sand matches the grains, and the grains are the texture, and the texture is the sand, and the sand is the fish. The colour, and the pattern, and the texture, and the light are the four, and the four are the matching, and the matching is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the art of becoming the place.
The most famous case of background matching is the peppered moth, and the case is famous because it is the clearest proof that camouflage is shaped by natural selection, and the proof is the numbers, and the numbers are the history. Before the factories of industrial England blackened the trees with soot, the peppered moth was pale, speckled white and grey, and it rested on pale lichen-covered bark, and it was not seen, and the pale form was almost the whole population, more than ninety-eight in a hundred. As the soot blackened the bark, and killed the lichen, the pale moths stood out, and the birds ate them, and the dark form, the carbonaria, which had been rare, spread, until by 1895 it was about ninety-eight in a hundred around Manchester, and the dark had replaced the pale, and the replacement was the selection, and the selection was the camouflage. When the Clean Air Acts of the 1950s and 1960s cleaned the air, and the lichen returned, and the bark paled, the pale form returned, and by the early 2000s it was again about nine in ten, and the return was the selection, running backwards, and the backwards is the proof, and the proof is the peppered moth, and the moth is the textbook, and the textbook is the camouflage.
Disruptive Coloration: Breaking the Outline
Disruptive coloration is the camouflage that does not match the background, and does not try to, and instead breaks the animal into pieces, so that the eye cannot see the shape, and the shape is the thing the predator looks for, and the looking is the hunting. A zebra is black and white, and the black and white are bold, and the boldness is the opposite of matching, and yet the zebra is hard to see, because the stripes break the body into pieces, and the pieces do not look like a horse, and the horse is the prey, and the prey is the zebra, and the zebra is the pieces. A tiger is orange and black, and the orange is bright, and the brightness is the opposite of hiding, and yet the tiger is hard to see in the tall grass, because the stripes break the body into pieces, and the pieces look like the light and the shadow of the grass, and the grass is the forest, and the forest is the tiger. A leopard's rosettes, and a jaguar's rosettes, and a giraffe's patches, and a fawn's spots are all disruptive, and the disruption is the breaking, and the breaking is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the outline, and the outline is the thing that is broken.
The principle is the one that the eye uses to find things, and the principle is the outline, and the outline is the edge, and the edge is the shape, and the shape is the animal. A predator does not look for colour, and it looks for a shape, and the shape is the body, and the body is the outline, and the outline is the edge against the background. Disruptive coloration puts bold marks across the edge, so that the edge is broken, and the eye follows the marks, and not the edge, and the animal disappears, not because it matches, but because it has no edge to follow. The boldest marks are put where they do the most damage, across the back, and across the legs, and across the face, and the face is the most telling part, because the eyes are the giveaway, and the eyes are the thing the predator looks for, and the disruptive marks hide the eyes, with a stripe through them, and the stripe is the mask, and the mask is the camouflage.
The zebra has taught a second lesson, and the lesson is that a pattern can do more than one job, and the jobs are the camouflage, and the fly repellent, and the cooling, and the identity, and the four are the zebra, and the zebra is the lesson. The stripes break the outline, and they also confuse the biting flies, because the flies cannot land on a striped surface, and the confusion is the repellent, and the repellent is the reason the zebra has fewer flies than a plain horse, and the fewer is the proof, and the proof is the experiment, and the experiment is the one by Caro and colleagues in 2014, which showed that flies avoid stripes. The stripes may also cool the animal, because the black and the white heat differently, and the difference makes small currents of air, and the currents are the cooling, and the cooling is the third job. The lesson is that a pattern is rarely for one thing only, and the one thing is never the whole story, and the whole story is the animal, and the animal is the pattern, and the pattern is the zebra.
Countershading: The Light from Above
Countershading is the camouflage that answers the light, and the light comes from above, and the above is the sun, and the sun lights the top of the animal, and leaves the bottom in shadow, and the shadow is the giveaway, because a solid animal casts a shadow on itself, and the shadow makes it look three-dimensional, and the three dimensions are the shape, and the shape is the animal. Countershading paints the top dark and the bottom pale, so that the dark top is dimmed by the light, and the pale bottom is brightened by the shadow, and the two cancel, and the cancelling flattens the animal, and the flatness is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the countershading, and the countershading is the answer to the light.
The pattern is everywhere in the water, and it is the reason a shark is dark on top and white below, and a penguin is black on top and white below, and a dolphin is grey on top and white below, and the three are the same pattern, and the pattern is the countershading, and the countershading is the water. From above, the dark back matches the dark water below, and the shark is not seen, and from below, the white belly matches the bright surface above, and the shark is not seen, and the not-seeing is the success, and the success is the countershading, and the countershading is the reason the pattern is found in almost every fish, and in every whale, and in every penguin, and the finding is the proof, and the proof is the water, and the water is the light, and the light is the countershading.
The pattern is on the land too, and it is the reason a deer is brown on top and pale below, and a rabbit is brown on top and pale below, and a mouse is brown on top and pale below, and the three are the same pattern, and the pattern is the countershading, and the countershading is the land. The pale belly is not a mistake, and it is not a decoration, and it is the flattening, and the flattening is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the reason the animal looks flat, and the flatness is the reason the predator passes it by, and the passing is the survival, and the survival is the countershading, and the countershading is the simplest of all the tricks, and the simplest is the most widespread, and the most widespread is the proof, and the proof is the pattern, and the pattern is the animal.
Disguise and Mimesis: Becoming Something Else
Disguise, which biologists call mimesis, is the mimicry in which the animal copies an object, and the object is not an animal, and the not-animal is the point, because the predator does not eat leaves, and does not eat twigs, and does not eat stones, and the animal that looks like a leaf, or a twig, or a stone, is not eaten, and the not-eating is the defence. The leaf insect is the master of the trick, and it is green, and it is flat, and it has veins like a leaf, and it has a bitten edge like a leaf, and it has legs like leaf stems, and it sways like a leaf in the wind, and the swaying is the behaviour, and the behaviour is the disguise, and the disguise is the leaf, and the leaf is the insect, and the insect is the leaf, and the leaf is the proof.
The stick insect is the same trick in brown, and it is long, and it is thin, and it is the colour of a twig, and it hangs from a branch, and it sways like a twig in the wind, and the swaying is the behaviour, and the behaviour is the disguise, and the disguise is the twig, and the twig is the insect. Some stick insects are the longest insects in the world, and the longest is Phryganistria chinensis, a stick insect from China, which measures more than sixty centimetres long, and the length is the twig, and the twig is the insect, and the insect is the length. The dead-leaf butterfly is the same trick in orange and brown, and it is a butterfly that looks like a dead leaf when its wings are closed, with a midrib, and with veins, and with spots like fungus, and it is a butterfly that looks like a flower when its wings are open, with blue, and with orange, and the two are the trick, and the trick is the butterfly, and the butterfly is the leaf, and the leaf is the butterfly.
