Immune System in Animals: Innate and Adaptive Defences
Immunity is the ability of an animal to recognise what belongs to its own body and to destroy what does not, and it is one of the oldest and most widespread systems in the animal kingdom. Every animal, from a sponge that has no blood and no brain to a human with a thymus and a spleen, is under constant attack: bacteria settle on its surfaces, viruses slip into its cells, fungi grow in its tissues, and parasites burrow into its gut, and every one of those invaders wants the same thing, a warm, wet, nutrient-rich place to live and multiply. An animal that could not defend itself would be eaten alive from the inside, and it would not live long enough to reproduce, so natural selection has equipped every animal with a defence system, and the systems are as varied as the animals themselves. Some animals fight with cells that eat their enemies whole, some with chemicals that punch holes in bacterial walls, some with antibodies so precise that they can tell one strain of virus from another, and some with a memory so good that a second infection is stopped before it starts.
The immune system is not one organ and not one kind of cell: it is a whole network of barriers, cells, molecules and organs that work together, and it works in layers, like the walls of a castle. The outer wall is the skin and the mucus that covers the body's openings, and most invaders never get past it. The guards inside the wall are the cells of the innate immune system, which attack anything that looks foreign, quickly and without needing to be taught, and they are the same in almost every animal, because they are ancient. The elite soldiers behind the guards are the cells of the adaptive immune system, which learn the face of each invader, remember it, and strike it faster and harder the next time, and they exist only in vertebrates, and only in their full form in jawed vertebrates. A sponge has only the guards, a shark has guards and a simpler form of soldiers, and a mammal has both, in their most elaborate form, and the history of immunity is the history of adding layer upon layer to a defence that began with a single cell eating a bacterium.
This article covers the whole subject at full depth: what immunity is and why every animal needs it, the barriers that keep invaders out, phagocytosis and the cells that eat their enemies, antimicrobial peptides and the complement system, inflammation and natural killer cells, the immunity of invertebrates, including insects and their haemocytes, the strange adaptive immunity of jawless fish, which use a completely different molecule from every other vertebrate, the B cells and T cells of jawed vertebrates, antibodies and their classes across animal groups, immune memory, the difference between humoral and cell-mediated responses, the organs where immunity is organised, the ways immunity can go wrong, and the extraordinary immune systems of bats, sharks and axolotls. The science is explained in plain language, and the numbers are given where they matter, because immunity is a subject where the numbers, how many invaders a cell can eat, how many antibodies one cell can make, and how long memory lasts, are the point.
Immune System at a Glance
The immune system of an animal has two great branches, and every defence in the body belongs to one of them, or to both. Innate immunity is the branch an animal is born with: it is fast, acting within minutes of an invasion, it is general, attacking anything that looks foreign without needing to know exactly what it is, and it has no memory, so it fights the hundredth infection exactly as it fought the first. It is the branch that every animal has, from a sponge to a human, and it is built from barriers, phagocytes, antimicrobial peptides, the complement system, inflammation and natural killer cells. Adaptive immunity is the branch an animal learns: it is slow, taking days to reach full strength on a first infection, it is specific, recognising a single molecule on a single invader, and it remembers, so that the second infection is met in hours by cells and antibodies that were made for it. It exists only in vertebrates, and its full form, with B cells, T cells and antibodies, exists only in jawed vertebrates, which is to say in all fish with jaws, amphibians, reptiles, birds and mammals.
The two branches are not rivals: they are partners, and the adaptive branch cannot work without the innate branch. When a bacterium breaks through the skin, it is the innate cells that meet it first, and it is the innate cells that carry pieces of it to the lymph nodes, where they show the pieces to the lymphocytes, the cells of the adaptive branch, and it is that showing, called antigen presentation, that starts the adaptive response. The innate branch also decides how strong the adaptive response will be: the more alarm signals it sends, the more lymphocytes are called up, and the more antibodies are made. And when the adaptive response is over, it is the innate cells that clean up the battlefield, eating the dead bacteria and the dead cells, and the tissue heals. An animal with only innate immunity, like an insect, can fight infection well, but it fights every infection as if it were the first, while an animal with both branches, like a mammal, fights the second infection far better than the first, and that is the advantage that adaptive immunity bought, at the price of a far more complicated system.
The third thing to understand is that immunity is a problem of recognition, and the problem is hard. The body must tell self from non-self, and it must do it in a world where the invaders are constantly changing: a virus mutates, a bacterium swaps genes with its neighbours, a parasite wears a coat of the host's own molecules to hide. The innate branch solves the problem by recognising patterns that are common to whole classes of invaders and absent from the body's own cells: the cell wall of a bacterium, the double-stranded RNA of a virus, the chitin of a fungus, and these patterns are recognised by receptors that are built into the genome, the same in every individual of the species. The adaptive branch solves the problem differently, by making millions of different receptors at random, one per lymphocyte, so that among the millions there will be one that fits almost any invader, and then multiplying the lymphocytes whose receptors fit, a process called clonal selection. The two solutions are complementary: one recognises the familiar, the other the new, and together they cover almost everything that can invade a body.
The First Line: Barriers That Keep Invaders Out
The best defence is the one that never has to fight, and the first line of immunity is a set of barriers that keep invaders out of the body altogether. The skin is the largest of them: in a vertebrate it is a sheet of dead, keratin-filled cells, dry on the outside and constantly shed, so that a bacterium that lands on it is carried away with the dead cells before it can settle, and the skin also makes chemicals that kill bacteria, including fatty acids and the enzyme lysozyme, which cuts the walls of bacterial cells. A frog's skin is different: it is thin and moist, because the frog breathes through it, and it is defended not by dryness but by glands that secrete antimicrobial peptides, and by a layer of mucus that traps bacteria and is constantly renewed. An earthworm's skin is also moist, and it secretes mucus that carries antimicrobial substances, and the mucus is one reason a worm can live in soil that is full of bacteria without being infected. The barrier is matched to the animal's life, and it is always the first thing an invader meets.
The openings of the body are guarded too, and each has its own defence. The mouth and the gut are lined with mucus, and the mucus traps bacteria and is swept away, and the stomach of a vertebrate is filled with acid so strong that it kills most of the bacteria that are swallowed: the pH of a human stomach is about 2, and the pH of a vulture's stomach, which must deal with rotting meat, is about 1, one of the most acidic environments in any animal. The airways are lined with cilia, tiny hairs that beat in waves and carry mucus and trapped dust and bacteria upward and out of the lungs, in the mucociliary escalator, and a single cough can expel air at more than a hundred kilometres an hour. The eyes are washed by tears, which contain lysozyme and antibodies, and the urinary tract is flushed by the flow of urine, and the reproductive tract is guarded by mucus and by an acid environment. Every opening is a door, and every door has a guard, and the guards are the reason most invaders never get inside.
Animals without a skin of their own have other barriers. An insect is covered in a cuticle, a hard shell of chitin, and the cuticle is waterproof and almost impenetrable, and it is the insect's first defence, which is why a wound in the cuticle is so dangerous: it is a breach in the wall, and the insect seals it quickly, with a clot and with melanin, the dark pigment that hardens around the wound and traps the bacteria that entered. A mollusc is protected by its shell, and by the mucus on its soft parts, and a crustacean by its shell and by the same clotting and melanin system that insects use. A sponge, which has no skin at all, is protected by the constant flow of water through its canal system, which carries away the bacteria that settle on it, and by cells that eat the bacteria that remain. The barrier is the cheapest defence there is, because it costs nothing to maintain once it is built, and it is the reason the first question about any infection is always the same: how did the invader get in?
Phagocytosis: The Cells That Eat Invaders
If an invader gets past the barriers, the next defence is a cell that eats it, and phagocytosis, from the Greek for eating cells, is the oldest form of immunity in the animal kingdom, older than antibodies, older than blood, older than the vertebrates themselves. A phagocyte is a cell that can flow around a bacterium, engulf it in a pocket of its own membrane, and digest it inside a vesicle called a phagosome, into which it pours acid and enzymes and toxic chemicals, including hydrogen peroxide and other reactive oxygen species, until the bacterium is destroyed. The process was first described by Élie Metchnikoff in the 1880s, who watched the cells of a starfish larva gather around a thorn he had pushed into it, and who realised that the cells were not building tissue around the thorn but eating the invader, and he called the process phagocytosis, and it won him the Nobel Prize in 1908. Every animal has phagocytes: a sponge has archaeocytes, which wander through its body eating bacteria, an earthworm has coelomocytes, which float in its body cavity, an insect has haemocytes, which circulate in its blood, and a mammal has macrophages and neutrophils, which patrol its tissues and its blood.
The phagocytes of a vertebrate are of two kinds, and each has its own job. Neutrophils are the first to arrive: they are the most numerous white blood cells, making up about sixty percent of the white cells in human blood, and they live for only a few days, and they are made in the bone marrow at a rate of about a hundred billion a day, so that there is always a fresh supply. When an infection starts, the neutrophils leave the blood, squeeze through the walls of the capillaries, and crawl toward the bacteria, following the chemical trail the bacteria leave and the alarm signals the damaged tissue sends, and they eat the bacteria, sometimes ten or twenty each, and then they die, and their death is part of the defence: a neutrophil that has eaten its fill releases its contents, including its DNA, in a net called a neutrophil extracellular trap, which catches and kills the bacteria around it. The pus in a wound is mostly dead neutrophils, and the dead cells are the price of the battle. Macrophages are the second kind: they are larger, they live for months or years in the tissues, and they are the clean-up crew and the messengers. A macrophage eats the bacteria, and it also eats the dead neutrophils, and it carries pieces of the bacteria to the lymph nodes, where it shows them to the lymphocytes, and it is that showing that starts the adaptive response. A macrophage is both a soldier and a scout, and it is the link between the innate and the adaptive branches.
Phagocytosis is not only a defence: it is also a way of feeding, and the two uses are the same process. A sponge eats by phagocytosis: its collar cells trap bacteria from the water and digest them, and the sponge is fed by the same cells that defend it. An amoeba eats by phagocytosis too, and it is the ancestor of every phagocyte: the cell that eats a bacterium to feed itself is the same cell that eats a bacterium to defend the body, and the difference is only in whose body it is. The continuity is the reason phagocytosis is found in every animal: it was invented before animals existed, in single-celled organisms that ate bacteria to live, and when animals evolved, the eating cell was kept, and it was given a new job, defending the body that feeds it. A single macrophage can eat a hundred bacteria in its lifetime, and a human body contains billions of them, and they are the reason most infections are stopped in hours, before the adaptive branch is ever needed.
Antimicrobial Peptides: Chemical Weapons
Not all defence is done by cells: much of it is done by chemicals, and the most widespread of them are the antimicrobial peptides, short chains of amino acids that kill bacteria, fungi and some viruses, and that are made by almost every animal. An antimicrobial peptide is usually small, between twelve and fifty amino acids long, and it carries a positive charge, and it is attracted to the negatively charged surface of a bacterial cell, and it inserts itself into the bacterial membrane and punches holes in it, so that the bacterium leaks and dies. The peptides are fast, acting in minutes, and they are broad in their action, killing many kinds of bacteria at once, and they are hard for bacteria to become resistant to, because resistance would require rebuilding the whole bacterial membrane, which is a far larger change than the single mutation that defeats an antibiotic. The peptides are ancient: they are found in insects, in molluscs, in fish, in frogs, in birds and in mammals, and they are one of the reasons the innate immune system has survived for hundreds of millions of years without being out-evolved by the bacteria.
Insects are the great makers of antimicrobial peptides, and they make them in large numbers and in many kinds. A fruit fly makes a peptide called defensin, which kills Gram-positive bacteria, and a peptide called cecropin, which kills Gram-negative bacteria, and a peptide called drosomycin, which kills fungi, and it makes them in its fat body, the organ that is the insect's liver, and releases them into its blood, the haemolymph, within hours of an infection, so that the blood itself becomes hostile to bacteria. A honeybee makes a peptide called apidaecin, and a silk moth makes a peptide called moricin, and a mosquito makes a peptide called gambicin, and each species has its own set, tuned to the microbes it meets. The peptides are so effective that a fly that has been injected with bacteria can clear the infection in a day, without any antibodies at all, and it is the peptides, with the phagocytes, that do the work. A frog's skin is another factory: it secretes peptides called magainins, which were among the first antimicrobial peptides to be discovered, and they are so potent that they kill bacteria at concentrations that do not harm the frog's own cells, because the frog's own cell membranes are built differently, with a different charge, and the peptides leave them alone.
Vertebrates make antimicrobial peptides too, and they make them in the places where bacteria are most likely to enter. The skin makes a peptide called cathelicidin, which is released when the skin is cut, and it kills the bacteria that enter the wound, and it also calls the white blood cells to the wound, so it is both a weapon and an alarm. The gut makes peptides called defensins, which are released by the Paneth cells in the wall of the small intestine, and they keep the bacteria of the gut from invading the wall, and they shape the community of bacteria that lives in the gut, killing the harmful ones and leaving the useful ones alone. The lungs make a peptide called surfactant protein D, which coats the bacteria that are breathed in and marks them for the macrophages to eat. The peptides are the chemical part of the innate branch, and they are the reason the body's fluids, the blood, the mucus, the tears and the milk, are all hostile to bacteria, and the reason an animal can be wounded and yet not infected, most of the time.
The Complement System: A Cascade in the Blood
The complement system is a set of about thirty proteins that float in the blood of a vertebrate, inactive, until they are needed, and then they activate each other in a chain reaction, a cascade, that ends with the destruction of the invader. The cascade can be started in three ways: by an antibody bound to a bacterium, by a sugar on the surface of a bacterium that the body recognises as foreign, or by the spontaneous breakdown of one of the proteins, which happens all the time, at a low rate, so that the system is always testing the surfaces it meets. The test is the key: the cascade is stopped on the body's own cells by proteins that sit on their surfaces and switch it off, but it is not stopped on a bacterium, which has no such proteins, so the cascade runs to completion on the bacterium and not on the body. The system is a way of marking what is foreign, and it is so precise that it can tell a bacterium from a blood cell, and it does it without any learning, because the proteins are made in the liver and are ready from birth.
The cascade has three jobs, and it does all three at once. The first is opsonisation, from the Greek for making tasty: the proteins coat the bacterium, and the coating is recognised by the receptors on phagocytes, which eat the coated bacterium far more eagerly than an uncoated one, sometimes ten times as eagerly, so that the complement makes phagocytosis much more effective. The second is inflammation: some of the proteins, when they are cut in the cascade, become chemical messengers called anaphylatoxins, which call the white blood cells to the site, open the blood vessels, and make the tissue swell, and they are one of the causes of the redness and heat of an inflamed wound. The third is direct killing: the last proteins in the cascade join together to form a structure called the membrane attack complex, a ring of proteins that punches a hole in the bacterial membrane, like a drill, and the bacterium leaks and dies. The complex is about ten nanometres across, and it is made of five different proteins, and it is one of the most direct weapons in the whole immune system, because it kills the bacterium itself, without any cell being involved.
The complement system is not only for vertebrates: a simpler version exists in invertebrates too, and it is one of the oldest parts of immunity. A horseshoe crab, an animal that has changed little in hundreds of millions of years, has a complement-like system in its blood, and it clots around bacteria and kills them, and the clotting is so sensitive that it is used in medicine to test drugs for bacterial contamination: the Limulus amoebocyte lysate test, made from the blood of the horseshoe crab, can detect a billionth of a gram of bacterial toxin, and it is used to test every injectable drug and every vaccine. The complement system of a mammal is more elaborate, with more proteins and more control, but it is built on the same idea, a cascade that marks the foreign and spares the self, and it is the reason the blood itself is a hostile place for a bacterium, and the reason a bacterium that gets into the blood must fight the complement as well as the cells.
Inflammation: Redness, Heat, Swelling and Pain
Inflammation is the visible sign that the immune system is working, and it is the oldest clinical sign in medicine: the Roman physician Celsus described it two thousand years ago as rubor, tumor, calor and dolor, redness, swelling, heat and pain, and the description is still accurate. When a tissue is injured or infected, the cells of the innate branch release chemical messengers, including histamine, prostaglandins and cytokines, and the messengers do four things: they widen the blood vessels, so that more blood flows to the area, which is the redness and the heat; they make the vessel walls leaky, so that fluid and white blood cells escape into the tissue, which is the swelling; they call the neutrophils and the macrophages to the site, by a chemical trail; and they sensitise the nerve endings, which is the pain. The pain is not an accident: it is a signal that makes the animal protect the injured part, and it is the reason an animal with a wounded leg will not walk on it, and will rest it until it heals.
Inflammation is a double-edged sword, and it must be controlled, because the same chemicals that kill bacteria can damage the body's own tissues. A neutrophil that releases its toxic chemicals into the tissue kills the bacteria, but it also damages the cells around it, and a macrophage that releases cytokines can call up so many white blood cells that the tissue is flooded with them, and the swelling can cut off the blood supply. The body controls inflammation with a second set of messengers, the anti-inflammatory cytokines, which are released as the infection is cleared, and which tell the white blood cells to stop, and tell the tissue to start repairing itself. The repair is done by the macrophages, which eat the dead cells and the debris, and by the fibroblasts, which lay down new collagen, and by the blood vessels, which grow back into the damaged area. A wound that heals cleanly is a wound in which the inflammation was strong enough to kill the invaders and short enough not to destroy the tissue, and the balance is the reason inflammation is both the most visible and the most carefully regulated part of immunity.
Inflammation is not only a response to infection: it is also a response to injury, and it is the reason a bruise swells and a sprain hurts, even when no bacteria are present. The damaged cells release the same alarm signals as an infected cell, and the white blood cells come, and they clean up the dead cells, and the tissue heals, and the process is the same whether the cause is a bacterium or a blow. Chronic inflammation, which goes on for weeks or months, is a different matter: it damages the tissue it is meant to protect, and it is involved in diseases from arthritis to heart disease, and it is the reason the immune system must be able to switch inflammation off as well as on. The switch is the anti-inflammatory cytokines, and the cells that make them, the regulatory T cells, are one of the most important parts of the adaptive branch, because they are the brakes on the whole system, and without them the immune system would attack the body it is meant to defend.