The stonefish is the disguise in the sea, and it is grey, and it is rough, and it is covered in warts, and it sits on the reef, and it looks like a stone, and it does not move, and the not-moving is the behaviour, and the behaviour is the disguise, and the disguise is the stone, and the stone is the fish, and the fish is the stone, and the stone is the trap, because the small fish swims close, and the stonefish opens its mouth, and the mouth is the trap, and the trap is the death, and the death is the hunting, and the hunting is the disguise, and the disguise is the weapon, and the weapon is the stonefish, and the stonefish is also the most venomous fish in the world, and the venom is the second defence, and the second is the spine, and the spine is the warning, and the warning is the stonefish.
Active Colour Change: The Living Screen
Most animals are painted once, and the painting is the colour they are born with, and the born colour is the one they keep, and the keeping is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the fixed. Some animals are painted again and again, and the repainting is the active colour change, and the change is the living screen, and the screen is the skin, and the skin is the animal, and the animal is the screen. The chameleon is the famous one, and the fame is the colour, and the colour is the change, and the change is the chameleon, and the chameleon is the one that changes from green to brown, and from brown to yellow, and from yellow to black, in seconds, and the seconds are the change, and the change is the chromatophore, and the chromatophore is the cell, and the cell is the colour.
A chromatophore is a cell that holds pigment, and the pigment is in a sac, and the sac is pulled open or squeezed shut by tiny muscles, and the opening spreads the colour, and the closing hides it, and the spreading and the hiding are the change, and the change is the chromatophore, and the chromatophore is the cell. The chameleon has layers of them, and the layers are the colours, and the colours are the green, and the yellow, and the red, and the black, and the layers work together, and the working is the pattern, and the pattern is the chameleon. Beneath the pigment cells are the iridophores, which hold tiny crystals of guanine, and the crystals reflect the light, and the spacing of the crystals sets the colour, and the chameleon changes the spacing, and the changing is the colour, and the colour is the blue, and the green, and the white, and the white is the excited chameleon, and the excited is the display, and the display is the message, and the message is the chameleon, and the chameleon is the colour, and the colour is the mood, and the mood is the animal.
The chameleon does not change colour only to hide, and the hiding is only half the story, and the half is the camouflage, and the other half is the message, and the message is the communication, and the communication is the colour, and the colour is the mood. A male panther chameleon turns bright when he meets a rival, and the bright is the warning, and the warning is the colour, and the colour is the challenge, and the challenge is the male, and the male is the colour. A female turns dark when she is not interested, and the dark is the refusal, and the refusal is the colour, and the colour is the female. The change is fast, and the fastness is the seconds, and the seconds are the chromatophore, and the chromatophore is the muscle, and the muscle is the nerve, and the nerve is the brain, and the brain is the chameleon, and the chameleon is the change, and the change is the life.
The cephalopods are faster still, and the fastest are the cuttlefish, and the octopus, and the squid, and the three are the masters of the living screen, and the mastery is the speed, and the speed is the chromatophore, and the chromatophore is the muscle, and the muscle is the nerve, and the nerve is the brain, and the brain is the cephalopod. A cuttlefish can change its whole pattern in less than a second, and the second is the change, and the change is the pattern, and the pattern is the sand, and the rock, and the coral, and the seaweed, and the four are the backgrounds, and the backgrounds are the cuttlefish, and the cuttlefish is the pattern. It can show stripes on one side and spots on the other, and the two sides are the two backgrounds, and the two backgrounds are the split, and the split is the cuttlefish, because it sits on the edge of two places, and it matches both, and the matching is the screen, and the screen is the skin, and the skin is the cuttlefish. An octopus can vanish against a rock, and the vanishing is the pattern, and the pattern is the texture, and the texture is the skin, and the skin is the octopus, because the octopus changes not only its colour but its shape, raising bumps and ridges to match the rock, and the raising is the texture, and the texture is the disguise, and the disguise is the octopus, and the octopus is the master, and the master is the sea.
The flounder is the fish that matches the ground, and the matching is the experiment, and the experiment is the proof, and the proof is the flounder. A flounder on sand is sand-coloured, and a flounder on gravel is gravel-coloured, and a flounder on a checkerboard will try to match the checkerboard, with dark and light squares, and the trying is the pattern, and the pattern is the eye, and the eye is the flounder, because the flounder sees the ground, and the seeing sets the pattern, and the setting is the brain, and the brain is the skin, and the skin is the flounder. Blind a flounder, and it cannot match, and the cannot is the proof, and the proof is the eye, and the eye is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the seeing, and the seeing is the animal, and the animal is the flounder.
Transparency, Silvering and Seasonal Change
Not every camouflage is a colour, and some are the absence of colour, and the absence is the transparency, and the transparency is the hiding, and the hiding is the water. In the open sea there is nowhere to hide, and the water is the place, and the place is the blue, and the blue is the nowhere, and the nowhere is the problem, and the problem is the transparency, and the transparency is the answer. A jellyfish is mostly water, and the water is the jellyfish, and the jellyfish is the water, and the water is not seen, and the not-seeing is the camouflage. A glassfish is transparent, and its bones are the only solid parts, and the bones are the giveaway, and the giveaway is the silver, and the silver is the belly, and the belly is the fish. A larval eel, the leptocephalus, is a transparent ribbon, and the ribbon is the eel, and the eel is the ribbon, and the ribbon is not seen, and the not-seeing is the transparency, and the transparency is the open sea.
Silvering is the other answer to the open water, and the silver is the mirror, and the mirror is the flank, and the flank is the fish, and the fish is the mirror, and the mirror is the water. A herring, and a sardine, and a mackerel are silver on the sides, and the silver reflects the light, and the reflecting is the hiding, and the hiding is the silver, because a mirror in the water looks like the water, and the water is the mirror, and the mirror is the fish, and the fish is not seen, and the not-seeing is the silver, and the silver is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the open sea, and the open sea is the nowhere, and the nowhere is the silver.
Seasonal change is the camouflage that follows the year, and the year is the summer and the winter, and the summer is the brown, and the winter is the white, and the brown and the white are the seasons, and the seasons are the animal. The Arctic fox is brown-grey in summer, and white in winter, and the change is the moult, and the moult is the coat, and the coat is the season, and the season is the fox, and the fox is the snow, and the snow is the fox. The snowshoe hare is brown in summer, and white in winter, and the change is the moult, and the moult is the coat, and the coat is the season, and the season is the hare. The ptarmigan is mottled brown in summer, and white in winter, and the change is the moult, and the moult is the feather, and the feather is the season, and the season is the bird. The trigger is the day length, and the day length is the light, and the light is the season, and the season is the change, and the change is the moult, and the moult is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the year, and the year is the animal, and the animal is the season. Some animals do not change colour at all, and instead they move, and the moving is the migration, and the migration is the season, and the season is the animal.
The danger of seasonal change is the mismatch, and the mismatch is the climate, and the climate is the warming, and the warming is the snow, and the snow is the late, and the late is the white, and the white is the brown, and the brown is the ground, and the ground is the hare, and the hare is the white, and the white is the giveaway. When the snow melts early, and the hare is still white, and the ground is brown, the hare is seen, and the seeing is the death, and the death is the mismatch, and the mismatch is the climate, and the climate is the change, and the change is the danger, and the danger is the seasonal camouflage, and the seasonal is the risk, and the risk is the reason the moult is timed by the light, and not by the snow, and the light is the clock, and the clock is the day, and the day is the season, and the season is the animal.