Natural Killer Cells: The Patrol That Needs No Introduction
Natural killer cells, or NK cells, are the patrol of the immune system, and they are named for what they do: they kill, and they do it naturally, without needing to be taught who the enemy is. An NK cell is a lymphocyte, a cell of the adaptive branch by birth, but it behaves like a cell of the innate branch, because it does not need a specific antigen to act, and it does not need to be shown the invader by another cell. It works by a simple rule: it inspects the cells it meets, and it kills the ones that are wrong. A healthy cell carries on its surface a set of molecules called MHC class I, which are the cell's identity card, and the NK cell reads the card with its inhibitory receptors, and if the card is present, it leaves the cell alone. A cell that has been infected by a virus, or a cell that has become cancerous, often stops showing its MHC class I, because the virus tells it to, or because the cancer has damaged the machinery, and the NK cell, finding no card, kills it. The rule is called missing self, and it is the opposite of the rule the T cells use, which is to look for a foreign card, and the two rules together cover both kinds of wrong cell.
NK cells are the first defence against viruses, and they are the reason most viral infections are stopped before the adaptive branch is ever needed. A virus that infects a cell must hide from the T cells, and it does it by telling the cell to stop showing its MHC class I, so that the T cells cannot see the viral proteins it is making, but in hiding from the T cells it exposes itself to the NK cells, which kill it for having no card, and the virus is caught between the two. Some viruses have learned to fight back: the cytomegalovirus makes a false MHC molecule, a decoy, which it puts on the surface of the infected cell, and the NK cell reads the decoy and leaves the cell alone, and the virus survives, and the battle continues, with each side evolving new tricks. The NK cells are also the defence against cancer: a cancer cell that has lost its MHC is killed by the NK cells, and a cancer that keeps its MHC is killed by the T cells, and it is only the cancers that can defeat both that grow into tumours. The patrol is not perfect, but it is fast, and it is always on duty, and it is the reason the body can fight a virus in hours, before the antibodies are made.
NK cells are not only killers: they are also messengers, and they make cytokines that call up the rest of the immune system. When an NK cell kills an infected cell, it releases interferon-gamma, a cytokine that tells the macrophages to eat more eagerly, and tells the blood vessels to let more white blood cells through, and tells the neighbouring cells to make antiviral proteins, so that the infection is contained while the adaptive branch is being prepared. The NK cells are found in the blood, in the spleen, in the liver and in the lungs, and they are most numerous where the body meets the outside world, in the gut and in the skin, where the invaders enter. They are the patrol that needs no introduction, and they are the reason the immune system can act before it has learned who the enemy is.
Invertebrate Immunity: Defence Without Antibodies
Most animals on Earth are invertebrates, and none of them has antibodies, and none of them has B cells or T cells, and yet they are not defenceless: they have an innate immune system that is rich, effective, and in some ways more sophisticated than the innate branch of a vertebrate. A sponge, the simplest animal, has no blood and no organs, but it has cells that eat bacteria, and it has molecules that recognise the patterns on bacterial surfaces, and it rejects a graft of another sponge's tissue, which means it can tell self from non-self, and it does it with receptors that are the ancestors of the receptors in a human. An earthworm has cells in its body cavity, the coelomocytes, that eat bacteria, and it has a fluid, the coelomic fluid, that contains antimicrobial peptides and a complement-like system, and it can be immunised, in a limited way: a worm that has survived one infection fights the next one better, not because it has memory cells, but because its phagocytes have been primed, a phenomenon called trained immunity, which is now known to exist in vertebrates too.
A mollusc, such as an oyster or a snail, has a blood that is full of haemocytes, cells that eat bacteria, and it has a fluid that contains antimicrobial peptides and a complement-like system, and it has a remarkable ability to reject a parasite: a snail that is infected by a trematode, a parasitic flatworm, can encapsulate the parasite, surrounding it with layers of haemocytes, and then melanise it, coating it in the dark pigment melanin, which hardens around it and kills it, and the encapsulation is so effective that some snails are resistant to parasites that kill other snails, and the resistance is inherited, which means it is genetic, and it is the reason some populations of snails survive in waters where the parasite is common. A crustacean, such as a shrimp or a crab, has the same system, and it has in addition a clotting system that seals a wound in seconds, and a prophenoloxidase cascade, which is described in the next section, and which is one of the most powerful defences in any invertebrate.
The invertebrate immune system is not a poor cousin of the vertebrate system: it is a different solution to the same problem, and it has its own strengths. It is fast, because it does not need to learn, and it is broad, because it recognises whole classes of invaders, and it is cheap, because it does not need the elaborate organs and the millions of different receptors that the adaptive branch requires. Its weakness is that it has no memory, so it fights every infection as if it were the first, and it cannot make antibodies, so it cannot neutralise a toxin as precisely as a vertebrate can. But the invertebrates are the most numerous and the most successful animals on Earth, and they have survived for hundreds of millions of years with only innate immunity, which is proof that the system works, and it is the reason the study of invertebrate immunity is not a study of a primitive system, but a study of a system that has been tested by evolution longer than any other.
Insect Immunity: Haemocytes and the Phenoloxidase Cascade
Insects are the most numerous animals on land, and they live in a world full of bacteria, fungi and parasites, and they defend themselves with an immune system that is entirely innate, and entirely effective. An insect's blood, the haemolymph, is an open system: it bathes the organs directly, in a body cavity called the haemocoel, and it carries the cells of immunity, the haemocytes, which are of several kinds. The plasmatocytes are the phagocytes: they eat bacteria, and they are the most numerous haemocytes, making up most of the cells in the blood. The granulocytes are the cells that release the chemicals of defence, including the antimicrobial peptides and the enzymes of the phenoloxidase cascade. The lamellocytes are the cells that encapsulate large invaders: when a parasitic wasp lays an egg inside a fly larva, the lamellocytes gather around the egg, in layers, and they melanise it, and the egg is killed, and the larva survives. The crystal cells are the cells that carry the prophenoloxidase, the inactive form of the enzyme that makes melanin, and they burst open when they are needed, releasing the enzyme into the blood.
The phenoloxidase cascade is the insect's most distinctive weapon, and it is a chain reaction like the complement system of a vertebrate. When a bacterium or a fungus enters the insect, the pattern-recognition receptors in the blood recognise the patterns on its surface, the peptidoglycan of a bacterium or the glucan of a fungus, and they activate a series of enzymes, the serine proteases, which cut each other in turn, and the last of them cuts the prophenoloxidase, turning it into phenoloxidase, and the phenoloxidase makes melanin, the dark pigment, from the amino acid tyrosine. The melanin is deposited around the invader, and it hardens, and it traps the invader, and the chemicals made on the way to melanin, the quinones, are toxic, and they kill the invader directly. The cascade is so fast that a wound in an insect is sealed with melanin in minutes, and the dark spot on the cuticle is the sign that the cascade has worked. The cascade is also dangerous, because the quinones are toxic to the insect's own cells, so it is controlled by inhibitors, the serpins, which stop the cascade when it has done its job, and the balance between the cascade and its inhibitors is the reason the insect can melanise an invader without melanising itself.
Insects also make antimicrobial peptides, and they make them in large numbers: the fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, has genes for about twenty different peptides, and it makes them in its fat body, the organ that is the insect's liver, and releases them into the haemolymph within hours of an infection. The peptides are regulated by two signalling pathways, the Toll pathway, which responds to fungi and Gram-positive bacteria, and the IMD pathway, which responds to Gram-negative bacteria, and the two pathways are the ancestors of the pathways that regulate immunity in a human: the Toll receptor of the fly is the ancestor of the Toll-like receptors of a mammal, and the IMD pathway is related to the TNF pathway of a mammal, which means that the molecules that control immunity in a human were first worked out in a fly. The fly has become the great model for the study of immunity, because its genes are easy to change, and its immune system is easy to study, and the discoveries made in the fly have been found, again and again, to apply to humans, which is why the fruit fly, a creature with no antibodies, has taught us so much about the immune system that does have them.
Jawless Fish: A Different Kind of Adaptive Immunity
The jawless fish, the lampreys and the hagfish, are the only living vertebrates without jaws, and they are also the only living vertebrates without antibodies, and for a long time it was thought that they had no adaptive immunity at all. The truth, discovered in the early 2000s, is stranger and more interesting: they have an adaptive immune system, but it is built from completely different molecules, and it evolved independently, which means that adaptive immunity evolved twice, once in the jawless fish and once in the jawed vertebrates, and the two systems are a remarkable case of convergent evolution. The jawless fish do not have B cells or T cells or antibodies, and they do not have the genes that make them, the RAG genes, which are the genes that rearrange the antibody genes in a jawed vertebrate. Instead they have lymphocytes that make receptors called variable lymphocyte receptors, or VLRs, which are built from pieces of a protein called leucine-rich repeat, and which are assembled by a different mechanism, by copying and pasting pieces of DNA, so that each lymphocyte makes a different VLR, and the VLRs are as diverse as antibodies, with millions of different forms, and they can recognise almost any invader.
The VLR system works in the same way as the antibody system, but with different parts. A lamprey has two kinds of lymphocytes: one kind makes VLRB, which is secreted into the blood, like an antibody, and which binds to the invader and marks it for destruction, and the other kind makes VLRA, which sits on the surface of the cell, like a T-cell receptor, and which recognises the invader and tells the cell to kill it. The VLRB is a Y-shaped molecule, like an antibody, but it is built from leucine-rich repeats, not from immunoglobulin domains, and it binds to its target with a curved surface, like a hand gripping a ball, rather than with the flat surface of an antibody. The diversity is generated by a mechanism called gene conversion, in which pieces of DNA are copied from one place to another, and the result is a repertoire of millions of different receptors, made from a few hundred pieces of DNA, in the same way that the antibody repertoire is made from a few hundred gene segments. The system is a complete adaptive immune system, with recognition, memory and specificity, and it is built from different molecules, which is proof that evolution can solve the same problem twice, in two different ways.
The discovery of the VLR system changed the story of immunity, because it showed that adaptive immunity is not a single invention, but a problem that was solved twice, and it raised the question of which came first. The jawless fish are the older lineage, and their system is the older one, and the jawed vertebrates, which include all the fish with jaws, the amphibians, the reptiles, the birds and the mammals, have the newer system, built from antibodies and T-cell receptors, and the two systems have never been found in the same animal, which means that the ancestor of all vertebrates had neither, and each lineage invented its own. The VLRs are now used in medicine: they are being developed as research tools and as therapies, because they are small, stable and easy to make, and they can be engineered to bind to almost anything, and they are a reminder that the immune system of a lamprey, a creature that looks primitive, is in fact a sophisticated and independent invention, and that the history of immunity is longer and stranger than was thought.
Jawed Vertebrates: The Adaptive Immune System
The adaptive immune system of jawed vertebrates is built from two kinds of lymphocytes, the B cells and the T cells, and both are made in the bone marrow, and both are educated to recognise the body's own molecules and to ignore them, and both are capable of remembering an invader for years. The B cells are the makers of antibodies: each B cell makes a single kind of antibody, and it puts the antibody on its surface, as a receptor, and when the antibody binds to its target, the antigen, the B cell is activated, and it divides, and it makes plasma cells, which secrete the antibody into the blood in large numbers, and memory cells, which live for years and wait for the invader to return. The T cells are the killers and the coordinators: the cytotoxic T cells, also called CD8 T cells, kill the cells that are infected by a virus or that have become cancerous, and the helper T cells, also called CD4 T cells, coordinate the response, telling the B cells to make antibodies and telling the macrophages to eat more eagerly. The two kinds of cell work together, and neither can do its job alone.
The diversity of the adaptive system is made by a process that is unique in biology: the genes for the antibody and the T-cell receptor are not inherited in their final form, but are assembled in each lymphocyte, by cutting and pasting pieces of DNA, in a process called V(D)J recombination, and the cutting is done by enzymes called RAG1 and RAG2, which are the genes that the jawless fish do not have. Each antibody gene is made from three kinds of pieces, the V, the D and the J segments, and there are many pieces of each kind, and the lymphocyte chooses one of each, at random, and joins them together, and the joining is imprecise, so that the junction adds further variety, and the result is a repertoire of millions of different antibodies, made from a few hundred pieces of DNA. The same process makes the T-cell receptors, and the result is a repertoire of millions of different T cells, each with a different receptor, and among the millions there will be one that fits almost any invader, and the one that fits is the one that is multiplied, in clonal selection, so that the body makes more of the cells that work and fewer of the cells that do not.
The adaptive system must also learn what not to attack, and it learns it in the thymus and in the bone marrow, in a process called central tolerance. A T cell that is made in the bone marrow travels to the thymus, and there it is shown the body's own molecules, and if its receptor binds to them strongly, it is killed, in a process called negative selection, and only the T cells that do not bind to the body's own molecules are allowed to live. A B cell that is made in the bone marrow is tested in the same way, and if its antibody binds to the body's own molecules, it is killed, or it is made harmless, by a process called anergy. The education is not perfect: some self-reactive cells escape, and they are controlled by the regulatory T cells, which suppress them, and by the fact that a lymphocyte needs two signals to be activated, the antigen and a second signal from the innate branch, and a self-reactive cell that meets its antigen without the second signal is not activated, and it dies. The system is a balance, and the balance is delicate, and when it fails, the result is autoimmunity, in which the immune system attacks the body it is meant to defend.
B Cells and Antibodies: The Humoral Response
An antibody is a Y-shaped molecule, made of four chains of protein, two heavy chains and two light chains, and the tips of the Y are the parts that bind to the antigen, and the stem of the Y is the part that tells the rest of the immune system what to do. Each antibody binds to a single antigen, and it binds to it with a precision that is extraordinary: an antibody made against one strain of influenza will not bind to another strain, and an antibody made against one protein will not bind to a protein that differs from it by a single amino acid, in some cases. The binding is the recognition, and the stem is the action: once the antibody has bound, its stem can activate the complement system, and it can be recognised by the receptors on phagocytes, which eat the antibody-coated invader far more eagerly, and it can be recognised by the NK cells, which kill the antibody-coated cell, in a process called antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity. The antibody is both a sensor and a signal, and it is the reason the humoral response, the response in the blood and the other fluids, is so effective.
A single plasma cell can make about two thousand antibody molecules a second, and it can keep doing it for days, so that a single activated B cell, multiplied into thousands of plasma cells, can flood the blood with millions of antibodies, and the antibodies can reach every part of the body, because they travel in the blood, carried around the body by the circulatory system, and in the lymph, and they can cross into the tissues, and they can be secreted into the mucus, the tears and the milk. The antibodies do their work in several ways: they neutralise, by binding to a virus and stopping it from entering a cell, and by binding to a toxin and stopping it from reaching its target; they opsonise, by coating a bacterium and marking it for the phagocytes; they activate the complement, by binding to a bacterium and starting the cascade; and they agglutinate, by binding to several bacteria at once and clumping them together, so that they are easier to eat. A toxin that is neutralised by an antibody is harmless, even though it is still present, because it cannot reach its target, and a virus that is neutralised cannot enter a cell, and it is cleared by the phagocytes, and the neutralisation is the reason antibodies are the most direct defence against the poisons and the viruses that the body meets.
Antibodies are also the basis of passive immunity, the immunity that is given, not made, and that protects an animal before its own immune system is ready. A mammal passes antibodies to its young in the milk, and in the first milk, the colostrum, which is rich in antibodies, and the young animal, whose own immune system is not yet working, is protected by its mother's antibodies, for the first weeks of its life, until it can make its own. A bird passes antibodies into the yolk of its egg, and the chick hatches with its mother's antibodies already in its blood, and it is protected for the first days of its life. A fish passes antibodies into its eggs too, and the fry are protected by them. Passive immunity is temporary, because the antibodies are not replaced, and they fade over weeks, but it is vital, because the young animal is at its most vulnerable, and it is the reason the first milk is so important, and the reason a newborn animal that does not receive colostrum is far more likely to die of infection. The same principle is used in medicine: an antivenom is made of antibodies, taken from a horse that has been immunised against a snake venom, and it is given to a person who has been bitten, and it neutralises the venom, and it is passive immunity, given from one animal to another.
Antibody Classes Across Animal Groups
Not all antibodies are the same, and the classes of antibody, the isotypes, differ from one group of animals to another, and the differences tell the story of how the adaptive system evolved. A mammal has five classes: IgM, which is the first antibody made in an infection, and which is a large molecule, made of five Y-shaped units joined together, so that it has ten binding sites, and it is the best at activating the complement; IgG, which is the most abundant antibody in the blood, and which is made later in the infection, and which crosses the placenta and protects the unborn young; IgA, which is secreted into the mucus, the tears, the saliva and the milk, and which guards the surfaces of the body; IgE, which is involved in allergy and in the defence against parasitic worms, and which binds to the mast cells and causes them to release histamine; and IgD, which sits on the surface of B cells and helps to activate them. A bird has three classes: IgM, IgY, which is the equivalent of the mammalian IgG, and which is passed into the yolk of the egg, and IgA, which is secreted into the mucus. An amphibian has IgM, IgY and IgX, which is the equivalent of IgA, and a reptile has IgM, IgY and IgA. A bony fish has IgM and IgT, which is the equivalent of IgA, and which guards the mucus of the gills and the gut, and a shark has IgM and IgNAR, a strange antibody that is made of a single chain, not four, and that is the smallest antibody known, and that is so stable that it can survive conditions that would destroy a mammalian antibody, and it is being developed as a drug.
| Animal group | Antibody classes | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Jawless fish (lampreys, hagfish) | None — VLRs instead | Variable lymphocyte receptors, built from leucine-rich repeats; VLRB secreted like an antibody, VLRA on the cell surface like a T-cell receptor |
| Cartilaginous fish (sharks, rays) | IgM, IgNAR | IgNAR is a single-chain antibody, the smallest known, exceptionally stable; sharks also make IgM in a pentameric form |
| Bony fish | IgM, IgT (also called IgZ) | IgT guards the mucus of the gills and gut; IgM is the main antibody in the blood |
| Amphibians | IgM, IgY, IgX | IgX is the equivalent of IgA and guards the mucosal surfaces; IgY is passed to the eggs |
| Reptiles | IgM, IgY, IgA | IgY is the equivalent of the mammalian IgG; IgA guards the mucosal surfaces |
| Birds | IgM, IgY, IgA | IgY is passed into the yolk and protects the chick; IgA guards the mucus of the gut and airways |
| Mammals | IgM, IgG, IgA, IgE, IgD | Five classes, the most elaborate set; IgG crosses the placenta, IgA is in the milk, IgE fights parasitic worms and causes allergy |
The pattern is clear: the classes were added one by one, as the vertebrates evolved, and each new class was a new job. IgM is the oldest, and it is found in every jawed vertebrate, and it is the first antibody made in an infection, and it is the best at activating the complement. IgY, the equivalent of IgG, appeared in the amphibians, and it is the antibody that is passed to the young, and it is the most abundant in the blood. IgA, the antibody of the mucus, appeared later, and it is the antibody that guards the surfaces, and it is the most abundant antibody made by the body, because the surfaces are the largest part of the body that meets the outside world. IgE, the antibody of allergy and of worms, is found only in mammals, and it is the newest, and it is the one that causes the most trouble, because it is the antibody that makes the mast cells release histamine, and histamine is the cause of the itching and the swelling of an allergy. The classes are a history, and the history is written in the blood of every vertebrate.