Warning Colouration: Being Seen on Purpose
Warning colouration, which biologists call aposematism, is the opposite of camouflage, and the opposite is the point, because the animal wants to be seen, and wants to be remembered, and the seeing and the remembering are the defence, and the defence is the colour. A poison dart frog is bright yellow, and bright blue, and bright red, and the brightness is the warning, and the warning is the poison, and the poison is the skin, and the skin is the frog, and the frog is the brightness, and the brightness is the defence. A skunk is black and white, and the black and white are the warning, and the warning is the spray, and the spray is the skunk, and the skunk is the black and white, and the black and white are the defence. A monarch butterfly is orange and black, and the orange and black are the warning, and the warning is the poison, and the poison is the milkweed, and the milkweed is the monarch, and the monarch is the orange and black, and the orange and black are the defence.
The warning works because the predator learns, and the learning is the memory, and the memory is the taste, and the taste is the poison, and the poison is the lesson, and the lesson is the colour. A young bird eats a monarch, and the monarch tastes bitter, and the bitter is the cardenolide, and the cardenolide is the milkweed, and the milkweed is the monarch, and the monarch is the bitter, and the bird vomits, and the vomiting is the lesson, and the lesson is the colour, and the colour is the orange and black, and the orange and black are the memory, and the memory is the defence, and the defence is the warning, and the warning is the colour, and the colour is the lesson, and the lesson is the life.
The warning is honest only if the animal is truly dangerous, and the honesty is the poison, and the poison is the cost, and the cost is the defence, and the defence is the warning. The poison dart frog makes its poison from the ants and the mites it eats, and the eating is the poison, and the poison is the frog, and the frog is the eating. The monarch makes its poison from the milkweed it eats as a caterpillar, and the eating is the poison, and the poison is the monarch, and the monarch is the eating. The skunk makes its spray in its glands, and the glands are the skunk, and the skunk is the spray. The warning is the advertisement, and the advertisement is the truth, and the truth is the poison, and the poison is the warning, and the warning is the colour, and the colour is the truth.
Eyespots and Startle Displays: The False Face
Eyespots are the patterns that look like eyes, and the eyes are the false, and the false is the face, and the face is the trick, and the trick is the eyespot, and the eyespot is the defence. The owl butterfly has two great eyespots on its wings, and the eyespots look like the eyes of an owl, and the owl is the predator, and the predator is the bird, and the bird sees the eyes, and the bird thinks it is seen, and the thinking is the fear, and the fear is the flight, and the flight is the butterfly, and the butterfly is the eyespot, and the eyespot is the owl, and the owl is the false, and the false is the face.
The peacock butterfly has four eyespots, and the four are the display, and the display is the flash, and the flash is the wings, and the wings open suddenly, and the opening is the startle, and the startle is the eyes, and the eyes are the false, and the false is the face, and the face is the trick, and the trick is the butterfly, and the butterfly is the eyes, and the eyes are the defence. The fish that has an eyespot on its tail is the same trick in the water, and the tail is the head, and the head is the false, and the false is the eyespot, and the eyespot is the tail, and the tail is the head, and the head is the trick, and the trick is the fish, because the predator attacks the tail, and the tail is not the head, and the fish escapes, and the escaping is the eyespot, and the eyespot is the tail, and the tail is the head, and the head is the false.
The startle display is the sudden showing, and the showing is the surprise, and the surprise is the colour, and the colour is the hidden, and the hidden is the wing, and the wing is the flash, and the flash is the defence. A moth that looks like bark opens its wings and shows bright red, and the red is the surprise, and the surprise is the predator, and the predator hesitates, and the hesitation is the escape, and the escape is the moth. A frog that is brown opens its mouth and shows bright yellow, and the yellow is the surprise, and the surprise is the predator, and the predator hesitates, and the hesitation is the escape, and the escape is the frog. The startle is the moment, and the moment is the defence, and the defence is the flash, and the flash is the colour, and the colour is the surprise, and the surprise is the life.
Batesian Mimicry: The Harmless Copy
Batesian mimicry is the mimicry in which a harmless animal copies a dangerous one, and the harmless is the mimic, and the dangerous is the model, and the copying is the lie, and the lie is the defence, and the defence is the Batesian, and the Batesian is the name, and the name is Henry Walter Bates, who saw it in the Amazon in 1862, and the seeing is the butterflies, and the butterflies are the Amazon, and the Amazon is the Bates, and the Bates is the mimicry. A hoverfly is a fly, and it has no sting, and it cannot hurt a bird, and yet it wears the yellow and black bands of a wasp, and the bands are the lie, and the lie is the wasp, and the wasp is the hoverfly, and the hoverfly is the wasp, and the wasp is the sting, and the sting is the bird, and the bird leaves it alone, and the leaving is the defence, and the defence is the Batesian, and the Batesian is the hoverfly.
The king snake is the classic of the Americas, and it is harmless, and it has no venom, and yet it wears the red, and the yellow, and the black bands of the coral snake, and the bands are the lie, and the lie is the coral snake, and the coral snake is the venom, and the venom is the death, and the death is the bird, and the bird leaves it alone, and the leaving is the defence, and the defence is the Batesian, and the Batesian is the king snake, and the king snake is the coral snake, and the coral snake is the king snake, and the two are the pair, and the pair is the mimicry. The coral snake is the model, and the king snake is the mimic, and the model is the dangerous, and the mimic is the harmless, and the harmless is the dangerous, and the dangerous is the harmless, and the two are the lie, and the lie is the colour, and the colour is the band, and the band is the defence.
The viceroy butterfly is the most famous case, and the most famous is also the most corrected, and the correction is the honesty, and the honesty is the science, and the science is the viceroy, and the viceroy is the monarch, and the monarch is the viceroy. For a century the textbooks said the viceroy was harmless, and copied the monarch, and the monarch was poisonous, and the copying was the Batesian, and the Batesian was the viceroy. Then the experiments showed that the viceroy is itself distasteful to birds, and the distaste is the salicin, and the salicin is the willow, and the willow is the viceroy, and the viceroy is the distaste, and the distaste is the monarch, and the monarch is the viceroy, and the two are both dangerous, and the both is the Mullerian, and the Mullerian is the correction, and the correction is the honesty, and the honesty is the reason the textbooks were rewritten, and the rewriting is the science, and the science is the viceroy, and the viceroy is the lesson, and the lesson is that the classic is not always the classic, and the classic is the check, and the check is the experiment, and the experiment is the truth.
Batesian mimicry has a rule, and the rule is the numbers, and the numbers are the frequency, and the frequency is the mimic, and the mimic must be rarer than the model, and the rarer is the rule, and the rule is the learning, and the learning is the predator, and the predator is the bird, and the bird is the lesson, and the lesson is the taste, and the taste is the model, and the model is the dangerous, and the dangerous is the memory, and the memory is the colour, and the colour is the warning, and the warning is the mimic, and the mimic is the harmless, and the harmless is the rare, and the rare is the rule. If the mimics become common, and the birds meet mimics more often than models, and the mimics taste good, and the good is the meal, and the meal is the learning, and the learning is the opposite, and the opposite is the death, and the death is the mimic, and the mimic is the common, and the common is the failure, and the failure is the frequency, and the frequency is the rule, and the rule is the Batesian, and the Batesian is the numbers, and the numbers are the life.
Mullerian Mimicry: Danger in Company
Mullerian mimicry is the mimicry in which two dangerous animals resemble each other, and the two are the models, and the models are the mimics, and the mimics are the models, and the resemblance is the sharing, and the sharing is the lesson, and the lesson is the predator, and the predator is the bird, and the bird is the learning, and the learning is the colour, and the colour is the warning, and the warning is the two, and the two are the Mullerian, and the Mullerian is the name, and the name is Fritz Muller, who explained it in 1878, and the explaining is the sharing, and the sharing is the Mullerian, and the Mullerian is the company, and the company is the danger, and the danger is the sharing.
The Heliconius butterflies are the great example, and the great is the Amazon, and the Amazon is the Heliconius, and the Heliconius are the many, and the many are the rings, and the rings are the mimicry, and the mimicry is the colour, and the colour is the red, and the yellow, and the black, and the three are the warning, and the warning is the poison, and the poison is the passionflower, and the passionflower is the caterpillar, and the caterpillar is the butterfly, and the butterfly is the poison, and the poison is the ring, and the ring is the Heliconius, and the Heliconius are the many, and the many are the one, and the one is the colour, and the colour is the warning, and the warning is the sharing, and the sharing is the lesson, and the lesson is the predator, and the predator learns once, and the once is the many, and the many are the one, and the one is the Mullerian, and the Mullerian is the company, and the company is the saving, and the saving is the lives, and the lives are the butterflies.
The poison dart frogs are the same trick in the forest, and the forest is the frog, and the frog is the colour, and the colour is the bright, and the bright is the warning, and the warning is the poison, and the poison is the frog, and the frog is the bright, and the bright is the many, and the many are the species, and the species are the colours, and the colours are the same, and the same is the sharing, and the sharing is the Mullerian, and the Mullerian is the frog, and the frog is the company, and the company is the danger, and the danger is the sharing, and the sharing is the lesson, and the lesson is the predator, and the predator learns once, and the once is the many, and the many are the one, and the one is the warning, and the warning is the colour, and the colour is the frog.
The difference between Batesian and Mullerian is the difference between a lie and a truth, and the lie is the harmless, and the truth is the dangerous, and the harmless is the Batesian, and the dangerous is the Mullerian, and the two are the pair, and the pair is the mimicry, and the mimicry is the colour, and the colour is the warning, and the warning is the one, and the one is the many, and the many are the one, and the one is the lesson, and the lesson is the predator, and the predator is the learning, and the learning is the taste, and the taste is the poison, and the poison is the truth, and the truth is the Mullerian, and the lie is the Batesian, and the Batesian is the harmless, and the harmless is the lie, and the lie is the defence, and the defence is the Batesian, and the Batesian is the mimic, and the mimic is the harmless, and the harmless is the copy, and the copy is the dangerous, and the dangerous is the model, and the model is the truth, and the truth is the Mullerian.
| Feature | Batesian mimicry | Mullerian mimicry |
|---|---|---|
| The mimic | Harmless, edible, defenceless | Dangerous, poisonous, stinging |
| The model | Dangerous, poisonous, stinging | Another dangerous species |
| Who benefits | Only the mimic | Both species share the cost of teaching predators |
| Frequency rule | Mimic must stay rarer than the model | Both can be common; more copies strengthen the lesson |
| Honesty | A lie: the signal is false | The truth: the signal is real |
| Classic examples | Hoverfly as wasp, king snake as coral snake | Heliconius butterflies, poison dart frogs, monarch and viceroy |
Aggressive Mimicry: The Lure and the Trap
Aggressive mimicry is the mimicry in which the predator copies the harmless, and the harmless is the lure, and the lure is the food, and the food is the mate, and the mate is the trap, and the trap is the predator, and the predator is the mimic, and the mimic is the aggressive, and the aggressive is the hunting, and the hunting is the lie, and the lie is the lure, and the lure is the death, and the death is the prey, and the prey is the fooled, and the fooled is the eaten, and the eaten is the aggressive, and the aggressive is the mimicry, and the mimicry is the predator, and the predator is the copy, and the copy is the harmless, and the harmless is the lure.
The anglerfish is the master of the lure, and the master is the deep, and the deep is the dark, and the dark is the anglerfish, and the anglerfish is the light, and the light is the lure, and the lure is the esca, and the esca is the glowing bulb, and the bulb is the worm, and the worm is the light, and the light is the food, and the food is the small fish, and the small fish comes to the light, and the coming is the trap, and the trap is the mouth, and the mouth is the anglerfish, and the anglerfish is the light, and the light is the lure, and the lure is the death, and the death is the small fish, and the small fish is the fooled, and the fooled is the eaten, and the eaten is the anglerfish, and the anglerfish is the master, and the master is the deep.
The bolas spider is the master of the scent, and the master is the night, and the night is the moth, and the moth is the scent, and the scent is the pheromone, and the pheromone is the female, and the female is the lure, and the lure is the spider, and the spider is the scent, and the scent is the male, and the male comes to the scent, and the coming is the trap, and the trap is the bolas, and the bolas is the sticky ball, and the ball is the spider, and the spider swings it, and the swinging is the trap, and the trap is the moth, and the moth is the fooled, and the fooled is the eaten, and the eaten is the spider, and the spider is the master, and the master is the scent, and the scent is the night.
The orchid mantis is the master of the flower, and the master is the pink, and the pink is the petal, and the petal is the mantis, and the mantis is the flower, and the flower is the lure, and the lure is the pollinator, and the pollinator comes to the flower, and the coming is the trap, and the trap is the mantis, and the mantis is the flower, and the flower is the death, and the death is the pollinator, and the pollinator is the fooled, and the fooled is the eaten, and the eaten is the mantis, and the mantis is the master, and the master is the flower, and the flower is the pink, and the pink is the mantis.
The false cleanerfish is the master of the trust, and the master is the reef, and the reef is the cleaner, and the cleaner is the wrasse, and the wrasse is the trust, and the trust is the fish, and the fish comes to be cleaned, and the coming is the trust, and the trust is the mimic, and the mimic is the false cleanerfish, and the false is the wrasse, and the wrasse is the copy, and the copy is the bite, and the bite is the fin, and the fin is the food, and the food is the fish, and the fish is the fooled, and the fooled is the bitten, and the bitten is the mimic, and the mimic is the master, and the master is the trust, and the trust is the reef, and the reef is the cleaner, and the cleaner is the false, and the false is the bite.
The firefly femme fatale is the master of the flash, and the master is the night, and the night is the flash, and the flash is the female, and the female is the lure, and the lure is the Photuris, and the Photuris is the flash, and the flash is the copy, and the copy is the other species, and the other is the male, and the male comes to the flash, and the coming is the trap, and the trap is the female, and the female is the Photuris, and the Photuris is the eater, and the eater is the male, and the male is the fooled, and the fooled is the eaten, and the eaten is the Photuris, and the Photuris is the master, and the master is the flash, and the flash is the night.