T Cells: The Cell-Mediated Response
T cells are the lymphocytes that do not make antibodies, and they are the cells that fight the invaders that antibodies cannot reach: the viruses inside cells, the bacteria inside cells, and the body's own cells that have become cancerous. A T cell does not recognise a free antigen, as an antibody does: it recognises a fragment of the antigen, presented on the surface of another cell, by a molecule called MHC, the major histocompatibility complex. Every cell in the body carries MHC class I on its surface, and it uses it to show the T cells what it is making inside: if a cell is infected by a virus, it shows the viral proteins on its MHC class I, and the cytotoxic T cell, the CD8 T cell, recognises the fragment, and it kills the cell, by releasing chemicals that punch holes in it and that tell it to die, in a process called apoptosis. The killing is precise: the T cell kills only the infected cell, and it leaves the healthy cells around it alone, and it can kill several infected cells in a row, one after another, without being harmed itself.
The helper T cells, the CD4 T cells, are the coordinators, and they do not kill: they tell the other cells what to do. A helper T cell recognises a fragment of the antigen presented on MHC class II, which is found only on the antigen-presenting cells, the macrophages, the dendritic cells and the B cells, and when it recognises the fragment, it releases cytokines, the chemical messengers of the immune system, and the cytokines tell the B cells to make antibodies, and tell the macrophages to eat more eagerly, and tell the cytotoxic T cells to kill more effectively. The helper T cells come in kinds: the Th1 cells help the macrophages and the cytotoxic T cells, and they fight the invaders inside cells, and the Th2 cells help the B cells, and they fight the invaders outside cells, and the Th17 cells help the neutrophils, and they fight the bacteria and fungi on the surfaces, and the regulatory T cells, the Tregs, suppress the response, and they are the brakes that stop the immune system from attacking the body. The balance between the kinds decides what kind of response the body makes, and the balance is set by the cytokines that the innate branch releases when it first meets the invader.
The T cells are educated in the thymus, a small organ in the chest, and the education is the strictest in the whole immune system. A T cell that is made in the bone marrow travels to the thymus, and there it is tested: first it must show that its receptor can recognise MHC at all, in a process called positive selection, and if it cannot, it dies, and then it must show that its receptor does not bind to the body's own molecules, in a process called negative selection, and if it does, it dies, and only the T cells that pass both tests are allowed to live, and only about two percent of the T cells that enter the thymus survive it. The thymus is largest in a young animal, and it shrinks with age, and an old animal makes fewer new T cells, which is one reason an old animal is more vulnerable to infection, and to cancer. The T cells that survive the thymus circulate in the blood and in the lymph, and they wait, sometimes for years, for the antigen they recognise, and when they meet it, they divide, and they make effector cells, which fight, and memory cells, which remember, and the memory is the reason the second infection is met faster and harder than the first.
Immune Memory: Why the Second Infection Is Different
Immune memory is the reason a vaccine works, and it is the reason a person who has had measles once does not get it again, and it is the adaptive branch's greatest advantage over the innate branch. When a lymphocyte meets its antigen for the first time, it divides, and it makes effector cells, which fight the infection, and memory cells, which live for years, sometimes for a lifetime, and which wait for the invader to return. The memory cells are more numerous than the naive cells were, and they are quicker to respond, and they need less stimulation to be activated, so that the second infection is met in hours, by cells and antibodies that were made for it, while the first infection took days, and the second infection is often stopped before it causes any symptoms at all. The memory is the reason the second dose of a vaccine is more effective than the first, and the reason a booster is given: the booster reminds the memory cells, and it makes more of them, and it makes the antibodies stronger, in a process called affinity maturation, in which the B cells that make the best antibodies are selected, and the antibodies become more precise with each exposure.
The memory is carried in two forms: the memory cells, and the antibodies that remain in the blood after the infection is over. The antibodies fade over time, but the memory cells do not, and they are the reason the protection lasts, even when the antibodies are gone: the memory B cells can make new antibodies in days, when the invader returns, and the memory T cells can kill the infected cells in hours, and the speed is the protection. The memory is not perfect: some viruses mutate so fast that the memory is useless, because the virus that returns is not the virus that was remembered, and the influenza virus is the classic example, changing its surface proteins every year, so that a new vaccine is needed every year, and the memory of last year's virus does not protect against this year's. Some infections leave no memory at all, because the invader suppresses the immune system, or because the infection is so short that the memory is never made, and some animals have a shorter memory than others, because their memory cells do not live as long. But for most infections, the memory lasts for years, and for some, such as measles and smallpox, it lasts for a lifetime, and it is the reason those diseases, once survived, are never caught again.
The memory is also the reason vaccination works, and vaccination is the deliberate use of immune memory to protect an animal before it meets the disease. A vaccine is a harmless form of the invader, a killed virus, a weakened bacterium, or a piece of the invader's protein, and it is given to the animal, and the animal's immune system makes memory cells against it, without ever having the disease, and when the real invader arrives, the memory cells are ready, and the infection is stopped before it starts. Vaccination is used in animals as well as in humans: dogs are vaccinated against rabies and distemper, cattle against foot-and-mouth disease, chickens against Newcastle disease, and fish against bacterial infections, and the vaccination of livestock is one of the great achievements of veterinary medicine, because it has saved millions of animals, and it has protected the food supply. The memory is the immune system's library, and vaccination is the way of filling the library before the exam, rather than during it.
Humoral Versus Cell-Mediated Immunity
The adaptive response has two arms, and they fight different kinds of invader. Humoral immunity is the immunity of the fluids, the blood and the lymph, and it is carried by the antibodies, which are made by the B cells, and it fights the invaders that are outside cells: the bacteria in the blood, the toxins in the tissues, and the viruses before they enter a cell. Cell-mediated immunity is the immunity of the cells, and it is carried by the T cells, and it fights the invaders that are inside cells: the viruses that have already entered a cell, the bacteria that hide inside a macrophage, and the body's own cells that have become cancerous. The two arms are not independent: the helper T cells coordinate both, and the antibodies help the cells, by marking the invaders for the phagocytes, and the cells help the antibodies, by killing the infected cells that the antibodies cannot reach. The balance between the two arms is set by the kind of invader: a bacterium in the blood calls up the humoral arm, and a virus inside a cell calls up the cell-mediated arm, and the body makes the response that fits the enemy.
| Feature | Humoral immunity | Cell-mediated immunity |
|---|---|---|
| Carried by | Antibodies in the blood and other fluids | T cells, especially cytotoxic and helper T cells |
| Made by | B cells and plasma cells | T cells, educated in the thymus |
| Fights | Bacteria and toxins outside cells; viruses before they enter cells | Viruses and bacteria inside cells; cancerous cells |
| How it works | Antibodies neutralise, opsonise and activate complement | T cells kill infected cells directly and release cytokines |
| Transferred by | Serum, milk, colostrum (passive immunity) | Cells only, not by serum |
| Memory | Memory B cells and long-lived plasma cells | Memory T cells |
| Defence fails when | B cells are absent, as in some immunodeficiencies | T cells are absent, as in severe combined immunodeficiency |
The distinction between the two arms was proved by a classic experiment, in which the serum of an immunised animal was transferred to a naive animal, and the naive animal became protected against the disease, which showed that the protection was in the fluid, the antibodies, and in which the cells of an immunised animal were transferred to a naive animal, and the naive animal became protected, which showed that the protection was also in the cells, and the two experiments, done in the 1940s and 1950s, established the two arms, and they are still the basis of immunology. The two arms are also the basis of the two kinds of vaccine: a vaccine that makes antibodies protects against the invaders outside cells, and a vaccine that makes T cells protects against the invaders inside cells, and the best vaccines make both, because most invaders are fought by both arms, at different stages of the infection.
The Immune Organs: Where Defence Is Organised
Immunity is organised in organs, and the organs are of two kinds: the primary organs, where the lymphocytes are made and educated, and the secondary organs, where the lymphocytes meet the invaders and are activated. The primary organs are the bone marrow and the thymus. The bone marrow is where all the blood cells are made, including the B cells and the T cells, and it is where the B cells are educated, tested against the body's own molecules and killed if they react to them. The thymus is where the T cells are educated, in the strictest test in the body, and it is the organ that shrinks with age, and whose shrinking is one reason the immune system weakens with age. A bird has a third primary organ, the bursa of Fabricius, a small sac near the cloaca, where the B cells are educated, and it is the organ that gave the B cell its name: the B stands for bursa, and the T stands for thymus, and the two organs are the schools where the lymphocytes learn their trade.