Predators That Hide, Prey That Hides
Camouflage is used by the hunter and the hunted, and the hunter is the predator, and the hunted is the prey, and the two are the same trick, and the trick is the hiding, and the hiding is the life, and the life is the hunter, and the life is the hunted, and the two are the one, and the one is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the hiding, and the hiding is the survival, and the survival is the both, and the both are the animals, and the animals are the hiding, and the hiding is the art, and the art is the camouflage.
The lioness is the hunter that hides, and the hiding is the grass, and the grass is the dry, and the dry is the tawny, and the tawny is the lioness, and the lioness is the grass, and the grass is the lioness, and the lioness is not seen, and the not-seeing is the hunt, and the hunt is the antelope, and the antelope is the prey, and the prey is the not-seeing, and the not-seeing is the death, and the death is the lioness, and the lioness is the grass. The polar bear is the hunter that hides, and the hiding is the ice, and the ice is the white, and the white is the bear, and the bear is the ice, and the ice is the bear, and the bear is not seen, and the not-seeing is the hunt, and the hunt is the seal, and the seal is the prey, and the prey is the not-seeing, and the not-seeing is the death, and the death is the bear, and the bear is the ice, and the ice is the white, and the white is the bear, and the bear is the black, and the black is the nose, and the nose is the giveaway, and the giveaway is the bear, and the bear covers it with a paw, and the covering is the hunting, and the hunting is the bear.
The frog is the prey that hides, and the hiding is the leaf, and the leaf is the green, and the green is the frog, and the frog is the leaf, and the leaf is the frog, and the frog is not seen, and the not-seeing is the life, and the life is the frog, and the frog is the leaf. The hare is the prey that hides, and the hiding is the snow, and the snow is the white, and the white is the hare, and the hare is the snow, and the snow is the hare, and the hare is not seen, and the not-seeing is the life, and the life is the hare. The difference between the hunter and the hunted is the purpose, and the purpose is the eating, and the eating is the hunter, and the purpose is the not-eating, and the not-eating is the hunted, and the two are the one, and the one is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the hiding, and the hiding is the life, and the life is the both, and the both are the animals, and the animals are the hiding.
The mimic octopus is the animal that does both, and the both are the hiding and the lying, and the hiding is the rock, and the lying is the lionfish, and the lionfish is the flatfish, and the flatfish is the sea snake, and the three are the mimics, and the mimics are the octopus, and the octopus is the three, and the three are the one, and the one is the Thaumoctopus mimicus, and the Thaumoctopus is the octopus, and the octopus is the mimic, and the mimic is the master, and the master is the sea, and the sea is the octopus. It was found in 1998 off Sulawesi, and the finding is the year, and the year is the discovery, and the discovery is the mimic, and the mimic is the octopus, and the octopus is the one that copies fifteen animals, and the fifteen are the lionfish, and the flatfish, and the sea snake, and the twelve others, and the twelve are the copies, and the copies are the octopus, and the octopus is the master, and the master is the mimicry, and the mimicry is the octopus, and the octopus is the sea.
The Costs and Limits of Deception
Deception is never free, and the free is the lie, and the lie is the cost, and the cost is the pigment, and the pigment is the energy, and the energy is the animal, and the animal is the cost, and the cost is the life. The pigments that make the colours are made from food, and the food is the carotenoid, and the carotenoid is the red, and the red is the yellow, and the yellow is the orange, and the orange is the bird, and the bird is the food, and the food is the pigment, and the pigment is the cost, and the cost is the eating, and the eating is the colour, and the colour is the life. The melanin that makes the black is made from amino acids, and the amino acids are the food, and the food is the black, and the black is the cost. The structures that make the blue, and the green, and the iridescent are made from layers, and the layers are the growth, and the growth is the cost, and the cost is the time, and the time is the animal, and the animal is the cost.
The warning colours have a cost that is the opposite of the hiding, and the opposite is the seeing, and the seeing is the predator, and the predator is the bird, and the bird sees the bright, and the bright is the warning, and the warning is the poison, and the poison is the truth, and the truth is the defence, and the defence is the seeing, and the seeing is the risk, because a predator that has never tasted the poison does not know the warning, and the not-knowing is the eating, and the eating is the death, and the death is the young, and the young are the ones that pay, and the paying is the cost, and the cost is the learning, and the learning is the predator, and the predator is the bird, and the bird is the young, and the young are the cost, and the cost is the warning, and the warning is the colour, and the colour is the risk.
Camouflage has a cost that is the stillness, and the stillness is the hiding, and the hiding is the not-moving, and the not-moving is the feeding, and the feeding is the life, and the life is the moving, and the moving is the food, and the food is the stillness, and the stillness is the cost. A camouflaged animal must stay still, and the stillness is the hiding, and the hiding is the survival, and the survival is the stillness, and the stillness is the hunger, and the hunger is the cost, and the cost is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the stillness, and the stillness is the animal, and the animal is the cost. A leaf insect that moves is seen, and the seeing is the death, and the death is the moving, and the moving is the cost, and the cost is the stillness, and the stillness is the leaf, and the leaf is the insect, and the insect is the stillness.
Mimicry has a cost that is the dependence, and the dependence is the model, and the model is the dangerous, and the dangerous is the mimic, and the mimic is the harmless, and the harmless is the dependence, and the dependence is the model, and the model is the numbers, and the numbers are the frequency, and the frequency is the rule, and the rule is the rarer, and the rarer is the mimic, and the mimic is the dependence, and the dependence is the cost, and the cost is the mimicry, and the mimicry is the model, and the model is the dangerous, and the dangerous is the life, and the life is the mimic, and the mimic is the dependence.
| Type of camouflage | How it works | Best example | Main weakness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Background matching | Colour and pattern match the surroundings | Desert fox on sand, peppered moth on bark | Fails when the animal moves to a different background |
| Disruptive coloration | Bold marks break the body outline | Zebra stripes, tiger stripes, leopard rosettes | Bold marks can attract attention at close range |
| Countershading | Dark above, pale below, flattening the shape | Shark, penguin, deer | Useless when light comes from the side or below |
| Disguise (mimesis) | Body copies a leaf, twig or stone | Leaf insect, stick insect, stonefish | Needs stillness; movement breaks the illusion |
| Active colour change | Chromatophores repaint the skin in seconds | Chameleon, cuttlefish, octopus, flounder | Costs energy and needs the brain to read the background |
| Transparency and silvering | Body lets light through or mirrors it | Jellyfish, glassfish, herring | Eyes, gut and bones still give the animal away |
| Seasonal change | Coat or feathers change with the seasons | Arctic fox, snowshoe hare, ptarmigan | A mistimed moult leaves the animal mismatched |
How Predators See Through the Trick
The arms race never ends, and the never is the predator, and the predator is the learning, and the learning is the eye, and the eye is the brain, and the brain is the hunting, and the hunting is the seeing, and the seeing is the trick, and the trick is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the hiding, and the hiding is the predator, and the predator is the seeing, and the seeing is the arms race, and the arms race is the never, and the never is the life.
The first weapon of the predator is the search image, and the search image is the picture, and the picture is the brain, and the brain is the predator, and the predator is the hunting, and the hunting is the looking, and the looking is the image, and the image is the prey, and the prey is the picture, and the picture is the learning, and the learning is the finding, and the finding is the search image, and the search image is the concept of Niko Tinbergen, who saw that a bird that has found one cryptic moth finds the next one faster, and the faster is the image, and the image is the brain, and the brain is the bird, and the bird is the finding, and the finding is the search image, and the search image is the weapon, and the weapon is the predator, and the predator is the learning, and the learning is the eye.
The second weapon is the sense that the eye cannot fool, and the sense is the smell, and the smell is the nose, and the nose is the predator, and the predator is the hunting, and the hunting is the smelling, and the smelling is the prey, and the prey is the smell, and the smell is the animal, and the animal is the scent, and the scent is the giveaway, and the giveaway is the nose, and the nose is the weapon, and the weapon is the predator. A snake hunts by smell, and the smell is the tongue, and the tongue is the snake, and the snake is the smell, and the smell is the prey, and the prey is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the colour, and the colour is the nothing, and the nothing is the smell, and the smell is the giveaway. A bat hunts by sound, and the sound is the echo, and the echo is the bat, and the bat is the sound, and the sound is the prey, and the prey is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the colour, and the colour is the nothing, and the nothing is the sound, and the sound is the giveaway. The eye is the sense that camouflage fools, and the eye is the one, and the one is the sense, and the senses are the many, and the many are the weapons, and the weapons are the predator, and the predator is the senses, and the senses are the arms race, and the arms race is the never.
The third weapon is the learning, and the learning is the memory, and the memory is the taste, and the taste is the poison, and the poison is the mimic, and the mimic is the harmless, and the harmless is the learning, and the learning is the predator, and the predator is the bird, and the bird is the memory, and the memory is the taste, and the taste is the good, and the good is the meal, and the meal is the mimic, and the mimic is the harmless, and the harmless is the eaten, and the eaten is the learning, and the learning is the weapon, and the weapon is the predator, and the predator is the memory, and the memory is the arms race, and the arms race is the never, and the never is the life, and the life is the deception, and the deception is the learning, and the learning is the predator, and the predator is the prey, and the prey is the learning, and the learning is the never.
Camouflage and Mimicry in Pakistan
Pakistan is a land of mountains, and deserts, and forests, and coasts, and the four are the backgrounds, and the backgrounds are the animals, and the animals are the camouflage, and the camouflage is the Pakistan, and the Pakistan is the animals, and the animals are the hiding, and the hiding is the land, and the land is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the Pakistan.
The snow leopard is the master of the mountains, and the master is the grey, and the grey is the rock, and the rock is the snow, and the snow is the leopard, and the leopard is the rock, and the rock is the leopard, and the leopard is not seen, and the not-seeing is the hunting, and the hunting is the markhor, and the markhor is the prey, and the prey is the not-seeing, and the not-seeing is the death, and the death is the leopard, and the leopard is the grey, and the grey is the rosette, and the rosette is the rock, and the rock is the snow, and the snow is the leopard. The markhor is the prey that hides, and the hiding is the brown, and the brown is the cliff, and the cliff is the markhor, and the markhor is the brown, and the brown is the rock, and the rock is the markhor, and the markhor is not seen, and the not-seeing is the life, and the life is the markhor, and the markhor is the cliff.
The desert fox is the master of the Cholistan and the Thar, and the master is the sand, and the sand is the fox, and the fox is the sand, and the sand is the fox, and the fox is not seen, and the not-seeing is the hunting, and the hunting is the gerbil, and the gerbil is the prey, and the prey is the not-seeing, and the not-seeing is the death, and the death is the fox, and the fox is the sand. The common mime butterfly is the mimic of the gardens, and the mimic is the female, and the female is the copy, and the copy is the common rose, and the common rose is the poisonous, and the poisonous is the butterfly, and the butterfly is the female, and the female is the mimic, and the mimic is the common rose, and the common rose is the red, and the red is the black, and the black is the warning, and the warning is the mimic, and the mimic is the female, and the female is the butterfly, and the butterfly is the garden, and the garden is the Pakistan, and the Pakistan is the mimic.
The plain tiger is the model of the plains, and the model is the orange, and the orange is the black, and the black is the warning, and the warning is the poison, and the poison is the milkweed, and the milkweed is the tiger, and the tiger is the plain, and the plain is the butterfly, and the butterfly is the orange, and the orange is the warning, and the warning is the model, and the model is the plain tiger, and the plain tiger is the one that other butterflies copy, and the copying is the Batesian, and the Batesian is the plain, and the plain is the tiger, and the tiger is the model, and the model is the Pakistan, and the Pakistan is the butterfly.
The Evolution of Deception
Deception evolves by natural selection, and the selection is the predator, and the predator is the eye, and the eye is the eating, and the eating is the death, and the death is the visible, and the visible is the eaten, and the eaten is the not-hidden, and the not-hidden is the selection, and the selection is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the hiding, and the hiding is the survival, and the survival is the reproduction, and the reproduction is the colour, and the colour is the offspring, and the offspring are the hidden, and the hidden are the survivors, and the survivors are the camouflage, and the camouflage is the evolution, and the evolution is the selection, and the selection is the predator, and the predator is the eye, and the eye is the eating, and the eating is the never, and the never is the arms race, and the arms race is the evolution, and the evolution is the deception, and the deception is the life.
The arms race is the reason the tricks are so good, and the good is the time, and the time is the millions of years, and the millions are the generations, and the generations are the selection, and the selection is the predator, and the predator is the learning, and the learning is the prey, and the prey is the hiding, and the hiding is the learning, and the learning is the predator, and the predator is the prey, and the prey is the predator, and the two are the one, and the one is the arms race, and the arms race is the never, and the never is the evolution, and the evolution is the deception, and the deception is the arms race, and the arms race is the history, and the history is the animal, and the animal is the deception, and the deception is the history.
The eye is the judge, and the judge is the predator, and the predator is the prey, and the prey is the eye, and the eye is the brain, and the brain is the seeing, and the seeing is the selection, and the selection is the eye, and the eye is the judge, and the judge is the evolution, and the evolution is the eye, and the eye is the deception, and the deception is the eye, and the eye is the animal, and the animal is the eye, and the eye is the subject, and the subject is the camouflage, and the camouflage is the mimicry, and the mimicry is the eye, and the eye is the life, and the life is the seeing, and the seeing is the hiding, and the hiding is the lying, and the lying is the seeing, and the seeing is the eye.
Key Takeaways
- Camouflage hides the animal so it is not found, while mimicry makes it look like something else so it is found and dismissed, and the two are different strategies, not the same word.
- Background matching colours the animal like its surroundings, and the peppered moth proves the selection, with the dark form rising to about ninety-eight in a hundred around Manchester by 1895 and falling again when the air was cleaned.
- Disruptive coloration breaks the body outline with bold marks, so the predator cannot follow the edge, and the zebra, the tiger and the leopard all use it.
- Countershading paints the top dark and the belly pale, cancelling the shadow and flattening the shape, and it is the pattern of sharks, penguins, deer and almost every fish.