The secondary organs are the lymph nodes, the spleen and the mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue, and they are the places where the immune response happens. The lymph nodes are small, bean-shaped organs, scattered along the lymphatic vessels, and they filter the lymph, the fluid that drains from the tissues, and they are full of B cells and T cells, and when a bacterium is carried into a lymph node by the lymph, the lymphocytes that recognise it are activated there, and they divide, and the node swells, which is why the glands in the neck swell when a person has a throat infection: the lymph nodes are working. The spleen is the largest lymphoid organ, and it filters the blood, not the lymph, and it removes the old red blood cells, whose breakdown products are cleared by the organs of excretion, and it is full of B cells and T cells, and it is where the response to a blood-borne infection is organised, and an animal without a spleen is more vulnerable to the bacteria that live in the blood. The mucosa-associated lymphoid tissue, the MALT, is the collection of lymphoid tissue in the gut, the airways and the other mucosal surfaces, including the Peyer's patches in the wall of the small intestine, and it is where the response to the invaders that enter through the gut and the airways is organised, and it is the largest part of the immune system, because the gut is the largest surface that meets the outside world.
Fish have a simpler organisation, and their immune organs are different, because they have no lymph nodes and no bone marrow. A fish makes its blood cells in the kidney, which is its primary lymphoid organ, and it has a spleen, which filters the blood, and it has lymphoid tissue in its gut and in its gills, and the gills are a major immune organ, because they are a large surface that meets the water, and they are full of lymphocytes, and they are the first place a water-borne invader meets the immune system. A shark has a special organ, the epigonal organ, which is attached to the gonads, and which makes blood cells, and a Leydig organ, which is in the wall of the oesophagus, and which also makes blood cells, and the two organs are the shark's equivalent of the bone marrow. The organisation is different in every group, but the principle is the same: the lymphocytes are made in one place, educated in another, and activated where the invaders enter, and the organs are the places where the meetings happen.
Innate Versus Adaptive Immunity
The two branches of immunity differ in almost every way, and the differences are the reason both are needed. Innate immunity is fast, acting in minutes, and adaptive immunity is slow, taking days on a first infection, but the innate branch is general and the adaptive branch is specific, and the innate branch has no memory while the adaptive branch remembers for years. The innate branch is found in every animal, and the adaptive branch is found only in vertebrates, and the innate branch is built from barriers, phagocytes, peptides and complement, while the adaptive branch is built from B cells, T cells and antibodies. The innate branch is the first line, and the adaptive branch is the second line, and the second line cannot work without the first, because it is the innate cells that show the antigen to the lymphocytes, and that decide how strong the adaptive response will be.
| Feature | Innate immunity | Adaptive immunity |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Minutes to hours | Days on first exposure, hours on second |
| Specificity | General, recognises patterns shared by whole classes of invaders | Specific, recognises a single molecule on a single invader |
| Memory | None (except trained immunity, a short-lived priming) | Yes, memory cells live for years, sometimes for life |
| Found in | All animals, from sponges to humans | Vertebrates only; full form only in jawed vertebrates |
| Cells | Phagocytes, NK cells, granulocytes | B cells, T cells, plasma cells, memory cells |
| Molecules | Antimicrobial peptides, complement, lysozyme, cytokines | Antibodies, T-cell receptors, MHC molecules |
| Receptors | Built into the genome, the same in every individual | Assembled at random in each lymphocyte, millions of different forms |
| Improves with exposure | No | Yes, affinity maturation makes antibodies more precise |
The table makes the trade-off clear: the innate branch is fast and cheap, and the adaptive branch is slow and expensive, and the animal that has both pays the price of the adaptive branch, in the organs and the energy it requires, for the benefit of memory and specificity, and the animal that has only the innate branch pays no such price, and it survives, because the innate branch is enough, most of the time. The two branches are not two separate systems: they are one system, with two layers, and the layers were added at different times in evolution, the innate layer first, hundreds of millions of years ago, and the adaptive layer later, in the vertebrates, and the later layer was built on top of the earlier one, and it uses the earlier one to do its work.
When Immunity Goes Wrong: Autoimmunity and Allergy
The immune system must attack the foreign and spare the self, and when it fails, the result is disease, and the diseases are of two kinds: the immune system attacks the body, which is autoimmunity, or it attacks a harmless thing, which is allergy. Autoimmunity happens when the education of the lymphocytes fails, and a self-reactive cell escapes the thymus or the bone marrow, and it is activated, and it attacks the body's own tissues. The diseases are named for the tissue that is attacked: in type 1 diabetes, the T cells attack the insulin-making cells of the pancreas, and the animal can no longer make insulin; in multiple sclerosis, the immune system attacks the myelin that insulates the nerves, and the signals slow and fail; in rheumatoid arthritis, the immune system attacks the joints, and they swell and are destroyed. Autoimmunity is more common in some animals than in others, and it is often inherited, because the genes that control the education of the lymphocytes are inherited, and a defect in them lets more self-reactive cells escape. The treatment is to suppress the immune system, which stops the attack but leaves the animal vulnerable to infection, and the balance is the reason autoimmunity is so hard to treat: the system that is attacking the body is the same system that defends it.
Allergy is the opposite failure: the immune system attacks something harmless, a pollen grain, a food, a dust mite, as if it were a dangerous invader. The allergy is usually caused by IgE, the antibody that is meant to fight parasitic worms, and the IgE binds to the allergen, and it binds to the mast cells, which are the cells that carry histamine, and the mast cells release the histamine, and the histamine causes the itching, the swelling, the sneezing and the wheezing of an allergy. The IgE system is a defence against worms, and it is the reason the system exists, but when it is triggered by a pollen grain, it is a mistake, and the mistake is common, because the IgE system is easily triggered, and because the modern world, with its clean water and its lack of worms, leaves the system with nothing to do, and it turns on the harmless things instead. The hygiene hypothesis, which says that the lack of early exposure to microbes and parasites makes allergy more likely, is supported by the observation that allergy is rarer in animals that live in the countryside, and in children who grow up with animals, than in animals and children who live in clean cities.
Immunodeficiency is the third kind of failure: the immune system is too weak, and the animal cannot fight infection. It can be inherited, as in severe combined immunodeficiency, in which the animal has neither B cells nor T cells, and it dies of infection in its first year, unless it is kept in isolation, and it can be acquired, as in the feline immunodeficiency virus, which destroys the helper T cells of a cat, in the same way that HIV destroys the helper T cells of a human, and the cat becomes vulnerable to infections that a healthy cat would fight off easily. Immunodeficiency is also caused by stress, by malnutrition, and by age, and an animal that is stressed, or hungry, or old, is more likely to be infected, because its immune system is weaker, and the weakness is the reason the immune system is not only a matter of genes, but a matter of the animal's whole life, its food, its stress, and its age.
Extraordinary Immune Systems: Bats, Sharks and Axolotls
Some animals have immune systems that are extraordinary, even by the standards of a system that is already extraordinary, and three of them are worth knowing: the bat, the shark and the axolotl. Bats are the only mammals that fly, and they are the only mammals that can carry viruses that would kill other mammals, without being sick themselves, and the reason is their immune system. A bat's body temperature rises to more than forty degrees Celsius when it flies, which is a fever in any other mammal, and the heat would kill many viruses, and the bat's immune system is tuned to tolerate viruses rather than to attack them: it makes less inflammation than other mammals, and it has a different interferon system, which is always on, at a low level, so that the viruses are kept in check without the inflammation that would damage the bat's own tissues. The tolerance is the reason bats can carry coronaviruses, filoviruses and henipaviruses without being sick, and it is also the reason bats are a reservoir for viruses that can spill over into humans, where the same viruses cause severe disease, because the human immune system attacks them with inflammation, and the inflammation is what causes the damage. The bat's immune system is not stronger than a human's: it is different, and the difference is tolerance instead of attack.
Sharks are the oldest jawed vertebrates, and they have had an adaptive immune system for longer than any other animal, about four hundred and fifty million years, and their system is in some ways more sophisticated than a mammal's. A shark makes IgNAR, the single-chain antibody, which is the smallest antibody known, and which is so stable that it can survive in the blood for months, and which can bind to targets that a mammalian antibody cannot reach, because it is small enough to fit into the crevices of a protein. A shark also makes antibodies in large numbers, and it has a thymus and a spleen, and it has a special organ, the epigonal organ, that makes blood cells, and it has a system of memory, so that a shark that has been immunised once responds faster the second time. Sharks are also remarkably resistant to cancer, and they are resistant to infection, and they can heal wounds quickly, without infection, even in water that is full of bacteria, and the healing is partly due to their immune system, and partly due to the antimicrobial peptides in their skin. The shark is a reminder that the adaptive immune system is not a mammalian invention, but an ancient one, and that it has been refined for hundreds of millions of years in animals that are not mammals.