- Disguise, or mimesis, copies an object that is not an animal, a leaf, a twig or a stone, and the leaf insect, the stick insect and the stonefish are the masters of it.
- Active colour change uses chromatophores, pigment cells opened and closed by muscles, and chameleons change in seconds, cuttlefish in less than a second, and flounders match even a checkerboard.
- Transparency and silvering hide animals in the open sea, where there is no background to match, and seasonal change follows the year, with the Arctic fox and the snowshoe hare moulting from brown to white.
- Warning colouration is the opposite of hiding, bright colours that advertise poison, and the predator learns the lesson from one bad taste.
- Eyespots and startle displays flash a false face, and the predator hesitates, and the hesitation is the escape.
- Batesian mimicry is a harmless animal copying a dangerous one, and the mimic must stay rarer than the model, and the viceroy butterfly, long called the classic case, is itself distasteful, so it is Mullerian, not Batesian.
- Mullerian mimicry is two dangerous animals sharing one warning, and both benefit, because the predator learns the lesson once and applies it to both.
- Aggressive mimicry is the predator copying the harmless, the anglerfish lure, the bolas spider pheromone, the orchid mantis flower, the false cleanerfish and the firefly femme fatale.
- Deception costs energy, stillness and dependence, and it fails when the background changes, when the predator learns, or when the mimic becomes too common.
- Predators fight back with search images, with smell and hearing, and with learning, and the arms race between hiding and finding never ends.
- Pakistan has its own masters of deception, the snow leopard on grey rock, the markhor on brown cliff, the desert fox on sand, the common mime butterfly and the plain tiger.
Short Questions
1. What is the difference between camouflage and mimicry?
See answer
Camouflage hides the animal so that it is not found at all, by matching the background, breaking up the outline, or flattening the shape with countershading, and the predator passes by because it never sees the prey. Mimicry makes the animal look like something else entirely, a leaf, a twig, a stone, or a poisonous animal, so that the predator sees it and identifies it wrongly, and leaves it alone because the thing it thinks it sees is not worth eating or is dangerous. The leaf insect does both at once, green like the leaves around it and shaped like a leaf itself, and the two together are the lesson, and the lesson is the difference, and the difference is the key to the whole subject.
2. How does a chameleon change colour?
See answer
A chameleon changes colour with chromatophores, which are pigment cells in the skin that hold colour in tiny sacs, and the sacs are opened or squeezed shut by small muscles under the control of nerves, so that spreading the pigment shows the colour and hiding it removes it. Beneath the pigment cells are iridophores, which hold tiny crystals of guanine that reflect light, and the chameleon changes the spacing of the crystals to shift the reflected colour between green, blue and white. The change takes seconds, and it is used for camouflage, for temperature control, and for communication, because a bright male warns a rival and a dark female refuses a suitor, and the colour is the mood.
3. Why do harmless animals copy dangerous ones?
See answer
A harmless animal copies a dangerous one so that predators that have learned to avoid the dangerous model also avoid the harmless copy, and the copy gains the protection without paying the cost of making poison or growing a sting. This is Batesian mimicry, named after Henry Walter Bates, who saw it in Amazon butterflies in 1862, and the classic examples are the hoverfly in the yellow and black bands of a wasp and the king snake in the red, yellow and black bands of the coral snake. The trick only works while the mimics stay rarer than the models, because if predators meet harmless copies more often than dangerous originals, they learn that the colour is a lie and start eating both.
4. What is the difference between Batesian and Mullerian mimicry?
See answer
In Batesian mimicry the mimic is harmless and the model is dangerous, so only the mimic benefits, and the signal is a lie, because the copy carries no poison and no sting. In Mullerian mimicry both species are dangerous, so both benefit, because the predator learns the warning once and applies it to both, and the cost of teaching the predator is shared between them. The Heliconius butterflies of the Amazon are the great Mullerian example, many poisonous species sharing the same red, yellow and black patterns, and the viceroy butterfly, long taught as a Batesian copy of the monarch, is itself distasteful, so it belongs with the Mullerian group, and the correction is the honesty of the science.
5. How do eyespots protect a butterfly?
See answer
Eyespots protect a butterfly in two ways, by frightening the predator and by misleading its attack. The owl butterfly has two large eyespots that look like the eyes of an owl, and a bird that sees them thinks it is being watched by a predator and flies away, and the fear is the defence. The peacock butterfly flashes four eyespots suddenly when its wings open, and the suddenness startles the bird, and the hesitation is the escape. In fish, an eyespot on the tail makes the predator attack the tail instead of the head, and the tail is not vital, and the fish escapes with a torn fin, and the misleading is the defence, and the defence is the false face.
6. Why does camouflage sometimes fail?
See answer
Camouflage fails when the background changes, when the animal moves, when the predator uses a sense other than sight, or when the predator learns. A white snowshoe hare on brown ground after an early snowmelt is seen at once, and a leaf insect that moves is seen at once, and a snake that hunts by smell is not fooled by colour at all, and a bird that has found one cryptic moth forms a search image and finds the next one faster. Seasonal camouflage is timed by day length, not by the snow itself, so a warming climate can leave white animals on brown ground, and the mismatch is the danger, and the danger is the reason the arms race between hiding and finding never ends.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is camouflage in animals?
Camouflage in animals is the set of colours, patterns and shapes that make an animal hard to find, by matching its background, breaking up its outline, flattening its shape with countershading, or changing colour to fit the place it sits on. It works by deceiving the eye, so that the predator passes by without seeing the prey, or the prey never notices the predator until it is too late. The peppered moth is the classic proof, with the dark form rising to about ninety-eight in a hundred around Manchester by 1895 as soot blackened the trees, and falling again when the air was cleaned, and the rising and the falling are the natural selection, and the selection is the camouflage.
What is mimicry in animals?
Mimicry in animals is the resemblance of one animal to another animal, or to an object, so that the animal that sees it is fooled about what it is. A harmless hoverfly copies the yellow and black bands of a wasp, a leaf insect copies a leaf, a stick insect copies a twig, and an anglerfish copies a glowing worm, and each copy is a lie that changes what the other animal does. Mimicry differs from camouflage because the animal is seen, but seen wrongly, while camouflage works by not being seen at all, and the two together are the great deceptions of the animal kingdom.
How do chameleons change colour?
Chameleons change colour with chromatophores, pigment cells in the skin that hold colour in sacs opened and closed by tiny muscles, so that spreading the pigment shows the colour and hiding it removes it, and the change takes seconds. Beneath the pigment cells are iridophores holding tiny crystals of guanine, and the chameleon changes the spacing of the crystals to shift the reflected colour between green, blue and white. The change is used for camouflage, for warming and cooling, and for communication, because a bright male warns a rival and a dark female refuses a suitor, and the colour is the mood, and the mood is the animal.
What is Batesian mimicry?
Batesian mimicry is the mimicry in which a harmless animal copies a dangerous one, so that predators that have learned to avoid the dangerous model also avoid the harmless copy. It is named after Henry Walter Bates, who described it in Amazon butterflies in 1862, and the classic examples are the hoverfly in the bands of a wasp and the king snake in the bands of the coral snake. The mimic gains the protection without paying the cost of poison or a sting, but the trick only works while the mimics stay rarer than the models, because if predators meet harmless copies more often than dangerous originals, they learn that the colour is a lie.
What is Mullerian mimicry?
Mullerian mimicry is the mimicry in which two dangerous animals resemble each other, so that a predator that learns to avoid one also avoids the other, and the cost of teaching the predator is shared between them. It is named after Fritz Muller, who explained it in 1878, and the great examples are the Heliconius butterflies of the Amazon, many poisonous species sharing the same red, yellow and black patterns, and the poison dart frogs of the forest. The viceroy butterfly, long taught as a harmless Batesian copy of the monarch, is itself distasteful to birds, so it belongs with the Mullerian group, and the correction is the honesty of the science.
Do predators also use camouflage?
Yes, predators use camouflage as much as prey do, because the same trick serves hunting as well as hiding. A lioness the colour of dry grass is not seen by the antelope until she is close, a polar bear the colour of ice is not seen by the seal, and a stonefish that looks like a rock is not seen by the small fish that swims up to it. The anglerfish goes further and uses aggressive mimicry, waving a glowing lure like a worm to draw its prey close, and the mimic octopus copies lionfish, flatfish and sea snakes to escape its own enemies, so the same body can be a shield or a sword, and the shield and the sword are the two uses of deception.
Related reading
MCQs
1. What is the main difference between camouflage and mimicry?
- A. Camouflage uses bright colours and mimicry uses dull colours
- B. Camouflage hides the animal so it is not found, while mimicry makes it look like something else so it is found and dismissed
- C. Camouflage is used only by predators and mimicry only by prey
- D. Camouflage changes with the seasons and mimicry never changes
Answer: B
Explanation: Camouflage works by making the animal hard to detect, by matching the background or breaking up the outline, so the predator passes by without seeing it. Mimicry works by making the animal easy to detect but hard to identify correctly, so the predator sees it and names it wrongly, as a leaf, a twig, or a poisonous animal, and leaves it alone.
2. What is countershading?
- A. A dark back and a pale belly, which cancels the shadow and flattens the shape
- B. Bright stripes that warn predators the animal is poisonous
- C. The ability to change colour in seconds
- D. Copying the shape of a leaf or a twig
Answer: A
Explanation: Countershading paints the top of the animal dark and the bottom pale, so the light from above dims the dark top and the shadow brightens the pale belly, and the two cancel, flattening the animal so it looks two-dimensional. It is the pattern of sharks, penguins, dolphins and deer, and it answers the light that comes from above.
3. Which of these is an example of Batesian mimicry?
- A. Two poisonous butterfly species sharing the same warning colours
- B. A stonefish looking like a rock on the reef
- C. A harmless hoverfly wearing the yellow and black bands of a wasp
- D. An anglerfish waving a glowing lure to attract small fish
Answer: C
Explanation: Batesian mimicry is a harmless animal copying a dangerous one, and the hoverfly has no sting yet wears the yellow and black bands of a wasp, so birds that have learned to avoid wasps also avoid the hoverfly. Two poisonous species sharing colours is Mullerian mimicry, a stonefish is disguise, and an anglerfish lure is aggressive mimicry.
4. What is Mullerian mimicry?
- A. A harmless animal copying a dangerous one
- B. A predator copying its prey to get close to it
- C. An animal changing colour to match the seasons
- D. Two dangerous animals resembling each other so predators learn the warning once and avoid both
Answer: D
Explanation: In Mullerian mimicry both species are dangerous, so both benefit, because the predator learns the warning once and applies it to both, and the cost of teaching the predator is shared. The Heliconius butterflies of the Amazon are the great example, many poisonous species sharing the same red, yellow and black patterns.
5. How do chromatophores change an animal's colour?
- A. Pigment cells open and close tiny sacs of colour by muscle action, spreading or hiding the pigment
- B. The animal sheds its skin and grows a new one in a different colour
- C. Sunlight bleaches the fur over the summer
- D. The animal eats different foods that stain its skin
Answer: A
Explanation: A chromatophore is a pigment cell that holds colour in a sac, and tiny muscles pull the sac open to spread the colour or squeeze it shut to hide it, under the control of nerves, so the change takes seconds. Chameleons and cuttlefish use chromatophores, with iridophores beneath them reflecting light from guanine crystals.
6. Which of these is aggressive mimicry?
- A. A leaf insect looking like a leaf
- B. An anglerfish waving a glowing lure like a worm to draw small fish close
- C. A snowshoe hare turning white in winter
- D. A poison dart frog advertising its poison with bright colours
Answer: B
Explanation: Aggressive mimicry is the predator copying something harmless to lure its prey, and the anglerfish waves a glowing lure that looks like a worm, so small fish come close and are eaten. A leaf insect is disguise, a snowshoe hare is seasonal camouflage, and a poison dart frog is warning colouration.
7. How do eyespots protect a butterfly?
- A. They make the butterfly fly faster
- B. They absorb sunlight and warm the wings
- C. They startle predators with a false face and can deflect attacks away from the body
- D. They release a poison when a predator touches them
Answer: C
Explanation: Eyespots look like the eyes of a larger animal, so a bird that sees them thinks it is being watched and flies away, and the sudden flash of the wings startles the predator, and the hesitation is the escape. In fish, an eyespot on the tail makes the predator attack the tail instead of the head, and the fish escapes with a torn fin.
8. What did later research show about the viceroy butterfly?
- A. It is a perfect copy of the monarch in every detail
- B. It has no warning colours at all
- C. It migrates further than the monarch
- D. It is itself distasteful to birds, so it is a Mullerian mimic, not a Batesian one
Answer: D
Explanation: For a century the textbooks called the viceroy a harmless Batesian copy of the poisonous monarch, but experiments showed that the viceroy is itself distasteful to birds, because it stores salicin from willow, so both butterflies are dangerous and share the warning, which is Mullerian mimicry, and the textbooks were corrected.
9. What happened to the peppered moth during industrialisation?
- A. The dark form rose to about ninety-eight in a hundred around Manchester by 1895 as soot blackened the trees
- B. The moths stopped flying during the day
- C. The pale form became poisonous to birds
- D. The moths migrated to cleaner forests
Answer: A
Explanation: Before industry the peppered moth was pale and matched lichen-covered bark, but as soot blackened the trees and killed the lichen, the pale moths stood out and were eaten, and the dark carbonaria form spread until it was about ninety-eight in a hundred around Manchester by 1895. When the air was cleaned, the pale form returned, and the rise and the fall are the proof of natural selection.
10. Which statement about mimicry is FALSE?
- A. Batesian mimics copy dangerous models to avoid being eaten
- B. Mullerian mimics are themselves dangerous
- C. Aggressive mimics copy harmless things to lure prey
- D. Batesian mimics are always more common than the dangerous models they copy
Answer: D
Explanation: The false statement is that Batesian mimics are always more common than their models, because the rule is the opposite, and the mimic must stay rarer than the model. If predators meet harmless copies more often than dangerous originals, they learn that the colour is a lie and start eating both, and the mimicry fails, and the failure is the frequency, and the frequency is the rule.






Comments
Leave a comment