The axolotl, a salamander of Mexico that never grows up, is the third extraordinary case, and it is extraordinary for a different reason: it can regenerate, and its immune system is part of the reason. An axolotl can regrow a leg, a tail, a part of its heart, and even a part of its brain, and it does it without scarring, and the regeneration is controlled by the immune system: the macrophages that arrive at the wound do not cause inflammation, as they do in a mammal, but they signal the cells to regrow, and if the macrophages are removed, the axolotl cannot regenerate, and the wound heals with a scar instead. The axolotl's immune system is less inflammatory than a mammal's, and it is the lack of inflammation that lets the regeneration happen, because inflammation causes scarring, and scarring blocks regeneration. The axolotl is being studied for medicine, because if the secret of its regeneration can be found, it might be possible to make a human heal without scarring, and to regrow a damaged organ, and the secret, it turns out, is in the immune system, which is the system that decides whether a wound heals with a scar or with a new organ.
Immunity Across the Animal Kingdom
The table below brings the whole subject together, showing how each major group of animals defends itself, and it is worth reading as a summary of the article. The pattern is clear: every animal has barriers and phagocytes, and every animal has antimicrobial peptides, and the invertebrates stop there, with the addition of the phenoloxidase cascade in the arthropods, and the vertebrates add the complement system, and the jawed vertebrates add the adaptive system, with its B cells and T cells and antibodies, and the mammals add the most elaborate version of all, with five antibody classes and a thymus and lymph nodes. The pattern is also a history: the first animals defended themselves with cells that ate bacteria, the later animals added chemicals and cascades, and the vertebrates added a system that learns and remembers, and the history of immunity is the history of adding layer upon layer to a defence that began with a single cell eating a bacterium.
| Animal group | Barriers | Phagocytes | Antimicrobial peptides | Complement | Adaptive immunity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sponges | Water flow, mucus | Archaeocytes | Yes | No | No |
| Cnidarians | Mucus, stinging cells | Amoebocytes | Yes | Simple, complement-like | No |
| Flatworms | Mucus, skin | Neoblasts, phagocytes | Yes | No | No |
| Annelids (earthworms, leeches) | Moist skin, mucus | Coelomocytes | Yes | Complement-like | No |
| Molluscs | Shell, mucus | Haemocytes | Yes | Yes, simple | No |
| Arthropods (insects, crabs) | Chitin cuticle | Haemocytes | Yes, many kinds | Yes, simple | No, but phenoloxidase cascade and encapsulation |
| Jawless fish | Skin, mucus, scales | Macrophages, neutrophils | Yes | Yes | Yes, VLR system (no antibodies) |
| Cartilaginous fish | Skin, mucus, denticles | Macrophages, neutrophils | Yes | Yes | Yes, IgM and IgNAR |
| Bony fish | Skin, mucus, scales | Macrophages, neutrophils | Yes | Yes | Yes, IgM and IgT |
| Amphibians | Moist skin, mucus, antimicrobial peptides | Macrophages, neutrophils | Yes, magainins | Yes | Yes, IgM, IgY, IgX |
| Reptiles | Scales, dry skin | Macrophages, heterophils | Yes | Yes | Yes, IgM, IgY, IgA |
| Birds | Feathers, skin, mucus | Macrophages, heterophils | Yes | Yes | Yes, IgM, IgY, IgA; bursa of Fabricius |
| Mammals | Skin, mucus, acid, tears | Macrophages, neutrophils | Yes, cathelicidins, defensins | Yes, full system | Yes, five antibody classes, thymus, lymph nodes |
Key Takeaways
- Immunity is the ability to recognise what belongs to the body and to destroy what does not, and every animal has it, from a sponge to a human.
- The immune system works in layers: barriers first, then the innate branch, then the adaptive branch, and each layer catches what the one before it missed.
- Innate immunity is fast, general and without memory, and it is found in every animal, while adaptive immunity is slow, specific and remembers, and it is found only in vertebrates.
- Phagocytosis, the eating of invaders by cells, is the oldest form of immunity, and it is found in every animal, from the archaeocytes of a sponge to the macrophages of a mammal.
- Antimicrobial peptides kill bacteria by punching holes in their membranes, and they are made by almost every animal, from insects to humans.
- The complement system is a cascade of proteins in the blood that coats bacteria, calls the white blood cells, and punches holes in bacterial membranes.
- Inflammation is redness, heat, swelling and pain, and it is the sign that the immune system is working, and it must be controlled, because it can damage the body's own tissues.
- Natural killer cells kill the cells that have lost their MHC class I identity card, which is how they catch the cells that viruses and cancers try to hide.
- Invertebrates have no antibodies, but they have a rich innate immunity, including the phenoloxidase cascade of insects, which melanises and kills invaders.
- Jawless fish have an adaptive immune system built from VLRs, not antibodies, which proves that adaptive immunity evolved twice, independently.
- Jawed vertebrates have B cells and T cells, and the B cells make antibodies, and the T cells kill infected cells and coordinate the response.
- Antibody classes were added one by one in evolution: IgM is the oldest and is found in every jawed vertebrate, and mammals have five classes, the most elaborate set.
- Humoral immunity is carried by antibodies in the fluids, and cell-mediated immunity is carried by T cells, and the two arms fight different kinds of invader.
- Immune memory is carried by memory cells, and it is the reason the second infection is met faster and harder than the first, and it is the reason vaccines work.
- Passive immunity is given, not made: a mammal passes antibodies in its milk, a bird passes them into the yolk of its egg, and the young are protected until they can make their own.
- The immune organs are the bone marrow and the thymus, where lymphocytes are made and educated, and the lymph nodes, the spleen and the MALT, where they meet the invaders.
- Autoimmunity is the immune system attacking the body, allergy is the immune system attacking a harmless thing, and immunodeficiency is the immune system being too weak.
- Bats tolerate viruses instead of attacking them, sharks make the smallest antibody known, and axolotls regenerate because their immune system does not cause scarring.
- A single plasma cell can make about two thousand antibody molecules a second, and a human makes about a hundred billion neutrophils a day.
- The history of immunity is the history of adding layer upon layer to a defence that began with a single cell eating a bacterium.
Short Questions
1. What is the difference between innate and adaptive immunity?
See answer
Innate immunity is the branch an animal is born with: it is fast, acting within minutes of an invasion, it is general, attacking anything that looks foreign without needing to know exactly what it is, and it has no memory, so it fights the hundredth infection exactly as it fought the first, and it is found in every animal, from a sponge to a human. Adaptive immunity is the branch an animal learns: it is slow, taking days to reach full strength on a first infection, it is specific, recognising a single molecule on a single invader, and it remembers, so that the second infection is met in hours by cells and antibodies that were made for it, and it is found only in vertebrates, in its full form only in jawed vertebrates. The two branches are partners, not rivals: the innate cells show the antigen to the lymphocytes and decide how strong the adaptive response will be, and the adaptive cells, once made, direct the innate cells to fight harder.
2. How does phagocytosis work?
See answer
Phagocytosis is the process by which a cell eats an invader: the phagocyte flows around a bacterium, engulfs it in a pocket of its own membrane, and digests it inside a vesicle called a phagosome, into which it pours acid, enzymes and toxic chemicals, including hydrogen peroxide and other reactive oxygen species, until the bacterium is destroyed. The process was first described by Élie Metchnikoff in the 1880s, who watched the cells of a starfish larva gather around a thorn, and it won him the Nobel Prize in 1908. Every animal has phagocytes: a sponge has archaeocytes, an earthworm has coelomocytes, an insect has haemocytes, and a mammal has macrophages and neutrophils, and a single macrophage can eat a hundred bacteria in its lifetime, and a human body contains billions of them.
3. What are antibodies?
See answer
An antibody is a Y-shaped molecule, made of four chains of protein, two heavy chains and two light chains, and the tips of the Y bind to a single antigen with great precision, while the stem of the Y tells the rest of the immune system what to do. Once an antibody has bound, its stem can activate the complement system, and it can be recognised by the receptors on phagocytes, which eat the antibody-coated invader far more eagerly, and by the NK cells, which kill the antibody-coated cell. Antibodies are made by B cells and plasma cells, and a single plasma cell can make about two thousand antibody molecules a second, and the antibodies neutralise viruses and toxins, opsonise bacteria, activate the complement, and clump bacteria together so that they are easier to eat.
4. Why do jawless fish not have antibodies?
See answer
Jawless fish, the lampreys and hagfish, do not have antibodies because they do not have the genes that make them, the RAG genes, which rearrange the antibody genes in a jawed vertebrate, and because their lineage split from the jawed vertebrates before antibodies evolved. Instead they have an adaptive immune system built from completely different molecules, the variable lymphocyte receptors, or VLRs, which are built from leucine-rich repeats and assembled by gene conversion, and which are as diverse as antibodies, with millions of different forms. The VLR system has two kinds of lymphocytes, one that secretes VLRB into the blood like an antibody, and one that carries VLRA on its surface like a T-cell receptor, and it is a complete adaptive immune system, with recognition, memory and specificity, which proves that adaptive immunity evolved twice, independently, once in the jawless fish and once in the jawed vertebrates.
5. What is immune memory?
See answer
Immune memory is the ability of the adaptive immune system to remember an invader it has met before, and to respond to it faster and more strongly the second time. When a lymphocyte meets its antigen for the first time, it divides and makes effector cells, which fight the infection, and memory cells, which live for years, sometimes for a lifetime, and which wait for the invader to return. The memory cells are more numerous than the naive cells were, and they are quicker to respond, and they need less stimulation to be activated, so that the second infection is met in hours, by cells and antibodies that were made for it, while the first infection took days. The memory is the reason a vaccine works: a vaccine is a harmless form of the invader, given so that the body makes memory cells without ever having the disease, and when the real invader arrives, the memory cells are ready.
6. How does inflammation help fight infection?
See answer
Inflammation helps fight infection by bringing the defences to the site of the invasion: the chemical messengers released by the injured tissue widen the blood vessels, so that more blood flows to the area, and make the vessel walls leaky, so that fluid and white blood cells escape into the tissue, and call the neutrophils and macrophages to the site by a chemical trail, and sensitise the nerve endings, which is the pain that makes the animal protect the injured part. The neutrophils eat the bacteria, the macrophages eat the bacteria and the dead cells, and the complement proteins in the fluid coat the bacteria and punch holes in them, and the swelling and the heat are the signs that the blood and the cells have arrived. Inflammation must be controlled, because the same chemicals that kill bacteria can damage the body's own tissues, and the body switches it off with anti-inflammatory cytokines as the infection is cleared, and the tissue then repairs itself.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the immune system in animals?
The immune system in animals is the network of barriers, cells, molecules and organs that recognises what belongs to the body and destroys what does not. It works in layers: the skin and mucus keep most invaders out, the innate branch, phagocytes, antimicrobial peptides, the complement system and natural killer cells, attacks anything foreign within minutes, and the adaptive branch, found only in vertebrates, learns each invader and remembers it, so the second infection is stopped faster. Every animal has an innate immune system, from a sponge to a human, and only jawed vertebrates have the full adaptive system with B cells, T cells and antibodies.
How do invertebrates fight infection without antibodies?
Invertebrates fight infection with an entirely innate immune system: barriers such as the chitin cuticle of insects and the shell of a mollusc, phagocytes that eat bacteria, antimicrobial peptides that punch holes in bacterial membranes, and, in arthropods, the phenoloxidase cascade, which coats invaders in melanin and kills them. Insects also encapsulate large parasites, surrounding them with layers of haemocytes. They have no memory cells and no antibodies, so they fight every infection as if it were the first, but the system is fast, broad and effective, and invertebrates are the most numerous animals on Earth.
What is the difference between humoral and cell-mediated immunity?
Humoral immunity is carried by antibodies in the blood and other fluids, made by B cells, and it fights invaders outside cells, such as bacteria in the blood and toxins in the tissues, by neutralising them, coating them for phagocytes, and activating the complement system. Cell-mediated immunity is carried by T cells, and it fights invaders inside cells, such as viruses that have already entered a cell and cancerous cells, by killing the infected cell directly. The two arms are coordinated by helper T cells, and most infections are fought by both, at different stages.
How do vaccines work in animals?
A vaccine is a harmless form of an invader, a killed virus, a weakened bacterium, or a piece of the invader's protein, given to an animal so that its immune system makes memory cells against it without ever having the disease. When the real invader arrives, the memory B cells make antibodies in days and the memory T cells kill infected cells in hours, and the infection is stopped before it causes symptoms. Vaccination is used in animals as well as in humans: dogs are vaccinated against rabies and distemper, cattle against foot-and-mouth disease, chickens against Newcastle disease, and fish against bacterial infections.
What are antibodies, and which animals have them?
An antibody is a Y-shaped molecule made by B cells that binds to a single antigen with great precision, and its stem then activates the complement system and marks the invader for phagocytes and natural killer cells. Antibodies exist only in jawed vertebrates: cartilaginous fish have IgM and the single-chain IgNAR, bony fish have IgM and IgT, amphibians have IgM, IgY and IgX, reptiles and birds have IgM, IgY and IgA, and mammals have five classes, IgM, IgG, IgA, IgE and IgD. Jawless fish have no antibodies at all; they use variable lymphocyte receptors, or VLRs, instead.
Why do bats carry viruses without getting sick?
Bats tolerate viruses instead of attacking them with full force. When a bat flies, its body temperature rises above forty degrees Celsius, which is a fever in other mammals, and its immune system is tuned to keep viruses in check with a low level of interferon that is always on, while making less inflammation than other mammals. The low inflammation means the bat's own tissues are not damaged, so the bat stays healthy while carrying coronaviruses, filoviruses and henipaviruses. In humans the same viruses trigger strong inflammation, and the inflammation is what causes the severe disease.
Related reading
MCQs
1. Which white blood cells are the first to arrive at a site of infection?
- A. Lymphocytes
- B. Macrophages
- C. Neutrophils
- D. Eosinophils
Answer: C
Explanation: Neutrophils are the most numerous white blood cells, making up about sixty percent of the white cells in human blood, and they are the first to arrive at an infection, leaving the blood, squeezing through the capillary walls, and crawling toward the bacteria, and they eat the bacteria and then die, and the pus in a wound is mostly dead neutrophils.
2. How do antimicrobial peptides kill bacteria?
- A. By punching holes in the bacterial membrane
- B. By blocking the bacterium's DNA
- C. By starving the bacterium of oxygen
- D. By dissolving the bacterial nucleus
Answer: A
Explanation: Antimicrobial peptides carry a positive charge, are attracted to the negatively charged surface of a bacterial cell, insert themselves into the bacterial membrane and punch holes in it, so that the bacterium leaks and dies, and bacteria find it hard to become resistant, because resistance would require rebuilding the whole bacterial membrane.
3. What is the membrane attack complex?
- A. A group of antibodies that surrounds a virus
- B. A net of DNA released by a neutrophil
- C. A clot that seals a wound in an insect
- D. A ring of complement proteins that punches a hole in a bacterial membrane
Answer: D
Explanation: The membrane attack complex is the last step of the complement cascade: five different proteins join together to form a ring about ten nanometres across that punches a hole in the bacterial membrane, so that the bacterium leaks and dies, without any cell being involved.
4. Which animal group has an adaptive immune system built from VLRs instead of antibodies?
- A. Cartilaginous fish
- B. Jawless fish
- C. Bony fish
- D. Amphibians
Answer: B
Explanation: Jawless fish, the lampreys and hagfish, have no antibodies and no RAG genes, and instead their lymphocytes make variable lymphocyte receptors, or VLRs, built from leucine-rich repeats, with VLRB secreted into the blood like an antibody and VLRA on the cell surface like a T-cell receptor, which proves that adaptive immunity evolved twice, independently.
5. Which antibody class is secreted into mucus, tears, saliva and milk?
- A. IgA
- B. IgG
- C. IgM
- D. IgE
Answer: A
Explanation: IgA is the antibody of the mucosal surfaces: it is secreted into the mucus, the tears, the saliva and the milk, and it guards the surfaces of the body, and it is the most abundant antibody made by the body, because the surfaces are the largest part of the body that meets the outside world.
6. What is the main job of helper T cells?
- A. To eat bacteria directly
- B. To make antibodies themselves
- C. To kill infected cells with perforin
- D. To coordinate the response by releasing cytokines
Answer: D
Explanation: Helper T cells, the CD4 T cells, do not kill and do not make antibodies: they recognise a fragment of the antigen presented on MHC class II and release cytokines, which tell the B cells to make antibodies, tell the macrophages to eat more eagerly, and tell the cytotoxic T cells to kill more effectively, and they are the coordinators of the adaptive response.
7. Why is a second infection with the same invader usually milder than the first?
- A. The invader becomes weaker over time
- B. The skin becomes thicker after the first infection
- C. Memory cells respond faster and more strongly
- D. The innate immune system learns the invader
Answer: C
Explanation: After a first infection, memory B cells and memory T cells remain, and they are more numerous than the naive cells were, and quicker to respond, and need less stimulation to be activated, so the second infection is met in hours by cells and antibodies that were made for it, while the first infection took days.
8. What does the phenoloxidase cascade of insects produce?
- A. Antibodies
- B. Melanin
- C. Histamine
- D. Interferon
Answer: B
Explanation: The phenoloxidase cascade is a chain reaction in insect blood that ends with the enzyme phenoloxidase making melanin from the amino acid tyrosine, and the melanin is deposited around the invader, hardens, traps it, and the quinones made on the way are toxic and kill the invader directly.
9. In which organ are T cells educated?
- A. The thymus
- B. The spleen
- C. The bone marrow
- D. The bursa of Fabricius
Answer: A
Explanation: T cells are made in the bone marrow and educated in the thymus, where they are tested in positive selection, which checks that they can recognise MHC at all, and in negative selection, which kills the ones that bind to the body's own molecules, and only about two percent of the T cells that enter the thymus survive it.
10. Why can bats carry viruses that would kill other mammals without being sick themselves?
- A. Bats have no immune system at all
- B. Bats make far more antibodies than other mammals
- C. Bats are never exposed to viruses in the wild
- D. Their immune system tolerates viruses with less inflammation
Answer: D
Explanation: A bat's immune system is tuned to tolerate viruses rather than attack them: it keeps a low level of interferon always on, and it makes less inflammation than other mammals, so the viruses are kept in check without the inflammation that would damage the bat's own tissues, while in humans the same viruses trigger strong inflammation, and the inflammation is what causes the severe disease.






Comments
Leave a comment